I had my wedding here October 2022. We heard such great things about this restaurant and felt excited to have our wedding here on the beautiful property. However, there's a few things that we really wanted them to know for future weddings. Unfortunately, they did not respond to our 3 phone calls or my email to discuss the issues that we wanted to bring to light. I am posting a review now because I happened to see this restaurant pop up on my yelp page. Hopefully they have made improvements since my wedding but I will never return or recommend due to being ignored. The wedding just felt unorganized and here are some reasons why: -The office space they gave me to get ready with my mom and sisters was full of spackle buckets and other construction type materials which I had to move out of the way myself even though they said they would move it when I was there the day before. -The table linens were blue when I first arrived and had to ask them to change them to the off-white color we selected with the manager. -It was a rainy day, so we had a rain plan for the ceremony where if it was raining we will hold the ceremony inside as back up. Lucky for us it stopped raining about an hour before the ceremony! So we asked for it to be held outside (as originally planned). We only had around 20 chairs bc the woman in charge said not to bring out mismatched chairs (I don't know why they didn't have 40 matching chairs since they've done weddings here before). So my husband had to tell them please bring out more even though they don't match so that our guests could sit. -We wanted the dance floor and DJ set up on the patio as discussed but we were told the heaters wouldn't help with the cold temperature which seemed odd to us because we were told the patio would have heaters. So it was set up inside next to the bar. -Food was being served much longer than discussed; until about 8:30pm. Due to this we had to extended our time with the photographer and rush the parent dances and cake cutting. -The female server with very short hair came off as a bit rude towards my husband and myself in separate instances which I will not go into detail over because we can let it go, but the things that bothered me most about her is that she complained about us to our guests! One of her complaints was to a family member who traveled from another state whom we are not close with saying that "nobody in the bridal party had answers to her questions" but we didn't even have a bridal party... she should have asked me or my husband her questions. She also complained to another family member that she had to wake up early to serve us brunch (which wasn't true, we did not book them for any brunch) this started confusion as to why we didn't invite certain people to our brunch (which we weren't having) and I had to let my family know nobody was excluded and that we were not having any brunch. This makes me wonder what she might have said to other guests. Again, this is a long overdue review and hopefully they have made improvements since October 2022, but I feel my review should still be done due to the way they ignored our phone calls and emails.
Jim B
Nice restaurant with a bar on the golf course. We had burgers at the bar, the bartender was very friendly, food was good with lots of options to go on your burger.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Brooklyn Girl New York
Waited forever to get service. Staff was bringing pretzel with dinner instead of prior. Great outdoors but t he food sucks and service staff untrained.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ali Jak
My visit was to attend a non-golfing NAACP sponsored event. The employees were very courteous and responsive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Carol G.
We recently held a family reunion at Stonewalls. Although we wanted to be outdoors, they placed the 30 of us inside as it was very hot. Many of the guests were happy about that! Those that wanted to go outdoors walked through the beautiful gardens where many of us took photos. My guests could not stop commenting on how fabulous the food was! The salmon, the chicken piccata, the pasta primavera......everything was delicious! My personal favorite was the beet salad which I'm so glad Alisha recommended. To top off the wonderful buffet, the strawberry shortcake was the best I've ever had. The chef imports his flour from France and other ingredients from Italy to make the tastiest, lightest cake! Our server (I neglected to get her name) was excellent! She had a lot to do to keep up with this crowd! I especially appreciated her patience trying to serve beverages when everyone was milling around and socializing. Lastly, there was such an abundance of food, that I asked if I could take leftovers home. They wrapped and boxed everything up and we ate it for days!! I highly recommend Stonewalls for a gathering!!
Joal Savino
New chef is very good. Great atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Pear, Atlantic Swordfish Saute Belle
PATRICIA FERRARI
What a beautiful place and food was amazing.
Evan proios
Amazing restaurant great golf
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Antoinette Merenda Carbone
This place has not recaptured its status that it had as a 5* restaurant under Chef Guy over ten years ago. Have been back quite a few times and have been disappointed most of the time. Today I ordered the special. Salmon cake on brioche bun with sweet potato fries. More brioche than salmon cake. Thin stringy fries. Forget this one. Oscar their star employee is no longer there. There are better places here in Riverhead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
phil cimmino
Had my sons rehearsal dinner and welcome drinks for 100 people. Top notch service and food in a great venue
Celebrate a Saturday afternoon luncheon. Quiet, the food was great. Server was spunky!Dietary restrictions: Needs other gluten-free choices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Michelle L.
Came here for the first time, based off google reviews of 4.5 and took the chance to try a new place for our wedding anniversary dinner. It was Prime Rib special. We both went with this. Everything we had was delish! From the appetizer, down to the desert. Staff were attentive and a pleasure. Looking forward to our next trip there.
Rich Reinken
We recently hosted a birthday party for 45 guests at Stonewalls. It was a grand success. Food was excellent and service was solid. It was a pleasure working with the restaurant manager, Alisha. She helped us plan out every aspect of the party, was very responsive, and the event went off without a hitch. Everyone had a great time.
Sarah G.
I've been to Stonewalls several times - there is an outdoor patio that overlooks the golf course with numerous fans on a hot day and 2 dining rooms indoors. Plenty of space for a big group or seating where you don't have to be on top of other people. And for those in need they have high chairs too! No matter what we have tried it has been good/a super reliable option for lunch or dinner.
Corinn Halsey
All of us agreed there was way too much salt on all the food. Couldn’t even finish our meals.
I had my wedding here October 2022. We heard such great things about this restaurant and felt excited to have our wedding here on the beautiful property. However, there's a few things that we really wanted them to know for future weddings. Unfortunately, they did not respond to our 3 phone calls or my email to discuss the issues that we wanted to bring to light. I am posting a review now because I happened to see this restaurant pop up on my yelp page. Hopefully they have made improvements since my wedding but I will never return or recommend due to being ignored. The wedding just felt unorganized and here are some reasons why: -The office space they gave me to get ready with my mom and sisters was full of spackle buckets and other construction type materials which I had to move out of the way myself even though they said they would move it when I was there the day before. -The table linens were blue when I first arrived and had to ask them to change them to the off-white color we selected with the manager. -It was a rainy day, so we had a rain plan for the ceremony where if it was raining we will hold the ceremony inside as back up. Lucky for us it stopped raining about an hour before the ceremony! So we asked for it to be held outside (as originally planned). We only had around 20 chairs bc the woman in charge said not to bring out mismatched chairs (I don't know why they didn't have 40 matching chairs since they've done weddings here before). So my husband had to tell them please bring out more even though they don't match so that our guests could sit. -We wanted the dance floor and DJ set up on the patio as discussed but we were told the heaters wouldn't help with the cold temperature which seemed odd to us because we were told the patio would have heaters. So it was set up inside next to the bar. -Food was being served much longer than discussed; until about 8:30pm. Due to this we had to extended our time with the photographer and rush the parent dances and cake cutting. -The female server with very short hair came off as a bit rude towards my husband and myself in separate instances which I will not go into detail over because we can let it go, but the things that bothered me most about her is that she complained about us to our guests! One of her complaints was to a family member who traveled from another state whom we are not close with saying that "nobody in the bridal party had answers to her questions" but we didn't even have a bridal party... she should have asked me or my husband her questions. She also complained to another family member that she had to wake up early to serve us brunch (which wasn't true, we did not book them for any brunch) this started confusion as to why we didn't invite certain people to our brunch (which we weren't having) and I had to let my family know nobody was excluded and that we were not having any brunch. This makes me wonder what she might have said to other guests. Again, this is a long overdue review and hopefully they have made improvements since October 2022, but I feel my review should still be done due to the way they ignored our phone calls and emails.
Nice restaurant with a bar on the golf course. We had burgers at the bar, the bartender was very friendly, food was good with lots of options to go on your burger.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Waited forever to get service. Staff was bringing pretzel with dinner instead of prior. Great outdoors but t he food sucks and service staff untrained.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
My visit was to attend a non-golfing NAACP sponsored event. The employees were very courteous and responsive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
We recently held a family reunion at Stonewalls. Although we wanted to be outdoors, they placed the 30 of us inside as it was very hot. Many of the guests were happy about that! Those that wanted to go outdoors walked through the beautiful gardens where many of us took photos. My guests could not stop commenting on how fabulous the food was! The salmon, the chicken piccata, the pasta primavera......everything was delicious! My personal favorite was the beet salad which I'm so glad Alisha recommended. To top off the wonderful buffet, the strawberry shortcake was the best I've ever had. The chef imports his flour from France and other ingredients from Italy to make the tastiest, lightest cake! Our server (I neglected to get her name) was excellent! She had a lot to do to keep up with this crowd! I especially appreciated her patience trying to serve beverages when everyone was milling around and socializing. Lastly, there was such an abundance of food, that I asked if I could take leftovers home. They wrapped and boxed everything up and we ate it for days!! I highly recommend Stonewalls for a gathering!!
New chef is very good. Great atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Pear, Atlantic Swordfish Saute Belle
What a beautiful place and food was amazing.
Amazing restaurant great golf
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has not recaptured its status that it had as a 5* restaurant under Chef Guy over ten years ago. Have been back quite a few times and have been disappointed most of the time. Today I ordered the special. Salmon cake on brioche bun with sweet potato fries. More brioche than salmon cake. Thin stringy fries. Forget this one. Oscar their star employee is no longer there. There are better places here in Riverhead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Had my sons rehearsal dinner and welcome drinks for 100 people. Top notch service and food in a great venue
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Celebrate a Saturday afternoon luncheon. Quiet, the food was great. Server was spunky!Dietary restrictions: Needs other gluten-free choices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Came here for the first time, based off google reviews of 4.5 and took the chance to try a new place for our wedding anniversary dinner. It was Prime Rib special. We both went with this. Everything we had was delish! From the appetizer, down to the desert. Staff were attentive and a pleasure. Looking forward to our next trip there.
We recently hosted a birthday party for 45 guests at Stonewalls. It was a grand success. Food was excellent and service was solid. It was a pleasure working with the restaurant manager, Alisha. She helped us plan out every aspect of the party, was very responsive, and the event went off without a hitch. Everyone had a great time.
I've been to Stonewalls several times - there is an outdoor patio that overlooks the golf course with numerous fans on a hot day and 2 dining rooms indoors. Plenty of space for a big group or seating where you don't have to be on top of other people. And for those in need they have high chairs too! No matter what we have tried it has been good/a super reliable option for lunch or dinner.
All of us agreed there was way too much salt on all the food. Couldn’t even finish our meals.