It's A Wonderful Bakery

This was an amazing experience. My co worker friend and I stopped there thus afternoon and purchased individual cookies as well a 4 Italian cookie boxes. So delicious❤️ The owner was extremely kind and had mentioned that she would hold orders for us if we called and wanted to reserve. We both reside in Watkins Glen but venture to Seneca Falls when we can. Excellent customer service and a big 5 star for the goodies as well. Venture people, and give this wonderful bakery a try.❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was traveling through the area and looking for something sweet. I asked SIRI for the local bakery. I was directed to “It’s a wonderful bakery”.i was greeted and taken care of right away. Purchased a few different cookies, but just now I’m eating a giant chocolate chip frosting stuffed cookie. absolutely delicious chewy chocolate chip cookie and the frosting exactly what I wanted. similar to wedding cake buttercream .I treat myself only once in a while and so glad I stopped there. Can’t wait to try the toffee cookie with frosting in the middle .My son will enjoy the molasses and the chocolate chip if they’re as good as the big cookie is .Definitely would go there again and will recommend to everyone I know. thank you for providing friendly service and quality cookies. 🥰

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a last minute request for a birthday cake, the owner was happy to fulfill our order doing her best to incorporate our specific preference for a strawberry flavored birthday cake, and had it ready for us in no time!

The cake was the highlight of our celebrations. It was the perfect amount of sweetness and fluffiness. Highly recommend her!

Food: 5

Service: 5

My son got married this past weekend at Ventosa vineyards. We live outside of the area and this bakery was recommended to us. We used her for rehearsal dinner and wedding desserts. Kelli did not disappoint. Everything was delicious. She was very easy to work with and very accommodating. Everyone commented on how delicious the desserts were. We also ordered Vegan and Gluten free options and they were delicious too!

Delicious cookies! Especially the peanut butter ones.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Homemade, creative, variety, can buy one or in a package! Can place orders for events such as but not limit to wedding, graduations, showers, birthdays and social events!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Found this place by accident and so glad I did! Chocolate chip cookies and chocolate milkyway cookies were wonderful! As were the m ini cheesecakes! I will definitely be back! Kelly is friendly and informative and deserves recognition!!

Fantastic service, She is beyond friendly!
Always a delightful treat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Barbie Birthday Cake

Amazing!
Called and told her I needed a cake.
All my daughter wanted was an Axolotl cake for her 6th. Told her to do whatever was easier in the long run.

She delivered!
Super friendly, Amazing cake and my daughter loved it!
Plus, cheaper then Walmart or Tops.
Definitely going here for next year's cake!!

This truly is a Wonderful Bakery!! I reached out after business hours. Not only did the owner immediately respond, she also had my order ready for me before she opened Monday morning. Above and beyond customer service! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

Had a tray of Italian cookies for my recent wedding. They were delicious! Enjoyed by all!

Outstanding!!! I ordered a cake, cupcakes, and cake pops for my husbands’ 70th birthday party. Everything was delicious. Many compliments from my guests. I had a guest that is gluten free and they accommodated me with four gluten free cupcakes so my guest would not be excluded. Thank you so very much.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is the best bakery! The owner is friendly and is quick to respond to messages. The Cakes and Italian cookies I’ve gotten from here were AMAZING! I’d recommend It’s a wonderful bakery to everyone for all occasions, even if the only occasion is you want a sweet treat 😁

Best ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I must speak about my wonderful experience at It's A Wonderful Bakery. To start off Keli is awesome! Sweet as can be and so respectful. I am obsessed with her cannolis so I decided to ask her to make a birthday cake for my daughter's 7th birthday. When I tell you not only was the barbie cake gorgeous it's was delicious. Very price friendly and professional.Thank you Keli!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5