Old Stove Pub

3516 Montauk Hwy, Sagaponack
(631) 537-3300

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Pan Roasted Atlantic Salmon with Organic Lentils
Sagaponack Steak for 2
Iceberg Wedge Salad
Local Sea Scallops
Stuffed Eggplant
Steamed Mussels
Flank Steak
Skirt Steak
Fish

Menu

Starters
Old Stove Trio Dips
Babaganoush, tzatziki, hummus served with warm pita.
Saganaki
A Greek cheese baked in casserole with olive oil and lemon.
Truffle Burrata
Roasted Peppers, Frisee and Balsamic Glaze.
Iceberg Wedge Salad
Blue cheese and feta dressing, red onion, bacon, and scallion.
House Cesare Salad
Crisp romaine, home made dressing, and shaved Parmesan.
Classic Greek Salad
Heirloom tomatoes, vine ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, olives, bell peppers, feta, white balsamic vinaigrette.
Zucchini Spirals
Very light and thin flash fried served with a spinach tzatziki.
Steamed Mussels
Mussels with white wine, garlic, cherry tomatoes, and shallots.
Calamari
Lightly fried calamari served with chipotle mayo.
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Baked jumbo crab with pea shoot salad, whole grain mustard.
Traditional Onion Soup
Roasted Peppers, Frisee and Balsamic Glaze
Roasted Beet Salad
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
3 Jumbo shrimp, frisee salad served with mustard mayo and cocktail sauce.
Tuna tartare
Sushi Quality Grade A Tuna, Wasabi Avocado, Sesame Oil, Sesame seeds, Soy sauce and diced mango

Entrees
Stuffed Eggplant
Basmati rice, lentils, zucchini, tomato, feta, tzatziki, and tahini. Vegetarian.
Baby Back Ribs
Half rack with house coleslaw.
Half Roasted Chicken
Broccoli rabe, roasted fingerling potatoes.
Pan Roasted Atlantic Salmon
Organic lentils, baby spinach, and whole grain mustard cream.
Sea Scallops
Lemon butter, shaved brussel sprouts, cauliflower puree.
Jumbo Prawns
White wine, garlic, with a little spice, served with basmati rice pilaf.
Fresh Branzino
Sauteed with lemon, capers, and baby cherry tomatoes.
Skirt Steak
House marinade.
Australian Lamb Chops
Prime Filet Mignon
Tenderloin. 10 oz.
Rib-Eye Boneless
Prime with blue cheese butter 12 oz.
Sagaponack Steak
20 oz. prime dry-aged beef strip-loin. For 2 person.
Tomahawk Steak
40 oz. prime dry-aged rib-eye with the bone. For 2 person.

Sides
Cauliflower Gratin
Sauteed Brussel Sprout
Cooked in oil or fat over heat.
Potatoes a la Old Stove
Creamed Spinach
French Fries
Fried potatoes.
Sauteed Spinach
Sauteed Mushroom
Mashed Potatoe

Sauces
Au Poivre
Red Wine Demi Glaze

Sushi starters
Tunacho
Lean tuna, wonton chips, seaweed salad, beni shoga, shredded ginger, togarashi spice, eel sauce, kewpie mayo and scallion
Yellowtail Jalapeno
Yellowtail topped with sliced jalapeno Sriracha sauce and wasabi yuzu
Tuna Tataki
Seared sliced pepper tuna with wasabi yuzu, tobiko and scallion.
Yuzu white tuna tataki
Torched sliced white tuna topped with zuke ginger, umam, tobiko, scallion and wasabi yuzu.
Dragon Ball
Avocado wrapped around spicy shrimp, crab stick, eel sauce and lemon yuzu mayo
Regular rolls - any two for $35
Spicy tuna, tuna and avocado, salmon and avocado, mango avocado yellowtail scallion, yellowtail Jalapeno
Tuna Tartare
Sushi Quality grade-A tuna, wasabi avocado, sesame oil, sesame seeds, soy sauce and diced mango

Sushi Entrees
Tuna Special Roll
Tuna, cucumber, avocado, mango & spicy mayo
Firecracker special roll
Shrimp tempura roll filled with avocado and topped with spicy crab, crunchy flake, spicy mayo, masago & eel sauce
Shrimp Tempura Roll
Shrimp tempura, avocado, cucumber, lettuce and eel sauce
Naruto sashimi roll
Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, avocado, masago wrapped with cucumber & ponzu sauce
Green dragon roll
Jumpo lump card, cucumber and avocado topped with toasted eel & eel sauce
Sushi Deluxe (8 pc & tuna roll)
Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, etc.
Sashimi Deluxe (15 pcs)
Tuna, salmon, yellowtail etc.
Sushi & Sashimi Combo (5 sushi, 9 sashimi & tuna roll)
Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, etc.

Desserts
Baklava
Filo, almonds, and honey syrup.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+71 photos
Photo credit: google
+70 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Our server Liam was amazing. The service and food were the best we have ever had. The mussels appetizer was exceptional as were the crab cakes and branzino. Wes dined outside under the stars and it was perfect! Highly recommend
August 2025
I absolutely loved this restaurant! The atmosphere is amazing – cozy, stylish, and full of good vibes. The food is delicious, every dish is full of flavor and beautifully served. The service is outstanding – the staff is very attentive, friendly, and professional. Everything here makes you feel welcome and cared for. Definitely one of the best dining experiences I've had – highly recommend!
August 2025
The service was exceedingly slow. The steaks were good. We didn't get a chance to eat the dip trio we ordered because they only gave our party of five a handful of pita chips and never checked on us again. We've been there many times. It's usually pretty solid, but last night was not a great one for them. I'm sure we'll still give it another try at some point.
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Fairway Restaurant - 3556 Montauk Hwy
American, Cafe, Vegetarian
Townline BBQ - 3593 Montauk Hwy
Barbecue, Barbeque, Bar
Wölffer Estate Vineyard - 139 Sagg Rd
Wineries, Venues & Event Spaces, Vegetarian

Old Stove Pub

3516 Montauk Hwy, Sagaponack, NY 11962
(631) 537-3300