Jay's Pizza & Eats

Best pizza spot in stonypoint hands down.. There specialty pizza is amazing..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Mango Habanero Wings, Lemon Pepper Wings, Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Pizza

I just moved to the Stony Point area, this is the closest pizza ? shop to me, and it has great pizza. I'm talking about great pizza, should be on "one bite". I have had salad, wings, sandwiches and everything prepared here is good! I'm from the Bronx and to be able to have a great pizza shop close by is golden, doesn't get better than that!

Wheelchair accessibility: Ground floor

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Grilled Tilapia Salad, BBQ Wings, Homemade Rice Balls, Veal Parm, Made Fresh to Order, Happy Shrimp Salad, Square Pie, Popeyes Pie, Chicken Marsala, Sicilian, Mango Habanero Wings, Zeppolis, Lemon Pepper Wings, Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Flatbread, Grilled Chicken, Sunny Square Pizza, Potato Croquettes

I can not speak about the atmosphere or service because the pizza was brought to me by a family member. I had 3 cheese slices from the pie. Let me tell you, there was no sag, cheese was just right, low grease, very crunchy and the perfect size. The taste brought me back to my youth growing up the Bronx.

Food: 5

First time here slices were pretty good will be returning try more things

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Moved to Tomkins cove over 2 years ago and have constantly been getting food from jays. You can NEVER go wrong with ordering. From salads to paninis to burgers to penne vodka to of course pizza. It’s all so so good.

I think yesterday I found my favorite pizza that they offer and it’s the Spice-a-roni.

Grateful to have such a great place so close by.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered meat lovers, plain, and peperoni pies from here about 3 times and the food is okay. The service could use some work. They always seem annoyed or upset everytime I've been there and it's not a vibe. 2 stars

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Stopped in for lunch today and we had pizza and lasagna. both were very good and really liked all the cheese on the lasagna. Salads were very good and fresh.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Perfectly edible pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Trying to have a relaxing Friday night and order pizza. This is how the cheese pizza looked like the crust was hardly Chewable. The cheese was saggy in a disgusting way . A you see in the picture. I wish I could upload a video. i had to throw the pie in the garbage because there is no way this pizza was freshly made.

Very nice staffSicilian pie is

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Placed an order for delivery and twice they had messed up the order and no apologies or refund was done, charged 15 dollars for personal pizza which is overpriced when I asked for a large. Dont order delivery you will loose money and patience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

I eat out Italian-American atleast 3x a week, for years. I was open to trying them when this owner took over, but I didnt like it.. being that it's the only place close by, I deal with it when I have to. At first I thought it was coincidence but I tried again and again. I order the SAME thing everytime, and get violently ILL for an entire day an hour or two after eating my meal. This is NO coincidence! I'm still up recovering from last night. I'm done chancing it, it's official. The ingredients in this meal must have issues with refrigeration or cross contamination. I will report this and I would suggest any others that get sick from this location but have kept it to themselves, to report it too. The meal only has about 2 ingredients. Cheese and bread. Shouldn't be getting sick everytime.Also, who I assume is the owner is not friendly. Always treats me as if I am an inconvenience. All I do is order, pay and walk out, come back after given time to retrieve my food. I shouldn't be treated like that everytime I walk in. Thankfully because of those vibes I've only eaten in once and afterwards didn't want to deal with his attitude so took it to the car and ate it there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Solid pizza joint! Tasty wings and Greek salad as well ?

Surprisingly good pizza, especially at the Jay

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was my second time trying this place, and again disappointed. There’s literally no flavor in their pies. Just had to throw away my slice. Would suggest little caesars over this place without question.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3