Jersey Mike's Subs

280A Middle Country Rd, Selden
(631) 538-1983

Recent Reviews

Billy carmello

Top of the line they definitely got my vote those cold cut combos have nothing on any hero place I've ever encountered...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Marcano

Usually order through DoorDash and ways have issues with the food. 347 location is more accurate and better with

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Margaret O'Brien

Best Jersey Mike's around! Guys working here make the sandwiches perfect every time, if you ask for extra meat or cheese or request modifications they actually make it just the way you ask. Highly recommend this JM to anyone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Hamilton

Kids working close the store early. Got there before 9pm and they had already locked the door and said they were closed. Won’t go to this location again as this is not the first time it has happened.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Selma

quality has gone

Food: 2

Bryan Peritore

Parking: Easy to get to. Plenty of free parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ham and Provolone, Sandwich

Lori G.

Going to start off this review by saying I am skeptical of most cookie cutter sandwich chains, but I have to be honest here, this location is really good. My family and I have become huge fans of Jersey Mike's. We have had hot and cold subs and each and every time they've been delicious and made to perfection. We always place our order in advance and it is always freshly made and ready when we arrived. We used to only go to homerun heroes, but now jersey mikes is our go to for all things subs.

Robert Abrams

I go there weekly usually. Extremely fresh bread and ingredients, large variety of sandwiches and wraps on the menu. The shore points system allows you to build up to free food. I always do the Giant size subs (12 points each on shore system). Staff is friendly and attentive. When very busy, they still manage to shine. Both thumbs up! On Tuesdays, its double points on all purchases. They even off wraps and bowls made from the subs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lilly Baird

Surprisingly very good. I thought it would be more like subway which i don't really care for, but it was delicious, more like a Wegmans sub . Order online, and it's ready when you are.

Food: 5

Henry Bradley III

First time at Jersey MikeMike's, but not the last ?..Got a spicy Italian with the works plus bacon..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rene Tegelvad

Just got my sub for today, Brandon on the slicer is on fire! It would be nice if some of his high energy work rubbed off on other employees

Joel B.

I have been the biggest fan of Jersey Mike's subs since 2018, that's when I first got introduced to this place by a friend. However, it was a different location. fast forward a few years and I've been venturing to this location for about two years now. For the last year coming here has been a nightmare. Several times they've gotten my order incorrect or were lacking a product and did not communicate it until I said something. Most recently when I complained about my order being incorrect, there was such a nonchalant attitude about it. They were unapologetic and even left to the back without a single word. I'm not a loud person or rude and it takes a lot for me to even speak up, so it was disturbing how quick they were to ignore me and there were about 4 employees available and none cared. Following the last visit, I wrote a comment to Jersey Mike's through there App, where it indicated that they would reach out to the store and someone would reach out to me, but I haven't heard anything back since. It's clear that management or the person that oversees this store does not care. I don't experience this at any other location. It's truly sad because this is the most convenient location to visit. I would wholehearted avoid this location, it was not a one time issues, but several over a set period of time. Hopefully they get better, but in the meantime I don't recommend going here.. I know I will not be venturing to this location any time soon.

Jeff Edmonds

Great sandwiches ?, the kids and I love it. Blows subway away.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey and Provolone

David B.

Excellent costumer service . A bit crowded but loved the Philly cheese steak . Will definitely be back . The staff here is awesome !!!

Michael Gosselin

The lettuce was brown, chips on the rack was expired and tune did not sit well at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Load More