Our non profit was holding a huge benefit yesterday. at 11 am the baker we had hired for desert bailed on us thr morning of our event. Sarah not only came through with a sizable order within hours, she also stayed after hours to ensure I could get there to pick them up. Her shop is clean and cute and smells absolutely delightful when you enter. Service and quality are top notch. thank you for all you do!
Andrea Hampton
Hats off to Sarah and her sweet crew! I finally made the trip to Sterling and it was everything I anticipated it being: a warm, friendly atmosphere with the sweetest aroma wafting through the air and a warm and welcoming staff. I purchased scones which were incredibly soft and equally delicious, sugar spiced pecans and the homemade English muffins which were SO thick and absolutely incredible!! As a fellow baker, I highly recommend paying a visit to this fine establishment!
CM Gustke
Stopped by with my fiancé on a whim the other day while we were in town meeting with out wedding photography thinking we'd try a few things and see if they would be a contender for our wedding cake. what we didn't know was that everything we picked out to try would become an intrusive craving for days on end. Blueberry pie bars were so good. Apple pie bars, incredible. Snickerdoodles, amazing. But the STRAWBERRY JAM COOKIES 🤤🤤🤤🤤
We can't stop thinking about them. We cant wait to do a cake tasting for our wedding! Might even just make the hour drive from home on my next day off just for cookies. They're that good.
The ladies working this past Saturday (3/1/25) were so sweet and helpful!
Rob Holland
A delightful little bakery with delicious home made treats and coffee!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Ohler
Stopped and grabbed a half dozen of their cookies…. They were amazing
Caitlyn Buckman
We used Sweets by Sarah to supply several of the desserts for the dessert table at our wedding at Colloca Estate Winery. Everything was delicious, our guests raved about all of the desserts! My personal favorite was the cake pops--we had a couple of different flavors and they were all great. Sarah was also super easy to work with. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracey Reynolds
We visited in early July with out of town company and plan to return today. The absolutely best , high quality baked goods we have ever had. Their granola is delicious as well. They ship it to my relatives in Rhode Island - it is THAT good! Try their bars- so thick and rich and their scones are perfect. Can’t say enough about them- just go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
John David
The cinnamon rolls are huge & taste amazing.highly recommend trying one in fact get two!?
Colleen Guernsey
Sarah herself waited on me. Absolutely a great place, great atmosphere. The cinnamon rolls are the Best! Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
Elena Moskal
I am super happy with this cute little bakery! My children and I biked there and the kind attendant packed everything up so we could bike it back. Everything was delicious! We had a cinnamon roll, Italian cookies, and strawberry whoopie pie. Thank you for this charming addition to town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
Stopped by Sarah’s Sweets for their famous Cinnamon Roll and boy did that not disappoint! Their Snickerdoodles are Gas as well! “Pinnacle of Baked Goods”. All for a great Price. Please go check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
Sharon H
My neighbor and I hiked at the Sterling Nature Center and after we were done, we stopped at Sarah's because she knows her. This is a Very Cute and Delicious Bakery shop!! I totally hope to visit again next time I'm driving through Fair Haven NY!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Visca
Delicious cookies, great coffee, quick and friendly service. Absolutely worth a quick stop while camping at Fairhaven!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jen Barto
All I can say is OMG YUMMY! Amazing cookies and muffins! Staff is super friendly! If you haven't tried... you are missing out for sure! Will be back on next vacation and probably every one after that!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J&H Precourt
The first thing that you notice is how wonderful it smells when you walk in. Excellent selection of the tastiest treats!!! Very friendly staff and charming atmosphere.
Our non profit was holding a huge benefit yesterday. at 11 am the baker we had hired for desert bailed on us thr morning of our event. Sarah not only came through with a sizable order within hours, she also stayed after hours to ensure I could get there to pick them up. Her shop is clean and cute and smells absolutely delightful when you enter. Service and quality are top notch. thank you for all you do!
Hats off to Sarah and her sweet crew! I finally made the trip to Sterling and it was everything I anticipated it being: a warm, friendly atmosphere with the sweetest aroma wafting through the air and a warm and welcoming staff. I purchased scones which were incredibly soft and equally delicious, sugar spiced pecans and the homemade English muffins which were SO thick and absolutely incredible!! As a fellow baker, I highly recommend paying a visit to this fine establishment!
Stopped by with my fiancé on a whim the other day while we were in town meeting with out wedding photography thinking we'd try a few things and see if they would be a contender for our wedding cake. what we didn't know was that everything we picked out to try would become an intrusive craving for days on end. Blueberry pie bars were so good. Apple pie bars, incredible. Snickerdoodles, amazing. But the STRAWBERRY JAM COOKIES 🤤🤤🤤🤤 We can't stop thinking about them. We cant wait to do a cake tasting for our wedding! Might even just make the hour drive from home on my next day off just for cookies. They're that good. The ladies working this past Saturday (3/1/25) were so sweet and helpful!
A delightful little bakery with delicious home made treats and coffee!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped and grabbed a half dozen of their cookies…. They were amazing
We used Sweets by Sarah to supply several of the desserts for the dessert table at our wedding at Colloca Estate Winery. Everything was delicious, our guests raved about all of the desserts! My personal favorite was the cake pops--we had a couple of different flavors and they were all great. Sarah was also super easy to work with. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We visited in early July with out of town company and plan to return today. The absolutely best , high quality baked goods we have ever had. Their granola is delicious as well. They ship it to my relatives in Rhode Island - it is THAT good! Try their bars- so thick and rich and their scones are perfect. Can’t say enough about them- just go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
The cinnamon rolls are huge & taste amazing.highly recommend trying one in fact get two!?
Sarah herself waited on me. Absolutely a great place, great atmosphere. The cinnamon rolls are the Best! Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
I am super happy with this cute little bakery! My children and I biked there and the kind attendant packed everything up so we could bike it back. Everything was delicious! We had a cinnamon roll, Italian cookies, and strawberry whoopie pie. Thank you for this charming addition to town!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped by Sarah’s Sweets for their famous Cinnamon Roll and boy did that not disappoint! Their Snickerdoodles are Gas as well! “Pinnacle of Baked Goods”. All for a great Price. Please go check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Pound Cinnamon Roll Orange and Chocolate Cookie and a Oreo Monster Cookie
My neighbor and I hiked at the Sterling Nature Center and after we were done, we stopped at Sarah's because she knows her. This is a Very Cute and Delicious Bakery shop!! I totally hope to visit again next time I'm driving through Fair Haven NY!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious cookies, great coffee, quick and friendly service. Absolutely worth a quick stop while camping at Fairhaven!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
All I can say is OMG YUMMY! Amazing cookies and muffins! Staff is super friendly! If you haven't tried... you are missing out for sure! Will be back on next vacation and probably every one after that!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The first thing that you notice is how wonderful it smells when you walk in. Excellent selection of the tastiest treats!!! Very friendly staff and charming atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...