PrimeCut Steakhouse

680 Heiden Rd, South Fallsburg
(845) 434-7000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lyd

Excellent experience all around

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Fitzgerald

Wonderful to have a meat option near the falls.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Meat and Fries

Wigs 1234

The food is delicious the price is very reasonable the service is very pleasant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph W

Service was great! The waiters were very nice! The salad wasn’t great, chicken poppers neither, the burger and also the choc. Babka were great! They price like an upscale restaurant but it’s not there yet.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Izzy S.

(1)Ordered a bowel of Soup @ $12 the soup arrived in a 2/3 oz Remekin. They should really put it on the menu what the size would be. Not to mislead the public. Would I have known it's a 3 oz Remekin I would've never ordered. I don't mind paying the $12. I mind being robbed (2)Asked the waiter for an additional Bread which they start out with. which comes in the size of a Baguette . Each waiter peeked out of the kitchen to see how to detour and bypass our table not to face us by not planning on bringing the Bread. What a lousy stingy niggardly service. (3)we've ordered a Salad. Not as a bonus. The Full $25. But it never showed up.. Honestly I used to enjoy coming here for many years. But it's time to move on to more fair honest restaurants in the catskills.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Education First

Food is good but prices are outrageously high and the portions are very small. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Osh R

Great experience & good service!

D'Ambrosio Hotel Property

Worst place,They don't have even the basic skills how to run a steak house! I'm not even talking about the wait time, which is rediculously long! But simply removing dirty dishes from one course to the next is non-existent, even after asking 2 waiters and the manager to clear the table before next course is served, was simply ignored! We just got up before dessert and left couldn't take this anymore!

Juan Lucero

$50 service fee on top of your bill with understaffed service. Not a great idea unless the owner is trying to put extra money in their pockets. Food was too salty for my taste but that part is just me

joseph herbst

Starting with staffUnder staffed isn’t saying it enough I there were 2 people at the time I walked in and nobody standing at frontNow once seated I was waiting approximately 10 min for someone to take my orderI place my order it took roughly 15-20 just for starters to come outFinally starters arrived and finished sitting and waiting for someone to take off plates from tableAfter another 20 minutes table full of empty ( eaten food ) the bring out my 2 main dishesBut no place on the table due to nobody cleaned it so I needed to hold the main dishes till they cleaned the tableThey didn’t ask if I need anything or more foodAnd even when I asked for my receipt I asked 3 xVERY UNPROFESSIONAL!!Now let’s talk about the foodMy starters were short ribs and dry they tried to polish it with a ton of sauceAnd the meat pizza is just nothing close to good very little meat just all over the placeMy main dish was a medium steak the temperature was good but sadly it didn’t taste good had a boiled taste not seared and bad aftertasteFries was just a chunk of garlic but no other seasoningAnd onion rings were fried way to long was basically close to burntSo overall I had a very bad experience and wouldn’t recommend it

James Dain

So this was just bizarre.. We attempted to find this place and found a gated compound with barbed wire fencing encompassing the entire perimeter of the property. I was unable to figure out how to enter on the property and did not see any movement or traffic in the hotel lobby or driveway entrance. Something is not right here.. pretty convinced this is a fake restaurant. Or once you enter through the security gates, they lock you inside and then you become the prime cut for the night.May god mercy on your soul if you decide to enter this place

leahla Rosenberg

Was there multiple times this summer so attractive the food there is not comparable to any other steakhouse’s!!! Every penny spent was worth! Quick service and nice waitresses! Thank you for the amazing experience! Can’t wait for next summer celebration!

Yachet Adler

Food was delicious and service great. But took very long to get our food.

Harris Lubin

This place is a dump! The lobby and the restaurant smell from chlorine and mold. The menus are filthy. We walked in and walked out within 5 minutes!

A Walter

Food was decent, although, some were over spiced. The portions were very small. I paid 80 dollars for the small rib steak bellow.

Loading...