Noble Pies Bakery & Cafe

I just had the most delicious quiche ever !! The Brussel Sprout and Bacon is to die for! and the Key Lime was just right for dessert. Run... don't walk !

I placed an online order, paid, and received an email confirmation with an order number. Then they don’t have record of the order when I arrive to pick it up. They don’t have anything I ordered in the store either. I was told “sorry for the mix up” Sorry? Mix up? I have a party and no dessert or vegetable now. Plus I have to deal with following up to make sure my credit card is credited since they weren’t sure how to credit it.

Service: 1

This is a superb spot for pie, certainly the best in the area

I special ordered a curry vegetable pie and key lime pie for pick up at Rye. I called the Warwick store to place the order. I reconfirmed by phone and email and received an email confirmation that I was charged. Despite all these actions , the pies were not delivered to the Rye Store. When I went to pick them up there was no explanation. We had to go to another bakery in Pleasantville to obtain replacements for our order.
However, Zach the owner reached out to me and apologized for the error. He delivered the pies and a couple of extra treats the next week. All the pies were delicious. The mini Apple pie was outstanding. It is obvious he takes pride in his product and want to provide excellent service. He has informed me that he will be retraining the staff so that everyone will hopefully get their pies at the right day and time!

Food: 5

Service: 2

Cute little spot surrounded by green trees. We stopped by to get a pie. Had a slice of peach pie. It was pretty amazing. It was our first time there. And i understood that they are specializing on pies. I haven't seen anything else on display, like muffins or croissants. But it was enough for us to select from. And also they do coffees. The place itself has very comfortable sitting. The only thing i would add is ambient music.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Key lime pie with no cream , broken crust no lime decoration. I could have made this myself, it wasnt that tasty either. Not worth the exorbitant cost.

Recently tried the apple crumb and chocolate cream and they were absolutely delicious. Service was great. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped in for our first Noble Pie and found the cherry pie to be phenomenal! It’s hard to find a good cherry pie. The balance between sweet and sour, the freshness of the cherries and the crumbly bits of crust really make for a memorable treat. We had a nice chat with the person working the register. We will be back for more!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Unbelievably good quiche

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The two cookies were full of mold. This is disrespectful and dishonest.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Very gud

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hudson Valley Apple Pie

Delicious blueberry pie! The bakery offers savory and sweet options - fresh ones and also takeouts that you can store/freeze for later. Cashier was very friendly and helpful; taking thorough time to explain options and make recommendation. Have not tried savory option yet but look forward to it!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charming pie shop / bakery. Found the flavored lattes to be really good as they make their own syrups. Got the pumpkin syrup with real pumpkin. Staff is very friendly too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A truly inspiring space.

Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there.When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks).The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega.As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies.Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.