Stay away, its never been that good of a pizza place but for a while now it takes the cake of how are they still open!? Disgusting and
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Brian Galland
Always top notch ?
Emily Bommelje
Amazing Every time! Worth the wait in gold!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Gina B.
I called in my order and the man on the phone taking my order seemed like I was putting him out calling my order in! We ordered a large pizza, light sauce, 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 plain cheese. When we get there, there is a sign on the register 'Cash Only'. Now, I thought why did this grown man taking my order not tell me on the phone. A surprising coincidence they have an ATM in the store. Are they getting a cut of the ATM surcharge? Luckily I had enough cash. The pizza was flat and looked like old dough was used. The crust took up about 2 inches of the pizza, then about 1 inch of just dried red sauce. With a light sprinkle of cheese in the center. Only a few pepperonis were on half. Across the street behind the firehouse is the best pizza Rochester has had since Bay and Goodman pizza... Perri's. So- pass by Pizza Shack and go directly to Perri's!
Ron Just Digging Life
Love it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bill R.
Got a great medium pie with a couple toppings for under twenty bucks. That's a great deal in 2023! Pizza was good, will definitely return
Takierra E.
New to the area so I’ve been trying the local pizza places nearby. This was my 3rd new place that my family and I have tried out and we have found our new pizza home. The food was delicious pizza was delicious sauce was awesome. The wings were the best that I’ve had in this area to date. Asked to fry hard and they were fried just right and not too tough. We will definitely be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Knapp
This place is a hidden gem! The pizza was excellent. The prices here are reasonable + actually less expensive than what other places are charging. Everything is fresh made, including dough and sauce - mozzarella is fresh sliced right there. The owner is a really good guy & cares about his food and customers. It's not the fanciest of places, but the food and prices more than make up for it! They have a good sized menu with decent variety - you'll find something that you'll like. Bring right on West Ridge Rd. makes getting in & out (especially out) a bit of a pain, so it's a good idea to plan your visit when traffic is lighter. I will definitely be going back here - now one of my go-to pizza shops!
Wow .. all I can say, this pizza was succulent, fresh, and amazing. Might be the best pizza I ever had ? HIGHLY RECOMMEND. Well done thin to perfection. I think Dave Portnoy would score this extremely high himself. Best in 585 definitely will be a reoccurring customer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steveol
So, personally, I've never ordered here before, I honestly probably should soon. I get a lot of DD/ Ubereats orders here. Every time I arrive, the staff are amazing and very friendly. One thing I appreciate about the staff, is the honesty, if I have to wait for a order to be done cooking, and I'm told another 5 minutes, I wait no more than 5 minutes. Im told 10 minutes, I wait 10 minutes or sooner, etc.. Unlike a certain pizza shop that's right around the corner, who shall remain nameless. They say a few minutes longer... and 15 minutes+ I'm still waiting, happens 70%+ of the time. The only complaint that I truly have is if it's around dinner time and they're busy. The very small and limited parking can be a hassle at times, especially being right at the intersection. But, a business like this, it's not just about the food. It's also about the customer experience. The way each staff member treats you from the second you enter to the second you leave is nothing short of amazing. I will edit this review once I finally decide to try their food.
Service: 5
Frank Longo
The pizza that I ordered was good. The help could be a bit more organized and harmonious.
Sarah
Ordered a chicken finger sub with mayo, lettuce, tomato etc. So much mayo the bread was falling apart. I peeled off a pickle and there was a hair underneath. A small brown hair. I'm a long haired blond. Couldn't even eat it. Won't be going back.
Holly Williams
Absolutely delicious! Hands down best pizza in Rochester! Hidden gem!
Always a great pie! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Pepperoni Pizza, Steak, Chicken Wings, Garlic Parm Wings
Best pizza in town hands
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stay away, its never been that good of a pizza place but for a while now it takes the cake of how are they still open!? Disgusting and
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Always top notch ?
Amazing Every time! Worth the wait in gold!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
I called in my order and the man on the phone taking my order seemed like I was putting him out calling my order in! We ordered a large pizza, light sauce, 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 plain cheese. When we get there, there is a sign on the register 'Cash Only'. Now, I thought why did this grown man taking my order not tell me on the phone. A surprising coincidence they have an ATM in the store. Are they getting a cut of the ATM surcharge? Luckily I had enough cash. The pizza was flat and looked like old dough was used. The crust took up about 2 inches of the pizza, then about 1 inch of just dried red sauce. With a light sprinkle of cheese in the center. Only a few pepperonis were on half. Across the street behind the firehouse is the best pizza Rochester has had since Bay and Goodman pizza... Perri's. So- pass by Pizza Shack and go directly to Perri's!
Love it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Got a great medium pie with a couple toppings for under twenty bucks. That's a great deal in 2023! Pizza was good, will definitely return
New to the area so I’ve been trying the local pizza places nearby. This was my 3rd new place that my family and I have tried out and we have found our new pizza home. The food was delicious pizza was delicious sauce was awesome. The wings were the best that I’ve had in this area to date. Asked to fry hard and they were fried just right and not too tough. We will definitely be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a hidden gem! The pizza was excellent. The prices here are reasonable + actually less expensive than what other places are charging. Everything is fresh made, including dough and sauce - mozzarella is fresh sliced right there. The owner is a really good guy & cares about his food and customers. It's not the fanciest of places, but the food and prices more than make up for it! They have a good sized menu with decent variety - you'll find something that you'll like. Bring right on West Ridge Rd. makes getting in & out (especially out) a bit of a pain, so it's a good idea to plan your visit when traffic is lighter. I will definitely be going back here - now one of my go-to pizza shops!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow .. all I can say, this pizza was succulent, fresh, and amazing. Might be the best pizza I ever had ? HIGHLY RECOMMEND. Well done thin to perfection. I think Dave Portnoy would score this extremely high himself. Best in 585 definitely will be a reoccurring customer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So, personally, I've never ordered here before, I honestly probably should soon. I get a lot of DD/ Ubereats orders here. Every time I arrive, the staff are amazing and very friendly. One thing I appreciate about the staff, is the honesty, if I have to wait for a order to be done cooking, and I'm told another 5 minutes, I wait no more than 5 minutes. Im told 10 minutes, I wait 10 minutes or sooner, etc.. Unlike a certain pizza shop that's right around the corner, who shall remain nameless. They say a few minutes longer... and 15 minutes+ I'm still waiting, happens 70%+ of the time. The only complaint that I truly have is if it's around dinner time and they're busy. The very small and limited parking can be a hassle at times, especially being right at the intersection. But, a business like this, it's not just about the food. It's also about the customer experience. The way each staff member treats you from the second you enter to the second you leave is nothing short of amazing. I will edit this review once I finally decide to try their food.
Service: 5
The pizza that I ordered was good. The help could be a bit more organized and harmonious.
Ordered a chicken finger sub with mayo, lettuce, tomato etc. So much mayo the bread was falling apart. I peeled off a pickle and there was a hair underneath. A small brown hair. I'm a long haired blond. Couldn't even eat it. Won't be going back.
Absolutely delicious! Hands down best pizza in Rochester! Hidden gem!