My Cookie Dealer Pop-Up
501 Tanger Mall Dr, Riverhead
(631) 591-0688
Customers' Favorites
Stuffed Cookies
Funfetti
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I have ordered from here twice now, and my family and I all agree that these cookies are amazing! They're full of flavor and so good when you warm them! 10/10 recommend to anyone, not only do they taste great they're reasonably priced.
Saw the sign for My Cookie Dealer and just had to try. It definitely did not disappoint!! The service was great, and the cookies were amazing. Will definitely be back to try other flavors!!
I honestly don’t get the low reviews, this place is top tier. I’ve been driving up from the city every now and then for the past four years just for these cookies, and they never disappoint. They’re A1, every single time.
I do miss some of the original flavors I got hooked on, but I respect the creativity and variety they’re constantly bringing with the new drops. I’ve tried a ton of them and they’ve all been fire. Whether you eat them fresh and...
I do miss some of the original flavors I got hooked on, but I respect the creativity and variety they’re constantly bringing with the new drops. I’ve tried a ton of them and they’ve all been fire. Whether you eat them fresh and...
You May Also Like
Cafe Victoria and Market - 205 Tanger Mall Dr
![]()
Coffee, Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
The Preston Hotel - 428 E Main St
![]()
Pet Friendly, New American, Bar, Vegetarian
Bistro 72 - 1830 W Main St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, New American, Vegan, Vegetarian