Tarallo's Pizzeria & Restaurant
1700 Washington Ave, Seaford
(516) 221-6995
Recent Reviews
Sort by
1700 Washington Ave, Seaford
(516) 221-6995
I am definitely going to rate this 4 stars...Margherita pizza Absolutely delicious With the Sesame seed crust....A+++++BUT: It arrived very cold (brrrrr)We had to air fry it...for $25 it should arrive hot n ready to eat.I hope The owners can take some constructive criticism because I have to admit The Taste was absolutely delicious! Happy Healthy New Year!!!-
I took my family for diner. The food was really good. The portions were great. Anthony is a wonderful guy and great cook. I’m going to go back for sure.
Awesome food.. great chicken parm, owner is a great guy! Best pizza around
This is the most delicious pizza in the Nassau I recommend 100%
Best pizza around! Love the sesame crust, closest to Brooklyn style that I’ve found. If I’m not eating Tarallo’s pizza, I’m not eating pizza!!!
I'm from Brooklyn, and since living on LI, we have searched for similar pizza... Tarallo"s is awesome, and not just the pizza. Have NEVER been disappointed with anything we've ordered.
Go here often - sometimes after Mass. Nice pizza - recently went under an interior redesign and new management.
Great local pizza spot with solid pizza! Sicilian was ?
Great cheese pizza and excellent family specials
My family and I ordered a couple of pizzas yesterday, and let me tell you it was DELICIOUS! By far the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Thank you, we will definitely be back for more!
Restaurantji Recommends
Just ordered 10 pies for my sons Birthday and the food and service was amazing!!! The new owner Anthony took the time with me to make sure I had enough food for adults as well as the kids. And even accommodated a child with gluten allergies with a special pie as well. I cannot say enough forthe top-notch service ! everyone loved the pizza and even the delivery boy was polite and respectful.
This is one of my favorite pizza places on Long Island. If your looking for a pizza place, this is the one. Just make sure you get the sesame crust, it's a game changer!
Holy $#!+ pizza the way it should be! Get the sesame crust!
Delicious we just ordered today well done!! Fantastic we love this pizza and it’s just up block from our house ! Def our go to returns to luv it!!
Our go to. Get the sesame seed crust.
Loading...