Little Italy Pizzeria
23 Main St, Saranac Lake
(518) 891-9000
Customers' Favorites
Veal Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta or Salad
Penne Basil and Sundried Tomato Alfredo
Pasta with Clams Oreganato
Garlic & Oil Parmigiana
Pizza by the Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Ziti Alla Vodka
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza and Fries
Cheese Pizza
Menu
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Disappointing experience overall. The Margherita pizza was priced as a specialty pizza ($21) without clear explanation—basic ingredients like cheese and tomato sauce were counted as “extras.” Staff were kind but not knowledgeable about the menu. An 18% gratuity was added automatically for a party of two with no prior notice. Important: they only accept cash or check—no cards or digital payments. There’s an on-site ATM, but it charges a $2.50 fee. Service was friendly,...
We were looking forward to trying Little Italy Pizzeria during our visit to Saranac Lake, but unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations. The pizza was undercooked and lacked flavor, and the garlic bread was doughy and bland. The service was slow, and the staff didn’t seem particularly attentive or welcoming. They forgot to add broccoli and olives to our pasta even after placing an order for them. Also, it’s a cash-only place, which wasn’t clearly advertised, making...
Beth gave us great service! This is GREAT NY pizza. I am clueless about some of the other reviews I read. The prices were reasonable - yeah they only take cash. I'm in my 60's so i'm not paying bills with an apple watch anyway.
You May Also Like
Waterhole Music Lounge - 48 Main St
![]()
Bar, Music Venues
Grizle T's - 53 Main St
![]()
Bar, Sports Bar, Dive Bar