Gerardo’s Pizza and Pasta

Maybe you should change your hours of business, that way when people come in at 11:23, meanwhile it says open at 11 and your door is open, you don't get greeted by a rude employee. I order from here alot, but being treated like this, I will give my money to another pizza place that deserves it .

Not the best pizza ever but

I've been there twice now and consistently their pizza is very good. I've tried a few different types . the owner jerry is a wonderful man. The meatballs were very good. And the sausage and peppers were good as recommend this place

We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pizza came to $26. I understand inflation and the prices of everything are more now. The pizza was lacking in toppings and was undercooked. We had maybe a chicken cutlet worth of chicken on the entire pizza and the bacon was almost non existent. There are other places in town that can execute a chicken bacon ranch pizza much better. I will give another shot though it was mediocre.

Great pizza. The regular looked amazing and it was. Every bite had that perfect crunch. Definitely will be back

This was somehow my 1st visit. Ordered a chicken roll, fresh made, absolutely delicious! Thanks guys! Will be back!

They pizza is really good…but the last time I went there my pizza was like burnt and hard and I was just really confused

This place is terrible. They packaged my food so carelessly it spilled everywhere. Everytime I go there I have to wait twenty minutes to get my food after I already call in and give them almost an hour everytime. And the shrimp parm was absolutely disgusting. The sauce was greasy and the breading was mushy and gross on the shrimp. This pizza place sucks.

Order from here once or twice a week, like clockwork. Mostly the same thing every time, but the consistency is always on point. Friendly staff, the pasta dishes and heroes are great. Haven't used a different spot in a few years, nor do I plan to. Highly recommend to everyone who asks.

My first time there and was very impressed. Pizza was cooked exactly the way I like it. Sauce was not acidic and pepperoni was delicious. Thank you I will be back.

Kid-friendliness: Owner was very friendly and the lady behind the counter was very pleasant.

Parking: Plenty of parking

It took a long time to get a pie. The pie had hardly any sauce or topping for a pretty expensive price. Was better years ago. Not sure what happened. I'll try again but was pretty unhappy.

We ordered 10 pizza pies for my sons birthday and they were all made perfectly. Everyone had amazing things to say. Excited to order here again!

Looked for a good pizza place in Shirley/Mastic. This is one of those places the food is fresh and over all the have great slices.

This place is the best! The pizza is absolutely amazing! I'm a serious pizza cridic and I am in love with this pizza!

This pizza place is amazing great prices and employees were extremely nice. WOULD 100% go back:)