Awesome little spot. Cuban's very good, the guava and cheese croquet's one of the best things I've ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M. SR
It's a must visit. I went last year with my kids to enjoy sleepy hollow fun October activities and we came across this amazing spot and the atmosphere was amazing, staff was really nice, great service. We went twice within the same day and back the following day to take stuff on the go and their cubano sandwich, delicious. Definitely visiting again this year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Busel LLC
Who needs a plane ticket to Havana? ✈️🇨🇺 Just stop by Croqueteria. Their Cuban sandwich will make your taste buds dance, and the croquettes… oh, they’re impossible to eat just one! 🥪🔥 Highly recommended!
Unassuming place with an absolutely BOMB Cubano. Will be back 🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gerald Ramos
Great Cuban sandwich and a variety of Croquetas. I recommend for anyone looking for a Cuban sandwich and or croquetas to visit this location. I am looking forward to my next visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abel Aguilar
Love this place and the staff excellent place small kind of tiny but fantastic coffee and sandwiches .if only the place was bigger but its nice and cozy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
dave I
8/3/25 first time here, the GF found this place on G Maps. Croqueteria is a nice family run eatery. We had a nice conversation with them and we really loved the food. We split a Cubano and had several croquettes. 2 ham, 2 chicken and 2 guava & cheese. All were really good. Two small tables inside and a couple of tables outside. We will certainly return for more!
Omg! Finally found cubano that is just like what I use to have in Miami. The bread is perfect, flaky crispy crust and soft interior. The pork is well seasoned and made in house. You can taste that the pork has been cooking for many hours. Also, the guava cheese croquettes was addictive. The guava in middle is so fresh and the cheese is like a cheesecake and donut had a baby. I could eat a dozen of those. Also the feta cheese croquette was shockingly good, super flavorful. Will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lawrence Temple
Elite level food. Very friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nissie Pollak
what a lovely little family-owned business... delicious food & very personable staff :)) definitely worth a visit..
Best croquet I've ever had! Pablo is so very friendly :)
If you're visiting Sleepy Hollow and need a tasty snack, make sure to stop by here
CJ Redfern
Good, not great. I've had better cubanos, but this one was decent.
Ed Steinberg
I’ve been there a few times, but recently I brought a group of Cuban musicians there and they also love the food and of course the people there are fabulous
Joseph Tang
My wife and I made this our first stop on our trip from Brooklyn to Ithaca. - Staff was very friendly and courteous. - Food tasted great. We had the Cubano sandwich, steak sandwich, chicken croquet, cafecito, and flan. I'm usually not a fan of Cubano sandwiches but this one hit the spot. Steak sandwich and flan were good. - The cafecito was really great. I loved the taste and strong it was. - The two store owners and us chatted during the downtime. They are lovely folks. - We'll definitely stop by next time we're in Sleepy Hollow. - We recommend Croqueteria!
Jonathan Sonnenberg
Food was good. Haven’t had a cubano in forever. Most Cuban sandwiches up here are mid but this place is a solid choice.
Awesome little spot. Cuban's very good, the guava and cheese croquet's one of the best things I've ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a must visit. I went last year with my kids to enjoy sleepy hollow fun October activities and we came across this amazing spot and the atmosphere was amazing, staff was really nice, great service. We went twice within the same day and back the following day to take stuff on the go and their cubano sandwich, delicious. Definitely visiting again this year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Who needs a plane ticket to Havana? ✈️🇨🇺 Just stop by Croqueteria.
Their Cuban sandwich will make your taste buds dance, and the croquettes… oh, they’re impossible to eat just one! 🥪🔥
Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich, Pulled Pork Sandwich, Chicken Croqueta, Guava Pulled Pork Sandwich, Black Beans, Mushroom \u0026 Garlic, Cod Fish Croqueta
Unassuming place with an absolutely BOMB Cubano. Will be back 🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Cuban sandwich and a variety of Croquetas. I recommend for anyone looking for a Cuban sandwich and or croquetas to visit this location. I am looking forward to my next visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place and the staff excellent place small kind of tiny but fantastic coffee and sandwiches .if only the place was bigger but its nice and cozy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
8/3/25 first time here, the GF found this place on G Maps.
Croqueteria is a nice family run eatery.
We had a nice conversation with them and we really loved the food. We split a Cubano and had several croquettes. 2 ham, 2 chicken and 2 guava & cheese. All were really good.
Two small tables inside and a couple of tables outside.
We will certainly return for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich, Chicken Croqueta
Omg! Finally found cubano that is just like what I use to have in Miami. The bread is perfect, flaky crispy crust and soft interior. The pork is well seasoned and made in house. You can taste that the pork has been cooking for many hours.
Also, the guava cheese croquettes was addictive. The guava in middle is so fresh and the cheese is like a cheesecake and donut had a baby. I could eat a dozen of those. Also the feta cheese croquette was shockingly good, super flavorful.
Will definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elite level food. Very friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
what a lovely little family-owned business... delicious food & very personable staff :)) definitely worth a visit..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best croquet I've ever had!
Pablo is so very friendly :)
If you're visiting Sleepy Hollow and need a tasty snack, make sure to stop by here
Good, not great. I've had better cubanos, but this one was decent.
I’ve been there a few times, but recently I brought a group of Cuban musicians there and they also love the food and of course the people there are fabulous
My wife and I made this our first stop on our trip from Brooklyn to Ithaca.
- Staff was very friendly and courteous.
- Food tasted great. We had the Cubano sandwich, steak sandwich, chicken croquet, cafecito, and flan. I'm usually not a fan of Cubano sandwiches but this one hit the spot. Steak sandwich and flan were good.
- The cafecito was really great. I loved the taste and strong it was.
- The two store owners and us chatted during the downtime. They are lovely folks.
- We'll definitely stop by next time we're in Sleepy Hollow.
- We recommend Croqueteria!
Food was good. Haven’t had a cubano in forever. Most Cuban sandwiches up here are mid but this place is a solid choice.
Loading...