Gavin’s

12 Division St, Sidney
(607) 563-2697

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cheryl Otero

4 of us lady friends went inside to order pizza to bring home for a late dinner after our meeting. There was no long waiting. It was a good tasting pizza, but I've had better.

Ryan B

The best pizza outside of NYC! Love their wings too!

My family loved the food and fast service.

Laurie Williams

Ordered a family stromboli this evening, it was the best we had in a long time. It was filled to the max. Very delicious and filling.

Carlene Quintin

I have to say that I do like Gavin‘s food but the service that I have had has not been so well. There are some nice people that work there, but there is an older lady that worked last night that answers the phone and happens to be very miserable, very rude and very unaccommodating. First, you spend $15 for a dozen wings and they won’t split them to get two flavors, but they’ll send them to you naked with the two sauces. Why can’t they just shake them up and do a split order, like every where else? Why did I get such a bad attitude just for asking? I was being very nice and very polite. Really I got a bad attitude from the minute she answered the phone tonight. To top that off, I ordered a Philly cheesesteak and my daughter does not like onions. I asked her if she could not add onions on the second half of the sub. She got very irritated and she “Well, he doesn’t do that. He either puts them on the whole thing or none at all!” So I’m spending a bunch of money on an order and I get a very very bad attitude and not a single accommodation. That’s not right. I was very nice and just ordered it like she said to and left it at that. I just didn’t deserve that. Honestly, if my daughter did not want wings so bad, I probably just would’ve canceled my order and ordered somewhere else. I don’t know what is wrong with customer service these days, but honestly, if you don’t like working with customers, you can’t be friendly and let alone accommodating, well then you shouldn’t be in this field! Whatever happened to treating people the way you wish to be treated? 🙁

sheila rose

By far the BEST pizza in all of new york!!!

Misty Paiement

This is the best restaurant to go to if you crave pizza or wings. Really really good family restaurant and always accommodating. I’d love to support local businesses, and this is well worth it!

Jamie Mullineaux

Definitely the best subs around.

Loon’s Drive Alt

Dominos? Papa johns? Get outta here!
Gavin’s is where it’s at!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kelsey Loiselle

Amazing restaurant, staff is incredibly friendly, Have so many options to choose from!!!

Ann Harvis

Ordered 3 hours ahead of time, food was hot, accurate, excellent pizza and wings

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball Sandwich, Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, Sausage and Pepper Pizza, Cheese Pizza Slice, Steak Pizza

Susan Waltke

CELIAC FRIENDLY!!! Myhusband and I stopped in today as we were passing by. We have been there before and knew they have excellent pizza. Today was our first time stopping in since my celiac diagnosis. I asked for a gluten free pizza. I was given the option of regular gluten free crust or cauliflower. I got the regular with garlic white sauce and pickles. They asked if it was for an allergy. The man making the pizza changed his gloves. When my pizza came out, it was in its own metal tray. So I'm confident in their knowledge on food allergies and I'm not worried about cross contamination. And as always- the food it excellent!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Remo Radicchi

Employees very friendly and food was good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis Daskalakis

I had a calzone and a veggie pizza that had feta cheese on it. I was really impressed by both. Especially the slice of pizza, because I haven't had feta cheese on a slice before and this was excellent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Quadrio

Mike runs a great pizzeria! The food is great and a nice place to stop for lunch for a quick slice or a pepperoni roll.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Troy

Pizza is kinda mid compared to Joe & Vinny's. Not bad for the area, however.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Loading...