Paesan's Pizza

2513 Guilderland Ave, Rotterdam
(518) 631-6236

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matthew Kessler

Hey owner, stop being chronically online and focus on actually making good pizza!

Matthew McDowell

Great gluten free pizza

Nick Cavallaro

This is based on the location in the Schenectady/ Rotterdam location. The employees are usually not very friendly during pickup. A lot of people rave about the pizza but I think it’s so-so from this location. The frozen pizza Paesan’s sell at the grocery store I think tastes better than here. Can’t wait to be called a “Stunad” on Facebook for the review lol It is what it is.

Pasquale

They are charging $1 for a cup of tap water. Claims he pays a lot for cups.. BUT Coca Cola and sprite give FREE paper cups if they serve there products in the restaurant. Wouldn’t walk in that place even if they paid me to. Disgusting business practices!!

UPDATE, no fake review buddy, honest review. Video is the proof.. how can this be a fake review with your own face saying you’re charging for water? Fake Italian food is what you’re serving, You’re not even an Italian yourself.:: chicken parm 🤮. Who’s the stunad now ?go take a trip to Italy with that chicken parm and see what your ancestors will say to you.

Kevin S

Best pizza around.
Finally a place that uses sliced sausage instead of crumbles.
Not the cheapest, but you get what you pay for.

alphonso cino

This is a pretty nice building and the service is fine enough. The food is just always mediocre at best.

Alice Martinez

The food was fantastic 😋, david got me the chicken vodka pizza 🍕 with sesame seed crust (which i never had or knew it was a thing) IT WAS DELICIOUS 😋 😀 wings were great Italian sandwich was great cookies
🍪 were great , when we come this way again will be ordering again and again, thank you 😊 was very appreciated

Rachel Anigian

This place used to be great when I was a kid, now you got some bespectacled idiot running it at the front having people wait 15 extra minutes on top of the pick up time, and rudely ask me to move over while waiting for my pick up. Now I realize why people don’t come here like they used to!

Synthia Rebidue

Ordered chicken marsala pizza and garlic parm chicken wings and both were amazing. Chicken wings were cooked perfectly, and tasted alot better than I remember in the past. Definitely my go to place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon

Imagine owning a legit pizza place, and being ok with shipping “Kens blue cheese dressing” out as your blue cheese for your wings….embarrassing

It really shows a complete lack of care for quality. Disgusting sauce. NOT blue cheese at all. They demoted the sacred blue cheese to a throwaway condiment. Sad.

The pizza and wings are good here, just don’t expect to get the all important blue cheese with your wings. It’s white ketchup sauce.

Food: 3

Service: 3

Bonnie Choy

Hands down the best wings we've ever had! Prompt delivery and piping hot! Perfect flavor and plump and moist. So, so good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Bryant

I’ve been going here for 8 years and still going strong. Love these guys for pizza and wings, salads, and chicken parm. There’s been one time ever that they forgot to deliver an item, but they made it right immediately by bringing that item right over and the driver wouldn’t even accept a tip for the extra trip over. Thanks Paesan’s for being my tried and true pizza takeout spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Holly Lyons

Best pizza place in the capital region. The pizza is delicious, and they have a gluten free pizza that is also delicious! Other menu options are yummy, and there's no problem with substitutions. The staff are super friendly. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Chicken Wings, Sausage Peppers & Onions Roll, Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza

Desiree Ghisolfi

I’m from NYC and their pizza is some of the best up here. Love Paesan’s

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anna Bal

I ordered a large pizza and requested my veggies to be cooked separately and sliced very small and that's exactly what I got! The pizza was really friggin good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...