Bagel Lady Cafe
99 NY-25A #18, Shoreham
(631) 744-0071
Customers' Favorites
Bagel with cc Bacon
Country Platter
1 lb Egg Salad
Dozen Bagels
Egg Sandwich
Muffins
Cookies
Roll
blt
Other Items
Lox+ CC w\ onion and tomato
Bagel with LOX spread
Bagel with Flavor CC + Bacon
Bagel with CC + Bacon
Side Salad
Mini Bagel
Newsday Newspaper (Sunday)
Newday Newspaper (Mon-Saturday)
Croissant
Muffins
Pastry
Nova And Cream Cheese On Bagel
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese
Buttered Bagel
Dozen Bagels
Half Dozen Bagels
Roll (Plain)
Bagel (Plain)
Cream Cheese
1/2 Lox Spread
1/4 Lox Spread
1/2 lb Butter
1/2 lb Buffalo Mac Salad
1/2 lb Coleslaw
1/2 lb Potato Salad
1/2 lb Mac Salad
1 lb Buffalo Macaroni Salad
1 lb Coleslaw
1 lb Potato Salad
1 lb Macaroni Salad
1/2 lb Whitefish
1/2 lb Egg Salad
1/2 Tuna Salad
1/2 lb Chicken Salad
1 lb Whitefish
1 lb Egg Salad
1 lb Tuna Salad
1 lb Chicken Salad
1 lb Flavored CC
1 lb Plain CC
1/4 lb Flavored CC
1/2 lb Flavored CC
1/4 lb Plain
1/2 lb Plain CC
Breakfast
Steak, Egg and Cheese
Lumberjack (3 Eggs )
Morning Brunch ( 3 Eggs )
Country Platter ( 2 Eggs )
Egg Sandwich
Egg Sandwich (1 Egg)
Lumber Jack ( 2 Eggs )
Morning Brunch ( 2 Eggs )
Country Platter ( 3 Eggs )
Omelettes
Create Your Own
L.E.O.
Veggie Omelette
Italian Omelette
Spanish Omelette
Greek Omelette
Western Omelette
Just Pancakes Or French Toast
French Toast (3)
Pancakes (3)
French Toast (2)
Pancakes (2)
Senior Lunch Special
Senior Lunch Special
Breakfast Wraps
#3. Mushrooms, Onions, Spinach & A Touch Of Parmesan
#2. Baby Spinach, Onions, Tomato & Sprinkle Of Feta
#1. Alpine Lace Swiss, Tomato and Baby Spinach
Slender Selection Sandwiches
Sassy Southwest
True Bleu
Greek Treat
Slim Monterey
Trim California
Sassy Grilled Chicken
Light Waldorf Chicken Salad
Light Veggie Tuna
Very Veggie Wraps
Very Veggie California
Very Veggie Venice
Very Veggie San Jose
Very Veggie Ventura
Very Veggie Mediterranean
Very Veggie Tex Mex
Sassy Salads
Chopped Meditteranean Salad
Chopped Blue Cheese Salad
Chopped Cafe Salad
Catalina Salad
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Spinach Salad
Greek Salad
Waldorf Chicken Salad
Santa Fe Salad
Sonoma Salad
Asian Salad
Harvest Salad
Sassy Signature Salad
Jubilee Spinach Salad
Sassy House Salad
Signature Sandwiches
Chicken Cutlet Roll
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Hampton
Sienna
Monterey
Sunset
Turkey Club
The Duke
Black And Bleu
Balsamic Beef
Sedona
Continental
Waldorf Chicken
Sorrento
Harvest Chicken
Grilled Chicken Caesar
Florentine
Chicken Club
Chicken Fajita
Tuscan
Roma
Awesome Grilled Cheese
#10. Fajita w\Pepperjack Cheese, Cheddar, Roasted Peppers & Onions
#9. Jalapeno Peppers W\Cheddar, Cream Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers
#8. Fontina W\ Mushrooms & Sundried Tomatoes
#7. Feta, Mozzarella, Tomato, Kalamata Olives
#6. Fresh Mozzarella, Avocado & Bacon
#5. Provolone With Spinach And Artichoke Spread
#4. Cheddar, Grilled Granny Smith Apples & Bacon
#3. Mozzarella & Parmesan Cheese W\tomato Bruschetta
#2. Cheddar, Bacon, Avocado
#1. Fontina, Mushrooms, Roasted Red Peppers & Red Onion
Classic Cafe Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken
BLT
Grilled Cheese ( Any Variety )
Boars Head Roast Beef
Boars Head Turkey Sandwich
Boars Head Ham Sandwich
Liverwurst Sandwich
Bologna Sandwich
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Coffee
Box Of Coffee
Extra Large Coffee
Large Coffee
Medium Coffee
Small Coffee
Juice
96 Oz Tropicana
Martinelli Apple Juice
Orange Juice Cartons
Naked Juice
Kombucha
Half Gallon Juice
Large Juice
Small Tropicana
Lattes
Large Latte
Medium Latte
Small Latte
Frappucino
Large Frappacino
Small Frappacino
Smoothie
Extra Large Shake
Large Shake
Medium Shake
Small Shake
Extra Large Smoothie
Large Smoothie
Medium Smoothie
Small Smoothie
Soda
Regular Soda
Water
Smart Water
1 Liter Water
Sport Water
Water
Lunch Combos
#3 Lunch Combo- 1\2 Pannini and Small Sassy House Salad
#2 Lunch Combo- 1\2 Wrap and Small Sassy House Salad
#1 Lunch Combo- Small Soup And Small Sassy House Salad
Beverages
Body Armor
V8
EBoost
Honest Tea
Red Bull 16 oz
Monster Energy
Nesquik
Yoo-Hoo
Coconut Water
Pellegrino
Bai
Yogurt Drink
Yerba Beverage
Regular Red Bull 12oz
Small Red Bull 8.4 oz
Pure Leaf Iced Tea
Soda
Santa Fe Beverage
Arizona Tea
Snapple Iced Tea
Vitamin Water
Gatorade
Iced Teas
Extra Large Iced Coffee
Large Iced Coffee
Medium Iced Coffee
Small Iced Coffee
Extra Large Iced Tea
Large Iced Tea
Medium Iced Tea
Small Iced Tea
Breakfast Special
Flavor CC Special
CC Special
Butter Special
Breakfast Special ( Mon-Friday 5:30am-10am)
Breakfast Sides
Large Home Fries
Small Home Fries
French Toast BF
Pancake BF
Chips
Lays,Doritos,Snyders
Sun Chips
North Fork Chips
Herrs Chips
Soup
Large Chili
16 Oz Soup
12 Oz Soup
Small Chili
Cookies
Cookies
Gluten Free Pastry
Gluten Free Pastry
Meena's Pastries
Coconut Cranberry Cookie
Meena's Pastries
Candy
Peanuts
Halls
Tic Tac
Airheads
Blowpop
Milano Cookie
M&Ms
Alka Seltzer
Nature Valley
Menthos
Pringles
Sunflowe Seeds
Starburst
Ring Pop
5 Hour Energy
Pistachios
Oreos
Swedish Fish
Chewing Gum
Reeses
Twix
Kit Kat
Almond Joy
Arizona Fruit Snacks
Fig Newtons
Cakebites
Coffee Cake
Snowballs
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Our favorite bagel spot on Long Island! We travel from upstate New York and when on the island we go to the bagel shop every morning for the most delicious bagels, tasty cream cheese, and amazing iced coffee with coffee ice cubes! Best place to go!
February 2026
absolutely amazing. i’ve been coming here for over 10 years. best bagel place in all of suffolk, and the owner is sweet as can be! ❤️ and always there! never a day off!! ❤️
December 2025
My husband (Tony) went to buy 2 dozen bagels Christmas morning with cream cheese and butter for the homeless in mastic representing Home Church in Mastic and Meena graciously donated everything for free. What a blessing she was to many people.
Thank you Meena and John
Have a wonderful blessed New Year!
Thank you Meena and John
Have a wonderful blessed New Year!
December 2025
You May Also Like
eat + drink - Shoreham Plaza, 99 Rte 25A
![]()
American, Bar, Tapas/Small Plates, New American
PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA - 99 NY-25A #4
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian, Vegan
Osaka Japanese Restaurant - Shoreham Plaza, 99 Rte 25A
![]()
Japanese, Vegetarian