Pizza is insanely good. Thin and crunchy, super fresh. The owners are frequently there and they clearly are passionate about this spot being great. Incredible tap list, pretty slammin Caesar salad. Always jammin 90’s rock, what’s not to love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon Donoher
Solid bar pie! Plus great salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Oil Pizza
Carolyn F.
I had a medical appointment nearby and was looking for a place to have a late lunch/early supper. I checked Yelp and saw some mixed reviews, but thought I'd give it a chance. STREET PARKING. Keep in mind that there is street parking only. Because it was after the lunch rush, I did find a parking space nearby. The restaurant/bar was basically empty with a few stragglers - one at the bar and one at the high top. The greeting was pleasant, although I initiated it. I wish restaurants would take on more initiative when a patron enters. I digress. I was told I could sit anywhere and asked if I'd like a drink. I ordered a non-alcoholic beverage made with a ginger beer and pineapple base. It was refreshing but not worth $8.00 that's OK. It did quench my thirst The waitress was very pleasant and friendly. I explained that I had allergies and she made a recommendation of the vegetable pizza which sounded great. I also ordered the mozzarella appetizer and asked to make sure there was no onion or garlic. She said she would serve it plain. She told me she would communicate my allergies to the kitchen and I believed her. DETAILS MAKE THE DIFFERENCE . I was the only customer yet the appetizer was brought out on a bed of spicy garlic marinara sauce. That had to be returned to the kitchen, so the restaurant lost money and I could have been made ill. She apologized and had them make it over. I'm sure the chef or cook was not pleased. THEY WERE NOT OFF TO A GOOD START. Surely that would be the last time an allergy mistake was made, right? Wrong. My to go order - Rockefeller salad at 17 bucks was full of onions. The only way I found out was taking it out to take a photograph for yelp. Only then did the waitress rush over to check the contents. Through much of my youth, I waited tables and was a server for catering events, banquets, etc. It is the responsibility of the server to verify that everything is perfect before it leaves the kitchen. Communication is the most important job of any server. Unfortunately, as pleasant and friendly as she was, This was a major fail of service. She went from five stars down to three stars only because she was so pleasant. I was given the check offered my credit card and was about to leave when I realized I did not have my takeout order. Another fail. Would I return to this restaurant? I'm afraid not the pizza was interesting but the prices were quite high and the food was too risky for me. Recap: location on Main Street Tarrytown is very pleasant. This is really more of a bar than a restaurant so set your expectations. The menu is quite small. Quality of ingredients was very good. Friendliness was very good. Execution of allergy requirements was a complete fail.
Kaylyn C.
We went here for my birthday the pizzas were delicious and had a thin crust so you didn't feel bad eating them... for the carb watchers. Our waiter was the best! He kept checking in on us to make sure we were okay. It gets a tad crowded on the weekend, so go early.
Roger B.
5 stars for pizza hooray! I am so excited to have found this place. I was looking for something easy and quick but found a place I wish I could have enjoyed for hours on end. The vibe is that of a beer bar - long wooden traditional bar top with 4-top tables along the back wall and a bit of a bigger seating area towards the back. It's clean and comfortable but still retains the right vibe. The bartender handled our service and could not have been nicer - in addition to keeping our waters full the whole time. Ordered the fried mozz, the hot oil pie and the hot honey pie. Would do it all over again if my stomach didn't hurt so bad today. This place is a slam dunk.
David H.
Pizza 10/10 Beer 10/10 Buffalo wings 10/10 Ceasar salad 10/10 Special pizzas always good but hot honey is my go to. This is my go to spot around here to hang out have some beers and watch a game. Always playing good music and the two owners are awesome. Chill dudes, beleive they are brothers, and always have a good time
Derek Henson
The Beekman Ave pizza was amazing. It had a great slow burn and really hit the spot on a cold rainy day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: The Beekman Ave Pizza
Mathew Uckele
Great thin crust Detroit style pizza and great beer selection. Definitely would come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Beekman Ave Pizza
john stiloski
Had white pizza was off the
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Hot Honey Pizza
Wyn Clayton (Wyn Something)
It was late in the evening, was super hungry and needed a quick bite. The pizza was delicious so crispy and full of flavor. Had a drink as well. Great music. Service was fantastic. Atmosphere was incredible. Will stop by again!
Found out about these tavern pizzas from a Wash. Post article which rated it the best in the US. I couldn't agree more. Feel so lucky to be 10 minutes away. I had the white pizza which was incredibly tasty with different veggies and the best sausage I've ever had. My companion had the vegetable pizza with red sauce which was not as good and she was sorry she didn't order the white pizza. I also had a light ale (can't remember the name!!) also delicious. This is a nice find as the only other great pizza in the area is Main St. Pizza in Tarrytown.
Michael Geoghegan
Great pub! Pizza and wings are a go to. Craft beer menu with lots from the northeast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob K.
So this place was awesome -- really awesome. If there was a 4.5 rating, I'd give that. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the pizza wasn't AS GOOD as it was hyped to be. To be clear -- it was definitely very good. But maybe one step short of great? The place itself is a cozy pub / ale house vibe. Nice selection of beers. We started with the garlic knots which were soft, doughy, chewy, and perfectly garlicky. Prob the best I've ever had. Very delicious red sauce on the side. We also had the Rockefeller salad. Rare I'd highlight a salad but this was one of the best salads I've had. Their chicken cutlet that comes on it was bananas. Perfect chicken cutlet in my opinion. Amazing salad. For pizza we got a regular cheese and the spicy one (chicken cutlet, Fresno peppers, hot honey). The regular was very good. Kind of a cross between thin crust and pan pizza, really delicious. The spicy one was very good too but honestly too spicy. I really like spice but the fresnos were crazy spicy, so unless you have a really high tolerance for heat, stay away from this one. Overall, great meal and would return in a heartbeat!
Stephen Coleman
The pizza is thin yet soft & chewy!Magic!Good work, magic pizza!
One of our favorite local spots! The servers are always very nice and attentive. And the food is to die for - the garlic knots are our favorite. Restaurant is cozy and inviting. The vibes are superb.
Pizza is insanely good. Thin and crunchy, super fresh. The owners are frequently there and they clearly are passionate about this spot being great. Incredible tap list, pretty slammin Caesar salad. Always jammin 90’s rock, what’s not to love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Solid bar pie! Plus great salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Oil Pizza
I had a medical appointment nearby and was looking for a place to have a late lunch/early supper. I checked Yelp and saw some mixed reviews, but thought I'd give it a chance. STREET PARKING. Keep in mind that there is street parking only. Because it was after the lunch rush, I did find a parking space nearby. The restaurant/bar was basically empty with a few stragglers - one at the bar and one at the high top. The greeting was pleasant, although I initiated it. I wish restaurants would take on more initiative when a patron enters. I digress. I was told I could sit anywhere and asked if I'd like a drink. I ordered a non-alcoholic beverage made with a ginger beer and pineapple base. It was refreshing but not worth $8.00 that's OK. It did quench my thirst The waitress was very pleasant and friendly. I explained that I had allergies and she made a recommendation of the vegetable pizza which sounded great. I also ordered the mozzarella appetizer and asked to make sure there was no onion or garlic. She said she would serve it plain. She told me she would communicate my allergies to the kitchen and I believed her. DETAILS MAKE THE DIFFERENCE . I was the only customer yet the appetizer was brought out on a bed of spicy garlic marinara sauce. That had to be returned to the kitchen, so the restaurant lost money and I could have been made ill. She apologized and had them make it over. I'm sure the chef or cook was not pleased. THEY WERE NOT OFF TO A GOOD START. Surely that would be the last time an allergy mistake was made, right? Wrong. My to go order - Rockefeller salad at 17 bucks was full of onions. The only way I found out was taking it out to take a photograph for yelp. Only then did the waitress rush over to check the contents. Through much of my youth, I waited tables and was a server for catering events, banquets, etc. It is the responsibility of the server to verify that everything is perfect before it leaves the kitchen. Communication is the most important job of any server. Unfortunately, as pleasant and friendly as she was, This was a major fail of service. She went from five stars down to three stars only because she was so pleasant. I was given the check offered my credit card and was about to leave when I realized I did not have my takeout order. Another fail. Would I return to this restaurant? I'm afraid not the pizza was interesting but the prices were quite high and the food was too risky for me. Recap: location on Main Street Tarrytown is very pleasant. This is really more of a bar than a restaurant so set your expectations. The menu is quite small. Quality of ingredients was very good. Friendliness was very good. Execution of allergy requirements was a complete fail.
We went here for my birthday the pizzas were delicious and had a thin crust so you didn't feel bad eating them... for the carb watchers. Our waiter was the best! He kept checking in on us to make sure we were okay. It gets a tad crowded on the weekend, so go early.
5 stars for pizza hooray! I am so excited to have found this place. I was looking for something easy and quick but found a place I wish I could have enjoyed for hours on end. The vibe is that of a beer bar - long wooden traditional bar top with 4-top tables along the back wall and a bit of a bigger seating area towards the back. It's clean and comfortable but still retains the right vibe. The bartender handled our service and could not have been nicer - in addition to keeping our waters full the whole time. Ordered the fried mozz, the hot oil pie and the hot honey pie. Would do it all over again if my stomach didn't hurt so bad today. This place is a slam dunk.
Pizza 10/10 Beer 10/10 Buffalo wings 10/10 Ceasar salad 10/10 Special pizzas always good but hot honey is my go to. This is my go to spot around here to hang out have some beers and watch a game. Always playing good music and the two owners are awesome. Chill dudes, beleive they are brothers, and always have a good time
The Beekman Ave pizza was amazing. It had a great slow burn and really hit the spot on a cold rainy day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: The Beekman Ave Pizza
Great thin crust Detroit style pizza and great beer selection. Definitely would come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Beekman Ave Pizza
Had white pizza was off the
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Hot Honey Pizza
It was late in the evening, was super hungry and needed a quick bite. The pizza was delicious so crispy and full of flavor. Had a drink as well. Great music. Service was fantastic. Atmosphere was incredible. Will stop by again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Found out about these tavern pizzas from a Wash. Post article which rated it the best in the US. I couldn't agree more. Feel so lucky to be 10 minutes away. I had the white pizza which was incredibly tasty with different veggies and the best sausage I've ever had. My companion had the vegetable pizza with red sauce which was not as good and she was sorry she didn't order the white pizza. I also had a light ale (can't remember the name!!) also delicious. This is a nice find as the only other great pizza in the area is Main St. Pizza in Tarrytown.
Great pub! Pizza and wings are a go to. Craft beer menu with lots from the northeast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So this place was awesome -- really awesome. If there was a 4.5 rating, I'd give that. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the pizza wasn't AS GOOD as it was hyped to be. To be clear -- it was definitely very good. But maybe one step short of great? The place itself is a cozy pub / ale house vibe. Nice selection of beers. We started with the garlic knots which were soft, doughy, chewy, and perfectly garlicky. Prob the best I've ever had. Very delicious red sauce on the side. We also had the Rockefeller salad. Rare I'd highlight a salad but this was one of the best salads I've had. Their chicken cutlet that comes on it was bananas. Perfect chicken cutlet in my opinion. Amazing salad. For pizza we got a regular cheese and the spicy one (chicken cutlet, Fresno peppers, hot honey). The regular was very good. Kind of a cross between thin crust and pan pizza, really delicious. The spicy one was very good too but honestly too spicy. I really like spice but the fresnos were crazy spicy, so unless you have a really high tolerance for heat, stay away from this one. Overall, great meal and would return in a heartbeat!
The pizza is thin yet soft & chewy!Magic!Good work, magic pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Plain Cheese Pizza
One of our favorite local spots! The servers are always very nice and attentive. And the food is to die for - the garlic knots are our favorite. Restaurant is cozy and inviting. The vibes are superb.