Martucci's Restaurant

8074 Lake Shore Dr, Silver Bay
(518) 543-6528

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bridget Finster

The best part was the beautiful night and boat ride to the restaurant, Everything was a rush. We ordered drinks at the bar and before we even got our drinks to sit and enjoy the view we were rushed inside. We never saw our waitress. I mean not once. Kitchen staff placed food. We asked for ketchup and never received it. We wanted more drinks but again never saw a waitress. There were no more than three other tables seated. We were never offered dessert. I had to ask for the check. Food was ok. Very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Mary McLaughlin

Matucci’s is a one of a kind rare experience! We love the atmosphere, beautiful views, fabulous food and the bar and porch are great fun! Thanks Dave! Keep up the excellent work!

Greg Myers

Old Adirondack lodge with a very cozy atmosphere and a reliably delicious traditional 3-course dinner. Fresh greens salad, perfect cup of soup. The pork chop entree was cooked to perfection with surprisingly good mashed potatoes and squash medley sides. Nothing pretentious, just executed very well. If it ain't broke don't fix it!

Kid-friendliness: There are additional, unadvertised kids' menu items.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madeline

A peaceful and unique dining experience with wonderful lake views. Upon arrival, we were told to choose our entrees with the host and then grab our drinks at the bar and enjoy the back deck.

I had an extremely healthy glass of wine for ~13$. The evening lake atmosphere is just what we wanted to pair with our drinks.

We did feel the courses (bread, salad, soup, entrees) were too rushed. The stuffed flounder was superb, though! The dining room was a bit stuffy and small, but we relaxed after dinner outside again. Such a lovely evening!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle Bgagn

I was passing through and decided to stop here for breakfast. The lodge is quaint and the restaurant has a nice view of the lake. The service was great - the servers made sure to stop by and ask about my meal and if I needed anything. Overall I really enjoyed my experience here today.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Powell

Went to Martucci’s tonight for dinner - the atmosphere is awesome and the food was great! I love the place! We will be back with friends for sure!

G2826JFamandal

Dave would not give me a room due to the fact that I have seizures. He said he didn't want ambulances at his resort. He was very rude on the phone, wasn't professional. He sounded like he had been drinking while he was working

joebB7157CX

Had a very nice dinner and drinks. Had a party of 8 and were easily accommodated. Had pork chops and mashed potatoes, salmon and stuffed shells pasta dish. Plenty to eat. Recommend and will visit again.

Phil Reinfried

Love this restaurant great food and a nice bar

Mike Palmer

It was built by Greg the pig martucci using undeserved board of Ed pension money. I have a score to settle from McManus middle school

Nicole Strazzeri Zimmerman

The food is fantastic, no matter what you order!!

Erin Morrison

I love the Northern Lake George resort and their restaurant! Intimate, lodge atmosphere, simple yet delicious food and drinks right on the water. They grow a lot of veggies fresh at the lodge. Family run, relaxing place to stay and eat. Sit by the indoor fireplace or out on the deck.

Loading...