I've been to a lot of bagel places through NYC, Jersey, and Westchester, and this little spot is really a great place. Good bagels by themselves, and they also do a good job with putting together their bagel sandwiches as well. Highly recommended!!Vegetarian options: Your standard veg bagel options, and they make a particularly good egg and cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank Lofaro
Nice little shop. Bagels are ok, good to have this option close to my mother's house. Carvel icecream brings back memories.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Egg Everything
Donal Mc Fadden
This gem was well received when we came across it. A wide selection available for choice. These can only be described as delicious. Set us up nicely for the day exploring Tarrytown. Dessert after did also did not disappoint. Service was fantastic and very knowledgeable about local area and where to visit. If you get a chance definitely visit!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Everything Bagel with Bacon Egg and Cheese
Summer R.
Horseman Bagels has the most incredible bagels I've ever had! They are hot and fresh with the most perfect soft, doughiness while still having the perfect soft, yet crisp outside! We devoured plain bagels and rosemary garlic bagels. They were out of this world! The flavor was amazing. The tuna salad and nova were very good, too. The customer service is top notch! The whole staff couldn't be kinder, especially Saeed. They are personable, helpful, and patient. I highly recommend Horeman Bagels!! I would give it 10 stars if I could! If I lived nearby, I would come here for breakfast every single day.
Rissa
First time trying Horseman bagels location. Staff friendly. Bagels soft and very delicious. My Husband had an Everything Bagel, Egg and Extra Cheese. I had a Rainbow Bagel with scallon cream cheese. Two small coffee, great temperature, taste smooth. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Oliver
Stopped by here on a Friday morning and the bagels were fresh and delicious! The woman behind the counter was friendly and put just the right amount of butter on my bagel - on both sides after slicing it! I'm not in this neck of the woods often, but when I am I will be stopping by for more poppy seed bagels! There's a parking lot and they serve coffee and other delectable too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tayler N.
Great bagels! Please sample their Rose Cream Cheese, it's homemade and really amazing!!!
Kalyn E.
Fantastic bagel shop! Come hungry! The bagels are massive! I really love all the options here for a bagel! Staff is great at getting people in and out quickly! Would definitely return if I'm in the area!
Niurka M.
Love this spot! Nothing more comforting than the stag's friendly smiles, their incredible Pumpernickel bagels (I love them with Lox and scallion cream cheese), and the big bright windows. Simple and sweet.
Good bagels. Biga and chewy. Cooked well but not overdone. Good service. Finally theyre open!
Macy T.
Back again for bagels now they are re-open. Carvel also carrys many ice cream cake options. They currently offer gift certificates for any one interested in gifting local treats. Sayeed helped me today and is friendly and warm and happens to be one of the owners.
Athenais A.
What a great bagel shop. Bagels were perfect texture and delicious and the egg salad was very good. I also love that they did not skimp on the amount of salad they added to the bagel. My friend got an egg and cheese on a bagel which she thoroughly enjoyed. A++.
Kenny Shane
Place is clutch! very clean warm and welcoming and best part is the freshness of the bagels. You can tell it's made on the spot unlike a lot of other local bagel spots. This has become my go to I highly recommend the toasted BEC on a bagel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel with Bacon Egg and Cheese
jm
The zaatar bagels are excellent, my first time trying this variety. My daughter loved it. She uses the seasoning for cooking after having it in the Middle East. Many other varieties; also had the delicious croissants. Thank you,
Great bagels! Quick service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been to a lot of bagel places through NYC, Jersey, and Westchester, and this little spot is really a great place. Good bagels by themselves, and they also do a good job with putting together their bagel sandwiches as well. Highly recommended!!Vegetarian options: Your standard veg bagel options, and they make a particularly good egg and cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice little shop. Bagels are ok, good to have this option close to my mother's house. Carvel icecream brings back memories.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Egg Everything
This gem was well received when we came across it. A wide selection available for choice. These can only be described as delicious. Set us up nicely for the day exploring Tarrytown. Dessert after did also did not disappoint. Service was fantastic and very knowledgeable about local area and where to visit. If you get a chance definitely visit!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Everything Bagel with Bacon Egg and Cheese
Horseman Bagels has the most incredible bagels I've ever had! They are hot and fresh with the most perfect soft, doughiness while still having the perfect soft, yet crisp outside! We devoured plain bagels and rosemary garlic bagels. They were out of this world! The flavor was amazing. The tuna salad and nova were very good, too. The customer service is top notch! The whole staff couldn't be kinder, especially Saeed. They are personable, helpful, and patient. I highly recommend Horeman Bagels!! I would give it 10 stars if I could! If I lived nearby, I would come here for breakfast every single day.
First time trying Horseman bagels location. Staff friendly. Bagels soft and very delicious. My Husband had an Everything Bagel, Egg and Extra Cheese. I had a Rainbow Bagel with scallon cream cheese. Two small coffee, great temperature, taste smooth. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped by here on a Friday morning and the bagels were fresh and delicious! The woman behind the counter was friendly and put just the right amount of butter on my bagel - on both sides after slicing it! I'm not in this neck of the woods often, but when I am I will be stopping by for more poppy seed bagels! There's a parking lot and they serve coffee and other delectable too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bagels! Please sample their Rose Cream Cheese, it's homemade and really amazing!!!
Fantastic bagel shop! Come hungry! The bagels are massive! I really love all the options here for a bagel! Staff is great at getting people in and out quickly! Would definitely return if I'm in the area!
Love this spot! Nothing more comforting than the stag's friendly smiles, their incredible Pumpernickel bagels (I love them with Lox and scallion cream cheese), and the big bright windows. Simple and sweet.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good bagels. Biga and chewy. Cooked well but not overdone. Good service. Finally theyre open!
Back again for bagels now they are re-open. Carvel also carrys many ice cream cake options. They currently offer gift certificates for any one interested in gifting local treats. Sayeed helped me today and is friendly and warm and happens to be one of the owners.
What a great bagel shop. Bagels were perfect texture and delicious and the egg salad was very good. I also love that they did not skimp on the amount of salad they added to the bagel. My friend got an egg and cheese on a bagel which she thoroughly enjoyed. A++.
Place is clutch! very clean warm and welcoming and best part is the freshness of the bagels. You can tell it's made on the spot unlike a lot of other local bagel spots. This has become my go to I highly recommend the toasted BEC on a bagel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel with Bacon Egg and Cheese
The zaatar bagels are excellent, my first time trying this variety. My daughter loved it. She uses the seasoning for cooking after having it in the Middle East. Many other varieties; also had the delicious croissants. Thank you,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5