Bagel Lady Cafe

99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham
(631) 744-0071

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Francis DeNicola

Amazing bagels and sandwiches! Always fresh and sassy!

Allie

Expensive and the quality of the food has plummeted. I used to love this place but it’s not even close to the same anymore. I kept giving it another chance and trying it again and this last time was awful not to mention the absolutely ridiculous prices. I will never go here again and I was a regular customer but no more chances.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Lucas Lindaman

Good local bagel and sandwich shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Drumdudeck

There were quite a few bones in the lox. The staff kept skipping the next person in line and taking other people's orders instead. Very slow service. Undrinkable chai tea. Staff tried charging higher prices than what the menu listed using "custom items" and typing in a different price. Very expensive ($20 per person for a medium drink and a bagel).

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

AJ Levitt

My favorite bagel store in Suffolk. Only thing better than the food is the service.

Bill Condy

No bathroom

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Zack Lodi

Whoever says the food here isn’t amazing is lying. We come up from Florida every summer and make it a point to eat here at least 3-4 times every trip. Bagels and breakfast sandwiches are the best you’ll ever find and they’re always happy to see us and serve us! See you next year

Food: 5

Holly Quinn

Bagels are stale/hard. Do not taste fresh.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Allison Lewis

Food was delicious but waited a bit

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels

kathleen stuck

The best tasting bagels around.Tastiest vegetable cream cheese.Love this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels, Muffins, Salad, Dozen Bagels, Bagel with cc Bacon, 1 lb Egg Salad

Erin Ann McGuire

Best bagels and salads are sooooo good!!!!

jeremy smyth

The owner is absolutely the loveliest lady ever. We felt like we were at home eating with family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Country Platter

C E

Lovely little place. After over 24 hours on planes and busses we arrived into town about 30 minutes before closing and they happily served us delicious sandwiches even while cleaning up. Owner Meena is such a sweetheart she asked about our trip and we sat and talked for a short while about family and travel just very warm and inviting. Will definitely be my bagel place everytime I’m on the island. Thank you again! -Casey and Rare

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels, Dozen Bagels, blt

Wilson Barrera

I’m not the one To write a review, but customer service Is really poor in this place. I went there this morning. We order a Couple things and some coffee, When we got the coffee, the lady that took our order Did It wrong, We order five coffees three of them no sugar and two of them with sugar, Obviously I Wanted her to make new coffees since we didn’t order that she proceeded To scream and said “is this a joke” I told her how is it a joke if We ask for coffee, no sugar. She proceed to keep on screaming, on topOf that she forgot to charge us for a cake that we had order; which I asked this other gentleman For the cake, and out of nowhere she comes and screams “they didn’t pay for that charge them for it” like I was going to steal the cake? very nasty lady she was in her late 40s, you guys should really reconsider her if you guys want to keep customers because All she does is scare away customers.

Barbara Clasen

Went in today to get french toast bagel for my daughter. They did not have them today but when I told the owner my daughter was requesting them and we were leaving tonight for UK. She told me to come back and she made the bagels for me and gave me extra. Such an act of kindness. In this crazy world this lets me know there are still such wonderful humans out there. Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...