Cakes by Karen

194 S Union St, Spencerport
(585) 349-7804

Recent Reviews

Melinda Muth

Can't say enough about Karen! We had her make our wedding cake and cupcakes! She's so easy to work with also. Even during covid, she went above and beyond! Everyone raved! We ordered a birthday cake from her also and have had friends who ordered from her after they had our cake/ cupcakes. I'll leave it at that.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacquie Platt

Karen created the most beautiful dreidel cookies for our Chanukah celebration. Not only are the cookies meticulous and gorgeous, they are SCRUMPTIOUS! Thank you so much for doing this for us and on such short notice!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany Valente

The cookies. Are. AMAZING. You won’t regret ordering from Karen!!

Carolyn Sperry

My son's birthday cake looked great and tasted delicious. Everyone was impressed. Thank you Karen!

Alexander Gamcsik

Karen did an outstanding job with our wedding cake and cupcakes. We had sampled a few places, but Karen's had a delicious, homemade sort of quality that stood out among the rest. The cannoli cupcakes and chocolate cupcakes were incredible! She listened to us and made the cake exactly how we wanted it. She even delivered the cake and cupcakes to the venue. Everything turned out wonderful. Thank you!

Leah Baker

Called Karen on short notice for a gender reveal cake and she did not disappoint! She complied with my allergy needs and the cake was beautiful! Everyone thought it was delicious.

April McCloud

I had a variety pack of cakes that were so delicious! The cake was moist and the frosting was amazing. I'm so happy to support this bakery. The owner, Karen, is very friendly and I absolutely support her.

Autumn

Amazing customer service and delicious treats. She's an absolute sweet heart. Great communication and outstanding skills. She bakes all my kids birthday cakes. Highly recommend.

Michelle M

Ordered a birthday cake for my sons first birthday, along with cookies. The cake and cookies not only looked fabulous, but they tastes amazing!! I will definitely be a repeat customer!

audiplanz

Amazing customer service and delicious treats. She's an absolute sweet heart. Great communication and outstanding skills. She bakes all my kids birthday cakes. Highly recommend.

Jim Hy

Karen was communicative and personable. Her cupcakes that we tasted were frosted with a light frosting. The cake itself was moist and delicious.

Tom Marasco

Amazing cake. So much beautiful detail.

Don Echols

Cakes by Karen made the best cake for my child’s graduation!! The sugar cookies were also amazing. The cake was exactly what we asked for.

Paula Straughter

I recently ordered cupcakes and cookies for my daughter graduation dinner. Which was not good. They was dense, dry, tasteless and frosting was horrible. The following day I contacted Karen regarding the issue. I didn't get a response from her until Tuesday asking me not to contact her . Karen never mentioned how she could correct the problem or refund part or all of my money. She simply told me before buying I should first try. Although that was good advise it was rude, thoughtless, not good business practice . If I could rate this honestly it would not be a star.Completely disappointed!!!!!!

Ozden Serin bektaş

Birthday cake was a very hard, very stale, very bad . The cookie was very hard and had an egg smell. Sorry, it all went to the trash, my guests could not eat it.

Load More