I usually do not ever have an issue here. The staff is very accommodable; you just have to ask.
Sean Cone
It's okay too many children working good pizza sauce nice cheese and the dough as long as it's cooked undercooking I like my pizza bubbling golden brown cheese with a nice Golden crust
Jordan Wolcott
I got a small antipasta salad and the size of a small looked like the size of a large salad. It was the best salad I have had in a very long time. Thanks magros in sherburne ny for making my dinner amazing
Kayla Cullen
I have bought pizza from here multiple times and I think the food is great, but the constant yelling (screaming, honestly) at the young girls that work there (from I’m assuming the boss) really messes with the atmosphere in my opinion. It’s incredibly uncomfortable, and you feel bad watching the young girls that are working getting screamed at and belittled for every little thing they don’t do up to his standards. There hasn’t been a single time I’ve bought pizza from there and didn’t hear him yelling or loudly complaining about the girls not doing something right. I’m not sure if it’s a family owned business, or how close the staff are to where that’s normal, but me personally, as a customer it’s very awkward, and makes me not want to go into the establishment. This is my personal opinion and I don’t want to speak for anyone else. I understand under stress at work especially working in a restaurant things can get heated, but it seems like it’s constantly and it’s always the same guy going off the walls on the female staff.
tina breslau
Good food nice atmosphere, wonderful people
Bryan O'Connor
Hands down the best pizza I've ever had! Great service and excellent food. You won't find a better pizza place in NY.
Leslie Joscelyn
Greeted by friendly, smiling faces as soon as we walked in the door. It was quiet here, which I appreciated. The food was great. Will dine here again. Beta fish in vases on the tables were unique and cute touch.
Tyler Stone
The Pizza is good for the area.
Geririgged
Great quick service spot. The inside was overflowing with tropical flowers which was pretty fun but the tables had little space left for people ha
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Britt S
Joe & Vinny's/Magro's doesn't disappoint. The atmosphere is cool. There are real plants around & fish in vases on tables. The music was good.
I walked in around 15 mins before they were going to close. The staff were kind, helpful, and attentive. We saw some menus online that differed from the actual menus in store. Salvatore was nice enough to match the price for us. Thank you again, Salvatore & Lou Lou (sp). Best customer service I've ever received. Definitely will return. 100/10 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders, Wings, Pizza by the Slice, Garlic Knots
Great pizza! Friendly service, clean and cozy. Just what we needed on a long drive. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
A T
Have loved this place since I was a kid, now sharing huge subs and delicious garlic knots with my children. Whenever we're back in the area, we have to stop - even if for nothing more than the knots(with that marinara sauce, of course)!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Antipasto, Calzone, Pizza by the Slice, Sheet Pizza, Garlic Knots
Billie L
Three times we've stopped in for food since last November. First time my mom and I were just grabbing slices. It was mid afternoon and the place was quiet. We were just coming from a funeral and heading to see my dad who was in the hospital, so we're looking to get something quick to eat. We picked out a couple, paid for the slices and coffee and sat down. The new owner puts the already cooked slices in the oven and forgot about them. When I asked about 15-20 minutes later, they were burnt. He claimed he thought we had left. Said he looked around for us and didn't see us. The place is small. We sat near the coffee counter, since we were both drinking coffee. We were just out of view from the counter where you would order. We watched for the slices to come and he never showed his head around the corner. But he tried to make it up to us by handing back some cash for the trouble. The next time wasn't as bad, I called in an order for calzones to go with sauce in them. They came without sauce, so owner gave me a little plastic to-go container of sauce for them. This last time it is apparent that the new owner needs to get his act together. I called in an order for three calzones plus a large pizza with toppings. Waited 30 minutes before leaving the house to pick up the order. There were three people or groups of people waiting for orders when I got there. The new owner appeared to be busy, running around trying to fix other people's orders that got mixed up. There was one guy making pizzas, a couple of girls making appetizers and subs and another employee who was trying to do his own job in the back plus help customers up front. Owner tells the guy to "Don't worry about her.". The guy apologizes and goes to try help the owner who was trying to fix other people's orders first. Owner definitely needs classes on how to treat the employees. Yelled at the girls making subs, wings, whatever. "I've told you three times you need to bag subs and appetizers together so people get their orders!". Personally, I don't think a cold sub should be placed in a plastic bag with hot foods. The items were wrapped in paper bags with order slips stapled to them. When they get the other orders cleared up, the one guy asks what I ordered. Checked around, had found three calzones in a box. Okay, good. But then looked for the pizza and only found two cheese pizzas. No pizzas in the oven ready to come out, only a sheet pizza about ready to go in the oven. Our large pizza with toppings was not there. Owner throws some cold toppings on the pizza and stuffs it in the oven and tells me he'll take some money off the bill to make up for it then disappears. Maybe if the owner did a little more hands on work and paid attention to what he was doing rather than running around and putting blame on the employees, the place would run nicer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Elizabeth Adams
We loved this place! Best pizza we've had in a long time! Everyone was friendly and my kids loved it too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Garlic Knots
I usually do not ever have an issue here. The staff is very accommodable; you just have to ask.
It's okay too many children working good pizza sauce nice cheese and the dough as long as it's cooked undercooking I like my pizza bubbling golden brown cheese with a nice Golden crust
I got a small antipasta salad and the size of a small looked like the size of a large salad. It was the best salad I have had in a very long time. Thanks magros in sherburne ny for making my dinner amazing
I have bought pizza from here multiple times and I think the food is great, but the constant yelling (screaming, honestly) at the young girls that work there (from I’m assuming the boss) really messes with the atmosphere in my opinion. It’s incredibly uncomfortable, and you feel bad watching the young girls that are working getting screamed at and belittled for every little thing they don’t do up to his standards. There hasn’t been a single time I’ve bought pizza from there and didn’t hear him yelling or loudly complaining about the girls not doing something right. I’m not sure if it’s a family owned business, or how close the staff are to where that’s normal, but me personally, as a customer it’s very awkward, and makes me not want to go into the establishment. This is my personal opinion and I don’t want to speak for anyone else. I understand under stress at work especially working in a restaurant things can get heated, but it seems like it’s constantly and it’s always the same guy going off the walls on the female staff.
Good food nice atmosphere, wonderful people
Hands down the best pizza I've ever had! Great service and excellent food. You won't find a better pizza place in NY.
Greeted by friendly, smiling faces as soon as we walked in the door. It was quiet here, which I appreciated. The food was great. Will dine here again. Beta fish in vases on the tables were unique and cute touch.
The Pizza is good for the area.
Great quick service spot. The inside was overflowing with tropical flowers which was pretty fun but the tables had little space left for people ha
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Joe & Vinny's/Magro's doesn't disappoint. The atmosphere is cool. There are real plants around & fish in vases on tables. The music was good.
I walked in around 15 mins before they were going to close. The staff were kind, helpful, and attentive. We saw some menus online that differed from the actual menus in store. Salvatore was nice enough to match the price for us. Thank you again, Salvatore & Lou Lou (sp). Best customer service I've ever received. Definitely will return. 100/10 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders, Wings, Pizza by the Slice, Garlic Knots
Restaurantji Recommends
It's ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great pizza! Friendly service, clean and cozy. Just what we needed on a long drive. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Have loved this place since I was a kid, now sharing huge subs and delicious garlic knots with my children. Whenever we're back in the area, we have to stop - even if for nothing more than the knots(with that marinara sauce, of course)!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Antipasto, Calzone, Pizza by the Slice, Sheet Pizza, Garlic Knots
Three times we've stopped in for food since last November. First time my mom and I were just grabbing slices. It was mid afternoon and the place was quiet. We were just coming from a funeral and heading to see my dad who was in the hospital, so we're looking to get something quick to eat. We picked out a couple, paid for the slices and coffee and sat down. The new owner puts the already cooked slices in the oven and forgot about them. When I asked about 15-20 minutes later, they were burnt. He claimed he thought we had left. Said he looked around for us and didn't see us. The place is small. We sat near the coffee counter, since we were both drinking coffee. We were just out of view from the counter where you would order. We watched for the slices to come and he never showed his head around the corner. But he tried to make it up to us by handing back some cash for the trouble. The next time wasn't as bad, I called in an order for calzones to go with sauce in them. They came without sauce, so owner gave me a little plastic to-go container of sauce for them. This last time it is apparent that the new owner needs to get his act together. I called in an order for three calzones plus a large pizza with toppings. Waited 30 minutes before leaving the house to pick up the order. There were three people or groups of people waiting for orders when I got there. The new owner appeared to be busy, running around trying to fix other people's orders that got mixed up. There was one guy making pizzas, a couple of girls making appetizers and subs and another employee who was trying to do his own job in the back plus help customers up front. Owner tells the guy to "Don't worry about her.". The guy apologizes and goes to try help the owner who was trying to fix other people's orders first. Owner definitely needs classes on how to treat the employees. Yelled at the girls making subs, wings, whatever. "I've told you three times you need to bag subs and appetizers together so people get their orders!". Personally, I don't think a cold sub should be placed in a plastic bag with hot foods. The items were wrapped in paper bags with order slips stapled to them. When they get the other orders cleared up, the one guy asks what I ordered. Checked around, had found three calzones in a box. Okay, good. But then looked for the pizza and only found two cheese pizzas. No pizzas in the oven ready to come out, only a sheet pizza about ready to go in the oven. Our large pizza with toppings was not there. Owner throws some cold toppings on the pizza and stuffs it in the oven and tells me he'll take some money off the bill to make up for it then disappears. Maybe if the owner did a little more hands on work and paid attention to what he was doing rather than running around and putting blame on the employees, the place would run nicer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
We loved this place! Best pizza we've had in a long time! Everyone was friendly and my kids loved it too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Garlic Knots
Loading...