The pizza is fantastic!!! Had that last week. I ordered the El Greco pizza sandwich tonight. Very disappointed, menu says grilled lamb and beef. Could not find any beef and there were three thin pieces of lamb on each half, could not taste the gyro meat at all. It felt like I was eating a vegetable sandwich. I don’t like vegetable sandwiches. Do better please
Lisa-22
They have vegan cheese for pizza. A good hummus appetizer.
Updated from previous review on 2025-04-05
No name
Went there tonight and this is how it went, I ordered a New York mule and they said they were out of ginger beer, so I ordered a cranberry mimosa,they said they were out of cranberry, I then said OK I'll have a root beer, guess what, there were out of root beer, so then I said fine, I'll just have a glass of ice water, Well guess what,they had no freaking ice,unreal,well I still gave them a chance and ordered pizza and wings,they said the wings would not be done the same time as the pizza,I can't believe this,after I ate my pizza I went to the bathroom and went to wash my hands and there was no hot water, what a joke this place is
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
jack baker
I went here on the way to Niagara Falls and me and my girlfriend wanted to get 2 cups of coffee. It took us 45 minutes to get Americano and a latte. The latte was supposed to be the seasonal flavor and she got the wrong size Americano and I got a latte that had zero flavor to it. The foam wasn’t even like a latte I don’t even know if they even gave me a latte, I took like 45 minutes to get 2 hot beverages and it costed us like $11
John DeMillo
Awesome experience! Great concept Date night! Glad we went early as crowds started 5 minutes after we got there! The food is fabulous! We started with tasty hummus appetizer, and the wood fire pizza- we got the Cornell marinated chicken-fantastic! Love it!! And the chocolate dessert?? TDF!! Enjoyed the wine, service was excellent and friendly. This is a small town and everyone has their fave place to go- but you gotta give Fall Street Brewing a try! The only place with wood fire pizza! There’s so much on the menu we can’t wait to go back!! Love the new, bigger place!
Julius Fineberg
If the coffee had been as warm as the wine, and the wine as old as the salad, and the salad as fresh as the menu, and the menu as valued as it's staff it would have been a very good meal.
Apart from that, the meal was ruined by the chef/owner's vituperous haranguing coming from the kitchen. That poor staff.
In summary, it sucked.
Kathleen Dunham
This is an amazing place to have an event. Brad was very kind and accommodating. We had a last minute need for an event space and Brad stepped in and helped us out. The staff was wonderful, the food was incredible and the space is charming.
somesun4u
Delicious Gluten Free pizza, great atmosphere and service was great too! Love the new spot!
Robert Wilson
pizza is best in town. they’re still working on the vibe but the space is solid as well as the food and drinks. More effort on sound and acoustics, wayfinding, and lighting would go far. looking to trying more of their menu
Joshua Jones
Fall Street Brewing is more than just a brewery; it's a delightful experience. The breakfast pizza was absolutely divine, and the mini cinnamon buns were the perfect sweet treat. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting despite the spaciousness of the place. The view of the Women's Rights Hall of Fame, the park, and the canal is simply stunning. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, and the food selection is impressive. If you're looking for a great meal and a beautiful view, Fall Street Brewing is the place to be. I'm excited to return for lunch and their date night dinner.
Took a very long time to get a drink. The cauliflower was way too salty. The pasta dish with salmon.
Michael Scott
What a cute little place! ? Every once in awhile I accidentally stroll into one of those little hole in the wall places that unexpectedly turn out to be something special.??
This is probably the smallest brewery I've ever been. If I ever had my own I think this would be perfect. ??
This is different because they open early in the morning and serve breakfast!???
I had my typical flight? experience, very reasonably priced, followed by a pre-mixed bourbon cocktail?
JennyAkchin
Went in 08/24. No vegan options, but offered to take cheese off the hummus sandwich.
Ellyse Ducayne
So happy they have pure matcha instead of a matcha latte powder mix that already has a ton of sugar in in. New matcha latte spot!
Mekhi Russ
I totally don't work here nor do I hold any capacity for biases. I, with pure objectivity, believe that Fall Street Brewing is the best cafe/bar/brewery in the finger lakes!! :)
The pizza is fantastic!!! Had that last week. I ordered the El Greco pizza sandwich tonight. Very disappointed, menu says grilled lamb and beef. Could not find any beef and there were three thin pieces of lamb on each half, could not taste the gyro meat at all. It felt like I was eating a vegetable sandwich. I don’t like vegetable sandwiches. Do better please
They have vegan cheese for pizza. A good hummus appetizer. Updated from previous review on 2025-04-05
Went there tonight and this is how it went, I ordered a New York mule and they said they were out of ginger beer, so I ordered a cranberry mimosa,they said they were out of cranberry, I then said OK I'll have a root beer, guess what, there were out of root beer, so then I said fine, I'll just have a glass of ice water, Well guess what,they had no freaking ice,unreal,well I still gave them a chance and ordered pizza and wings,they said the wings would not be done the same time as the pizza,I can't believe this,after I ate my pizza I went to the bathroom and went to wash my hands and there was no hot water, what a joke this place is
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I went here on the way to Niagara Falls and me and my girlfriend wanted to get 2 cups of coffee. It took us 45 minutes to get Americano and a latte. The latte was supposed to be the seasonal flavor and she got the wrong size Americano and I got a latte that had zero flavor to it. The foam wasn’t even like a latte I don’t even know if they even gave me a latte, I took like 45 minutes to get 2 hot beverages and it costed us like $11
Awesome experience! Great concept Date night! Glad we went early as crowds started 5 minutes after we got there! The food is fabulous! We started with tasty hummus appetizer, and the wood fire pizza- we got the Cornell marinated chicken-fantastic! Love it!! And the chocolate dessert?? TDF!! Enjoyed the wine, service was excellent and friendly. This is a small town and everyone has their fave place to go- but you gotta give Fall Street Brewing a try! The only place with wood fire pizza! There’s so much on the menu we can’t wait to go back!! Love the new, bigger place!
If the coffee had been as warm as the wine, and the wine as old as the salad, and the salad as fresh as the menu, and the menu as valued as it's staff it would have been a very good meal.
Apart from that, the meal was ruined by the chef/owner's vituperous haranguing coming from the kitchen. That poor staff.
In summary, it sucked.
This is an amazing place to have an event. Brad was very kind and accommodating. We had a last minute need for an event space and Brad stepped in and helped us out. The staff was wonderful, the food was incredible and the space is charming.
Delicious Gluten Free pizza, great atmosphere and service was great too! Love the new spot!
pizza is best in town. they’re still working on the vibe but the space is solid as well as the food and drinks. More effort on sound and acoustics, wayfinding, and lighting would go far. looking to trying more of their menu
Fall Street Brewing is more than just a brewery; it's a delightful experience. The breakfast pizza was absolutely divine, and the mini cinnamon buns were the perfect sweet treat. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting despite the spaciousness of the place. The view of the Women's Rights Hall of Fame, the park, and the canal is simply stunning. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, and the food selection is impressive. If you're looking for a great meal and a beautiful view, Fall Street Brewing is the place to be. I'm excited to return for lunch and their date night dinner.
Restaurantji Recommends
Took a very long time to get a drink. The cauliflower was way too salty. The pasta dish with salmon.
What a cute little place! ?
Every once in awhile I accidentally stroll into one of those little hole in the wall places that unexpectedly turn out to be something special.??
This is probably the smallest brewery I've ever been.
If I ever had my own I think this would be perfect. ??
This is different because they open early in the morning and serve breakfast!???
I had my typical flight? experience, very reasonably priced, followed by a pre-mixed bourbon cocktail?
Went in 08/24. No vegan options, but offered to take cheese off the hummus sandwich.
So happy they have pure matcha instead of a matcha latte powder mix that already has a ton of sugar in in. New matcha latte spot!
I totally don't work here nor do I hold any capacity for biases. I, with pure objectivity, believe that Fall Street Brewing is the best cafe/bar/brewery in the finger lakes!! :)
Loading...