Decent place but overall not too crazy about it. The Ceasar salad I had absolutely went right through me. Not sure what it was that did it to me. My mother in law had a chicken and broccoli dish that I tried and it tasted amazing. I will go that route next time for sure.
Kevin Horton
Got the stuffed meat Sicilian. Delicious- filling.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Howie K
Great salads & wonderful creamy dressing. Get an extra one on the side! Rich robust vodka sauce for a pasta dish.
Michael Nathan
Average
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Single S.
Me and my wife have been customers for 2 years! What we love about this place is how consistent they are. There's no worrying about getting a great pizza one day and then a meh one the next -- they're always good! Plus, the staff is very friendly and their service is great. We can't recommend them enough! 10/10
Jennifer N.
A good slice or pie if you like a crispy bottom crust. Everywhere else I would have to order "well done" to get what is consistently served here. Never greasy.
Terence Goff
My favorite pizza in town! The dough is a bit thick so you have to like that. The owners are very personable and the place is always clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pepperoni Chips, Garlic Knots, Buffalo Chicken Roll
Darlyn D.
Food is amazing. Great specials. Efficient cordial staff. Eat in or take out it's the best!!
Joseph L.
I regularly order a variety of pizza and dinner dishes to pick up from Pezzi and they are always delicious, well-prepared, ready when they promise and the staff is attentive and efficient. Calogero always greets me and all guests with a smile and makes sure that the order is correct. I highly recommend Pezzi for all types of italian food!
Kenney H.
The food is amazing the service is great the best pizza on the north shore of Long Island
That’s the Buffalo chicken I ordered, the worst I ever had. Tiny bit size chicken, no flavor. That’s totally a joke.
Christopher Williams
Absolutely love their pizza and garlic knots. It reminds of an old fashion pizza place. Very polite staff and lovely food and drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
markwilliamsheehan
Kindly clone, "Calogero" who meets & greets us all on arrival. He's been on the site for over 20 years & counting! Thing is, his place was suggested by another Italian Eatery ~ which I'll happily review later... When I asked for the best slice of pizza within 10 miles, 'Dylan' who owns the fine-dining Italian near the Sea Cliff station said... 'Go to Pezzi!' He was right! Fabulous Pizza...and while I was there, I thought I'd also sample the eggplant parm and the homemade spaghetti sauces! Thankfully, they provided 'take away containers! Great place, nice, clean, well-lighted space! Oddly enough, when I've asked other 'locals' for the top spot for a slice...THIS place keeps popping-up! Well done! You're famous locally! I shall be back!
robert moffitt
Excellent as always. Great familiar atmosphere ? whether dining in or running out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Bennett
Just as good as it was when I was in high school next door.
Decent place but overall not too crazy about it. The Ceasar salad I had absolutely went right through me. Not sure what it was that did it to me. My mother in law had a chicken and broccoli dish that I tried and it tasted amazing. I will go that route next time for sure.
Got the stuffed meat Sicilian. Delicious- filling.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great salads & wonderful creamy dressing. Get an extra one on the side! Rich robust vodka sauce for a pasta dish.
Average
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Me and my wife have been customers for 2 years! What we love about this place is how consistent they are. There's no worrying about getting a great pizza one day and then a meh one the next -- they're always good! Plus, the staff is very friendly and their service is great. We can't recommend them enough! 10/10
A good slice or pie if you like a crispy bottom crust. Everywhere else I would have to order "well done" to get what is consistently served here. Never greasy.
My favorite pizza in town! The dough is a bit thick so you have to like that. The owners are very personable and the place is always clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pepperoni Chips, Garlic Knots, Buffalo Chicken Roll
Food is amazing. Great specials. Efficient cordial staff. Eat in or take out it's the best!!
I regularly order a variety of pizza and dinner dishes to pick up from Pezzi and they are always delicious, well-prepared, ready when they promise and the staff is attentive and efficient. Calogero always greets me and all guests with a smile and makes sure that the order is correct. I highly recommend Pezzi for all types of italian food!
The food is amazing the service is great the best pizza on the north shore of Long Island
Restaurantji Recommends
That’s the Buffalo chicken I ordered, the worst I ever had. Tiny bit size chicken, no flavor. That’s totally a joke.
Absolutely love their pizza and garlic knots. It reminds of an old fashion pizza place. Very polite staff and lovely food and drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kindly clone, "Calogero" who meets & greets us all on arrival. He's been on the site for over 20 years & counting! Thing is, his place was suggested by another Italian Eatery ~ which I'll happily review later... When I asked for the best slice of pizza within 10 miles, 'Dylan' who owns the fine-dining Italian near the Sea Cliff station said... 'Go to Pezzi!' He was right! Fabulous Pizza...and while I was there, I thought I'd also sample the eggplant parm and the homemade spaghetti sauces! Thankfully, they provided 'take away containers! Great place, nice, clean, well-lighted space! Oddly enough, when I've asked other 'locals' for the top spot for a slice...THIS place keeps popping-up! Well done! You're famous locally! I shall be back!
Excellent as always. Great familiar atmosphere ? whether dining in or running out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just as good as it was when I was in high school next door.