Haven't had a bad slice yet, veal Parmigiano is awesome. Best part is, it's within walking distance
Ayaan Anwar
Delicious food. Friendly owners.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan R.
This is the best pizza in the Seaford Wantagh area, which is saying something. I 've worked through the menu in pizza and pasta items, and it is definitely thin crust NYC rooted, but also is just full of flavor. The round grandma is a gimmick, but is still delicious. The spinach and white pizza is the best I ever had. The baked ziti is cheesed top to bottom, not just one drop of ricotta like most places. Found these guys just this year, and now they're my go to. Thanks for opening nearby, and for the WLIR vibe w the music choices.
G Bach
Delicious food. Great service. Beautiful dining area and ambiance, which has a few lovely pictures on the wall. Parking can be difficult when the bar/tavern next door is very busy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sabrina Kadel
Pizza was the best in the area. Under carriage on point - Rob
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Martin Jablonski
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pie 18’’
Lizzie H.
The pizza was so good we came back a day later but through Uber eats - hey it was late & freezing on a Sunday. Don't judge us But now I can confirm NOT ONLY does their food travel well but their entrees are to die for. So many times we'll order penne a la vodka to go or on Uber eats and are beyond disappointed with the lack of sauce (and usually flavor). That was 100% not the case here. Both meals were packed with flavor! Highly highly recommend this place.
Brian M.
Great food. We got the family deal and the grandma pie, salad and penne vodka were delicious. Came out piping hot. So great that they are here in the community.
Thomas Gagliardi
Pizza was phenomenal! Our new go to pizza place! Every slice was nice and crunchy. Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leslie Cardone
The triangle vodka slice is the best pizza I have ever had. I used to eat this pizza when they were located in Manhattan on Stone St. I’ve been dreaming about this pizza ever since they left that location... So happy they are still making my favorite slice. The triangle grandma slice is also amazing too!
Pizza Italia in Seaford, NY. Excellent regular slice. 9.0 relative to LI pizza. And the Round Grandma was delicious. Really traditional old school flavor. No rating as I haven't had lots of this style. The regular brought me back to what I remember pizza tasting like in the '60. Will be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Marini
Their broccoli Rabe and sausage pizza delicious.The reg pie so tasty I even ate the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gilad Paz
BEST. PIZZA. ANYWHERE!!!This pizza ruined me for life because nothing comes close!My wife and I traveled all the way from Manhattan to have this pizza, which used to be in our Chelsea neighborhood for years.Everything Anthony cooks is DELICIOUS, but our recommended highlights are their signature grandma pizza (my favorite pizza on earth!), vodka, chicken marsala, chicken ricotta (w/side of sauce), and fresh tomato & garlic. Also, the chicken rolls are excellent! Make sure you ask for Anthony’s INCREDIBLE marinara sauce on the side.Also, shout out to Brandon for the great service tonight.
Tommy G.
Pizza was phenomenal! Nice and clean interior. This is going to be my new go to pizza spot. Every slice we had was delicious and crunchy.
Paul C.
Good stuff. It's our new "go to" place in the area. Friendly staff. Wish I had a pic of the Grandma pie we've had. Chicken parm was awesome.
Haven't had a bad slice yet, veal Parmigiano is awesome. Best part is, it's within walking distance
Delicious food. Friendly owners.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the best pizza in the Seaford Wantagh area, which is saying something. I 've worked through the menu in pizza and pasta items, and it is definitely thin crust NYC rooted, but also is just full of flavor. The round grandma is a gimmick, but is still delicious. The spinach and white pizza is the best I ever had. The baked ziti is cheesed top to bottom, not just one drop of ricotta like most places. Found these guys just this year, and now they're my go to. Thanks for opening nearby, and for the WLIR vibe w the music choices.
Delicious food. Great service. Beautiful dining area and ambiance, which has a few lovely pictures on the wall. Parking can be difficult when the bar/tavern next door is very busy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Pizza was the best in the area. Under carriage on point - Rob
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pie 18’’
The pizza was so good we came back a day later but through Uber eats - hey it was late & freezing on a Sunday. Don't judge us But now I can confirm NOT ONLY does their food travel well but their entrees are to die for. So many times we'll order penne a la vodka to go or on Uber eats and are beyond disappointed with the lack of sauce (and usually flavor). That was 100% not the case here. Both meals were packed with flavor! Highly highly recommend this place.
Great food. We got the family deal and the grandma pie, salad and penne vodka were delicious. Came out piping hot. So great that they are here in the community.
Pizza was phenomenal! Our new go to pizza place! Every slice was nice and crunchy. Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The triangle vodka slice is the best pizza I have ever had. I used to eat this pizza when they were located in Manhattan on Stone St. I’ve been dreaming about this pizza ever since they left that location... So happy they are still making my favorite slice. The triangle grandma slice is also amazing too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza Italia in Seaford, NY. Excellent regular slice. 9.0 relative to LI pizza. And the Round Grandma was delicious. Really traditional old school flavor. No rating as I haven't had lots of this style. The regular brought me back to what I remember pizza tasting like in the '60. Will be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their broccoli Rabe and sausage pizza delicious.The reg pie so tasty I even ate the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEST. PIZZA. ANYWHERE!!!This pizza ruined me for life because nothing comes close!My wife and I traveled all the way from Manhattan to have this pizza, which used to be in our Chelsea neighborhood for years.Everything Anthony cooks is DELICIOUS, but our recommended highlights are their signature grandma pizza (my favorite pizza on earth!), vodka, chicken marsala, chicken ricotta (w/side of sauce), and fresh tomato & garlic. Also, the chicken rolls are excellent! Make sure you ask for Anthony’s INCREDIBLE marinara sauce on the side.Also, shout out to Brandon for the great service tonight.
Pizza was phenomenal! Nice and clean interior. This is going to be my new go to pizza spot. Every slice we had was delicious and crunchy.
Good stuff. It's our new "go to" place in the area. Friendly staff. Wish I had a pic of the Grandma pie we've had. Chicken parm was awesome.