Tortuga Sandwich Shop - Sanborn

5835 Buffalo St, Sanborn
(716) 216-6003

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Green Chili Shrimp Tacos
Super Crispy Potatoes
Madrid Style Potatoes
Andes Fried Potatoes
Alfajores Cookies
Chicken Sandwich
Madrid Potatoes
Cuban Sandwich
Goat Cheese
Large Salad

Menu

Sandwiches/Specials
Gustavo Sandwich
Crispy fried chicken with mild smoky pepper crust, fresh avocado, Jack cheese, garlic aioli, sweet jalapenos (Write in Special Instructions to sub grilled chicken)
Chivito Sandwich
Thinly sliced marinated ribeye, bacon, grilled provolone, chimichurri, garlic aioli, lettuce and tomato, and an over-easy egg.
Chino Sandwich
Marinated strip steak, sauteed onions & peppers, blistered tomatoes, Peruvian cheese sauce, aji verde (herb aioli), and crispy fried potatoes.
Evita Sandwich
Grilled provolone cheese and chimichurri grilled cheese sandwich
Phoenix Sandwich
Roast turkey breast, bacon, fresh avocado, Jack cheese, chipotle sauce, lettuce & tomato, sweet jalapeños.
Lanza Sandwich
Argentinian style sausage, grilled provolone, chimichurri, sauteed peppers and onions, garlic aioli, sliced tomato
Pepe Sandwich
Serrano ham, Manchego cheese, fresh tomato, dressed greens, and garlic aioli.
Salmita Sandwich
Grilled zucchini, Salsa Brava (smoky tomato sauce), dressed greens, and whipped goat cheese.
Brasa Sandwich
Peruvian marinated grilled chicken, fresh avocado, coleslaw, aji verde, sliced tomato, crispy fried potatoes
Special: El Chanchero
Pork carnitas, Mexican chorizo, smoked ham, Oaxaca blend cheese, fresh avocado, pickled jalapeños, garlic aioli, Mexican sour cream, lettuce & tomato, all served on a warm roll.

Sides
Elocos
Crispy Mexican street food corn fritters dusted in ancho chili and cotija cheese. Served with chipotle may, pickled jalapenos, and a wedge of lime.
Andes Style Potatoes
Super crispy potatoes topped with Peruvian cheese sauce and an herb aioli.
Pelotas
Now made with Spanish paella rice. Breaded saffron rice balls stuffed with Manchego cheese, served with Brava sauce and garlic aioli. 2 per order.
Tortuga Mac & Cheese - Large
Shell pasta in a mild sauce made from hatch chiles and sharp cheddar
Toluca Style Potatoes
Super crispy potatoes topped with queso Blanco cheese sauce, Mexican chorizo, chipotle sauce, and sweet jalapenos.
Tortuga Mac & Cheese - Small
Shell pasta in a mild sauce made from hatch chiles and sharp cheddar
Madrid Style Potatoes
Super crispy potatoes topped with Manchego cheese, Brava sauce, and garlic aioli.
Agave-Lime Slaw
Shredded cabbage and carrot, dressed with our agave lime coleslaw dressing.
Super Crispy Potatoes
Sprinkled with sea salt and served with ketchup.
Elote Pasta Salad
Roasted corn, pearl pasta, tomatoes Anejo cheese, mayo lime dressing, and tajin spice.
Salad- Small
Seasonal greens, romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes and house-made croutons.
Salad - Medium
Salad - Large
Seasonal greens, romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes and house-made croutons.

Dessert
Alfajores Cookie
Creamy caramel Dulce de Leche sandwiched between two sugar cookies with a light sprinkle of sea salt, then rolled in unsweetened flaked coconut.
Aztec Cake
Mexican chocolate mousse, salted dulce de leche caramel, cinnamon chocolate crumble and whipped cream.
Xoco Cookie
2 shortbread cookies stuffed with salted Mexican chocolate ganache and rolled in cinnamon - chocolate crumble.
Special: Frutero Cake
Mango mousse cake with shortbread crumble, whipped cream, hibiscus chamoy, diced fresh mango and Tajin spice.

Beverages
Bottled Pop
Bottled pop in a variety of flavors, depending on availability. Grab your favorite flavor at Tortuga.
Bottled Water
Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+35 photos
Photo credit: google
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place is the best. I usually get the Chino or their specials. Just had a chopped cheese called the Spanish Harlem. It was fantastic. I find myself craving this place daily at around 11am because it is so good.
February 2025
My favorite is the Gustavo. I enjoy most of their specials and side potatoes. They have the best birria tacos around! (Special). I only wish sometimes they had some regular sandwiches on the menu making it more kid friendly. The desserts are awesome too. Especially when they have the Chango!
January 2025
We ordered the Chino and Brasa along with a side of their Madrid potatoes and an Alfajor cookie. The Chino's steak was tough and a bit skimpy on the meat. The Brasa was a pretty good, straightforward chicken sandwich. The Madrid Potatoes were disappointing, the "brava" sauce tasted like a marinara sauce, and the cheese was not manchego, I believe it was provolone, which is odd for this type of a potato side. Finally, the alfajor cookie, while the caramel is pretty...
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Buffalo Coffee Roastery - 5844 Buffalo St
Coffee Roasteries
Marlboro Kitchen and Bar - 5894 Ward Rd
American, Bar, Poutineries
Tony's Pizza - 2935 Saunders Settlement Rd
Pizza, Vegetarian

Tortuga Sandwich Shop - Sanborn

5835 Buffalo St, Sanborn, NY 14132
(716) 216-6003