McColley's

89 S Union St, Spencerport
(585) 617-4279

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Boneless Chicken Wings

Sweet Potato Wedges

Early Bird Fish Fry

Dill Pickle Pizza

Corned Beef Hash

Reuben Sandwich

Bangers and Mash

Shepard's Pie

Ruben Pizza

Chip Trio

Photos

+87 photos

+86 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We had traveled to Ireland this year and felt like we were back there as soon as we walked in the door. It had the same type of atmosphere. Plenty of room, food and service is good and they have music but not sure when. You can talk without yelling and feel relaxed. As we were leaving it was getting quite busy which tells you the locals really like this place.
We'll be back

December 2025

I have to say that eating at McColley's last night was quite the pleasant experience. I had the Turkey Rueben which was the best I ever had. They use house roasted turkey and it truly makes a huge difference in flavor. My mom had the new menu item Pierogis, Kielbasa and Sauerkraut. Let me tell you how she devoured her meal, which is not very often that she does. The sauerkraut was perfect. Not to sour but still had a wonderful flavor. The servers are the best in the...

December 2025

Everything was very good, food, service, atmosphere. The only thing and this may seem minor to some, but for my husband and I who are retired, when I give $100 to pay for my bill which was $52.92 and only receive $47 in return. Where is the $.08? If you short everyone who pays with cash, the change that you keep, that is not fair. That is a lot of money your establishment is keeping over the year. Just saying. If your establishment doesn’t keep change, then be courteous...

July 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Spencerport, NY

McColley's

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

McColley's