what a lovely little family-owned business... delicious food & very personable staff :)) definitely worth a visit..
Ari Hershkowitz
Best croquet I've ever had! Pablo is so very friendly :)
If you're visiting Sleepy Hollow and need a tasty snack, make sure to stop by here
CJ Redfern
Good, not great. I've had better cubanos, but this one was decent.
Ed Steinberg
I’ve been there a few times, but recently I brought a group of Cuban musicians there and they also love the food and of course the people there are fabulous
Joseph Tang
My wife and I made this our first stop on our trip from Brooklyn to Ithaca. - Staff was very friendly and courteous. - Food tasted great. We had the Cubano sandwich, steak sandwich, chicken croquet, cafecito, and flan. I'm usually not a fan of Cubano sandwiches but this one hit the spot. Steak sandwich and flan were good. - The cafecito was really great. I loved the taste and strong it was. - The two store owners and us chatted during the downtime. They are lovely folks. - We'll definitely stop by next time we're in Sleepy Hollow. - We recommend Croqueteria!
Jonathan Sonnenberg
Food was good. Haven’t had a cubano in forever. Most Cuban sandwiches up here are mid but this place is a solid choice.
Maggie Mizrachi
I'm cuban born!!!! Finally came to this place The croquetas...are absolutely authentic, super delicious and flavorful!! Ham, and chicken wow very yummy!! And the chef and owner has his new creation of guava and cream cheese croquetas...this was a first for me but WOW this was omg delicious delicious!!!!!!
LIZZY
Fantastic and delicious Home made Great family own restaurant
Richard
The best Cuban sandwich anywhere in the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich
Jo Rivera
CROQUETERIA HAS THE BEST CUBAN SANDWICHES! I came from the Bronx took a drive to sleepy Hollow to try it out! Delicious 😋
I was extremely disappointed with my visit to Croqueteria. I had such high hopes from the reviews and was immediately let down as soon as I walked in the door. Was greeted with basically a frown and made to feel like I was there to solicit for something "Can I help you with something"... I immediately said, well, yeah, I'm here to order food... LOL. We also couldn't use the restroom (after a 2 hour drive), even though we were patrons...
The best part...the croquettes were some of the worst. The only salvageable one was the spinach and feta and even that was bland. The chicken one tasted like dog food and made my sister and I feel ill. Even my daughter couldn't finish the sweet pumpkin one.
So, overall.... on top of the unwelcoming attitude and inedible food..... I would never recommend.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Deborah Foglia
The Original Cubano… Crunchy bread on the outside, moist, tasty meats on the inside. Simply delicious. Lovely people and atmosphere! This is the thing cravings are made of. You won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Sampera
Very delicious food. Amazing service. We had ham croquetas and Cuban sandwiches for lunch. The hosts were very accommodating and lovely people. The flan is a must try! Thank you!
what a lovely little family-owned business... delicious food & very personable staff :)) definitely worth a visit..
Best croquet I've ever had!
Pablo is so very friendly :)
If you're visiting Sleepy Hollow and need a tasty snack, make sure to stop by here
Good, not great. I've had better cubanos, but this one was decent.
I’ve been there a few times, but recently I brought a group of Cuban musicians there and they also love the food and of course the people there are fabulous
My wife and I made this our first stop on our trip from Brooklyn to Ithaca.
- Staff was very friendly and courteous.
- Food tasted great. We had the Cubano sandwich, steak sandwich, chicken croquet, cafecito, and flan. I'm usually not a fan of Cubano sandwiches but this one hit the spot. Steak sandwich and flan were good.
- The cafecito was really great. I loved the taste and strong it was.
- The two store owners and us chatted during the downtime. They are lovely folks.
- We'll definitely stop by next time we're in Sleepy Hollow.
- We recommend Croqueteria!
Food was good. Haven’t had a cubano in forever. Most Cuban sandwiches up here are mid but this place is a solid choice.
I'm cuban born!!!! Finally came to this place The croquetas...are absolutely authentic, super delicious and flavorful!! Ham, and chicken wow very yummy!! And the chef and owner has his new creation of guava and cream cheese croquetas...this was a first for me but WOW this was omg delicious delicious!!!!!!
Fantastic and delicious
Home made
Great family own restaurant
The best Cuban sandwich anywhere in the area!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich
CROQUETERIA HAS THE BEST CUBAN SANDWICHES! I came from the Bronx took a drive to sleepy Hollow to try it out! Delicious 😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious sandwiches and handmade croquettes. An excellent choice! 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super friendly staff and amazing food. Those chicken croquetas and the cubano sandwich were soooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cubano Sandwich, Chicken Croqueta
I was extremely disappointed with my visit to Croqueteria. I had such high hopes from the reviews and was immediately let down as soon as I walked in the door. Was greeted with basically a frown and made to feel like I was there to solicit for something "Can I help you with something"... I immediately said, well, yeah, I'm here to order food... LOL. We also couldn't use the restroom (after a 2 hour drive), even though we were patrons...
The best part...the croquettes were some of the worst. The only salvageable one was the spinach and feta and even that was bland. The chicken one tasted like dog food and made my sister and I feel ill. Even my daughter couldn't finish the sweet pumpkin one.
So, overall.... on top of the unwelcoming attitude and inedible food..... I would never recommend.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The Original Cubano…
Crunchy bread on the outside, moist, tasty meats on the inside. Simply delicious.
Lovely people and atmosphere!
This is the thing cravings are made of.
You won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very delicious food. Amazing service. We had ham croquetas and Cuban sandwiches for lunch. The hosts were very accommodating and lovely people. The flan is a must try! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...