Great place to eat and the staff were helpful, courteous and friendly. Great atmosphere. Will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Desiree Finley (DezzyLoo)
LUCA, EDGAR AND DEVON... DREAM TEAM. PIZZA PERFECT!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Buzzell
Cafe Amici is my go-to place for take out pizza. I went yesterday and ordered a pizza and hung out inside to wait. Very pleasant atmosphere fun to watch the staff in front getting orders to customers. Alot of people were buying sliders in the front case and having them heated up to dine in. Very casual and fun place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mariposa Linda
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Café Amici in Selden is a gem! From the warm greeting at the door to the attentive staff and fresh bread service, everything feels welcoming. The appetizers were delicious, but the highlight was the Trojan entrée — huge portions, amazing flavor, and beautifully presented. If you still have room, the desserts are worth it too. Prices are great for the quality, and meeting Joe, the owner, made the experience even more special. Highly recommend!
Nicholas DeRosa
Great pizza place. It's spacious, clean, offers table as well as booth seating and has a bar. The guy who warmed up our slices was extremely friendly and sent one of my daughter's home with a small container of sauce she liked. Very cool.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
PJG151
Bartender lady was useless and didn't care. A Negroni? not a clue. Dinner was so-so. One of our our group got ice cold mussels in his dish if mussels marinara. Sunday eve, busy place, who is running the kitchen? Used to be great.
Kevin \u0026 Dana Lahey
We’ve been ordering from Caffe Amici for years and it’s always fantastic! Their food is always fresh, hot, and delicious — truly a great experience every time.
Since opening Selden Fit Body Boot Camp, we’ve been in the area a lot more and love stopping in. Their lighter choices are perfect for our lifestyle — things like pairing grilled chicken or seafood with veggie sides or salads, or opting for their specialty slices and wraps. Everything tastes fresh and full of flavor, and it’s great to have healthier options without sacrificing taste.
Owner Joe is always friendly and helpful, and you can tell he cares about the experience his guests have.
Caffe Amici offers plenty of choices — whether you’re in the mood to indulge in genuine Italian food or stick with lighter dishes that won’t derail your fitness goals. This is an amazing family-friendly restaurant with so much to offer. If you’re looking for a night out with variety, flavor, and great service, Caffe Amici is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Jacob
When it was time to cater for my son’s baptism there was no question where to get the food from. Joe, the owner, is a pleasure to work with. They delivered the food right on time and super hot/fresh. Everything was a huge hit especially their rigatoni alla vodka and chicken Mona Lisa.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ashley H
pizza is always amazing 10/10 me and my fiancé always come there to eat , wonderful atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Courter
I'll start with I normally order out from here, generally my food is delicious and the order correct. Tonight I was sent a wrong item that I have no use for as I don't eat or like it. Ordered stuffed artichoke and received mushrooms. I have been refunded the price of the artichoke, I'm just upset as that's what I was looking forward to eating, and wanted to communicate that. Hopefully it's not a common occurrence.
Yeah I like to tell you this is the second time years ago what happened with the shrimp? It tasted fishy and I wrote a review now this was horrible yesterday I mean I told the waiter Pedro but it didn’t make a difference. The bill cutlet was burned to the crisp burned like it was thrown in a basket and burned my friend and I had the same meal. The pasta was horrible. It was mushy. I told him he goes all they’re all like that he brings out another ball. I don’t eat that either. He didn’t care now that’s horrible what you people are doing is this how you train your waiters and waitresses? Why should I have to eat Burnville cutlet and mushy pasta? The only thing? Good was the soup that was it you really really gotta do something about this when they’re talking to is that how you train them? I wanna know to ignore people and not to offer them a different meal something edible. Why do I gotta eat? burn veal cutlets and mushy pasta. I didn’t come there for that.
carlos riley
The food is great the service. And prices. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luca Sullivan
What an amazing experience! There was so much delicious food, and everyone couldn’t stop talking about how great everything tasted. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the entire night felt effortless thanks to the incredible staff. I would absolutely recommend this place for birthdays, rehearsal dinners, or even just a fun night out with friends. Thank you for helping us create such a beautiful and memorable celebration!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rich Ardizzone
Delicious food and generous portions plus good prices... can't beat it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie M
Great pizza, good service, friendly environment. It's my go to pizza place.
Great place to eat and the staff were helpful, courteous and friendly. Great atmosphere. Will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LUCA, EDGAR AND DEVON... DREAM TEAM. PIZZA PERFECT!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cafe Amici is my go-to place for take out pizza. I went yesterday and ordered a pizza and hung out inside to wait. Very pleasant atmosphere fun to watch the staff in front getting orders to customers. Alot of people were buying sliders in the front case and having them heated up to dine in. Very casual and fun place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Café Amici in Selden is a gem! From the warm greeting at the door to the attentive staff and fresh bread service, everything feels welcoming. The appetizers were delicious, but the highlight was the Trojan entrée — huge portions, amazing flavor, and beautifully presented. If you still have room, the desserts are worth it too. Prices are great for the quality, and meeting Joe, the owner, made the experience even more special. Highly recommend!
Great pizza place. It's spacious, clean, offers table as well as booth seating and has a bar. The guy who warmed up our slices was extremely friendly and sent one of my daughter's home with a small container of sauce she liked. Very cool.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Bartender lady was useless and didn't care. A Negroni? not a clue. Dinner was so-so. One of our our group got ice cold mussels in his dish if mussels marinara. Sunday eve, busy place, who is running the kitchen? Used to be great.
We’ve been ordering from Caffe Amici for years and it’s always fantastic! Their food is always fresh, hot, and delicious — truly a great experience every time.
Since opening Selden Fit Body Boot Camp, we’ve been in the area a lot more and love stopping in. Their lighter choices are perfect for our lifestyle — things like pairing grilled chicken or seafood with veggie sides or salads, or opting for their specialty slices and wraps. Everything tastes fresh and full of flavor, and it’s great to have healthier options without sacrificing taste.
Owner Joe is always friendly and helpful, and you can tell he cares about the experience his guests have.
Caffe Amici offers plenty of choices — whether you’re in the mood to indulge in genuine Italian food or stick with lighter dishes that won’t derail your fitness goals. This is an amazing family-friendly restaurant with so much to offer. If you’re looking for a night out with variety, flavor, and great service, Caffe Amici is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
When it was time to cater for my son’s baptism there was no question where to get the food from. Joe, the owner, is a pleasure to work with. They delivered the food right on time and super hot/fresh. Everything was a huge hit especially their rigatoni alla vodka and chicken Mona Lisa.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
pizza is always amazing 10/10 me and my fiancé always come there to eat , wonderful atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'll start with I normally order out from here, generally my food is delicious and the order correct. Tonight I was sent a wrong item that I have no use for as I don't eat or like it. Ordered stuffed artichoke and received mushrooms. I have been refunded the price of the artichoke, I'm just upset as that's what I was looking forward to eating, and wanted to communicate that. Hopefully it's not a common occurrence.
Restaurantji Recommends
Yeah I like to tell you this is the second time years ago what happened with the shrimp? It tasted fishy and I wrote a review now this was horrible yesterday I mean I told the waiter Pedro but it didn’t make a difference. The bill cutlet was burned to the crisp burned like it was thrown in a basket and burned my friend and I had the same meal. The pasta was horrible. It was mushy. I told him he goes all they’re all like that he brings out another ball. I don’t eat that either. He didn’t care now that’s horrible what you people are doing is this how you train your waiters and waitresses? Why should I have to eat Burnville cutlet and mushy pasta? The only thing? Good was the soup that was it you really really gotta do something about this when they’re talking to is that how you train them? I wanna know to ignore people and not to offer them a different meal something edible. Why do I gotta eat? burn veal cutlets and mushy pasta. I didn’t come there for that.
The food is great the service. And prices. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What an amazing experience! There was so much delicious food, and everyone couldn’t stop talking about how great everything tasted. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the entire night felt effortless thanks to the incredible staff. I would absolutely recommend this place for birthdays, rehearsal dinners, or even just a fun night out with friends. Thank you for helping us create such a beautiful and memorable celebration!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food and generous portions plus good prices... can't beat it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, good service, friendly environment. It's my go to pizza place.
Loading...