Old Mill House Restaurant
2626 Main St, Stanley
(585) 526-9819
Customers' Favorites
Meatloaf Sandwich Special
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I recently had breakfast here and I can't say enough good things about it. I ordered the veggie omelette and hashbrowns and they were delicious, perfectly cooked and flavorful. My waitress was extremely pleasant, friendly and attentive and the prices beat anywhere else in the area, I highly recommend.
Awesome place to eat at. Service is great and food prep and quality is great too! Best thing- it’s right around the corner in our own hometown. Lowest price for breakfast around and especially that the coffee is free if you get there before 9:00!
So, not the worst diner we've ever been to, and not the best. The grilled meatloaf in the lunch special was very tasty, but I'm pretty sure the gravy came out of a jar. The "Whataburger" also tasted good, but was a little greasy - possibly from the bacon. The decor is a little date, and an open door let in the occasional yellow jacket wasp. Part of the kitchen is out front so you can watch the cook, which is kind of neat.Forgot to mention they are cash only,...
You May Also Like
Sweet Sue's Country Diner - 2148 NY-5
![]()
Diner, American, Vegetarian
Lincoln Hill Farms - 3792 NY-247
![]()
Music Venues, Brewery, Venues & Event Spaces, Pet Friendly