JR Lobster & Seafood

251 NY-59, Suffern
(845) 357-6618

Recent Reviews

Sort by
James Jusino

First time there today ,im jay.. Absolutely amazing place ,highly recommend it to anyone. Blue crabs where amazing..

Tom Pahucki

Purchased some Long Island Blue Point oysters and little neck clams. The gentleman made sure they were good, he tapped them together to be sure they were alive. Brought them home steamed half the clams and had a bunch of oysters and left enough for the next night. Great quality. Price was on the high side but you get what you pay for. Very helpful and a real clean shop.

W H

Just bought fresh flounder from them. I am a fresh fish lover and tend to be very sensitive to any “fishy” smell on the product. This fish was so fresh that some, which I had to keep in the fridge for three days, still smells like I just caught it myself (which I have done many times). Best fresh fish market in tri-state area!

Ionel Porumb

A great place to get some fresh fish or a steak. There are many options that you can choose from,(oysters, clams, fresh fish, fresh lobster, steak chicken etc.)The staff are super friendly and the place it’s very clean.

Kenneth Mattson

Never smells like fish, very clean and Dan will give you top notch service. Great frozen and of course fresh fish! It's simply the BEST!!

Matthew Crenshaw

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I’m a huge foodie. Hands-down. The best seafood I have ever tasted on the east coast. While your there you have to try the Chocolate Pecan Pie . It will change your life …

Lina Claire Meza

Italian guy is cute AF. ???

Laura S

Good food, good service. Would recommend! It’s a store/ take out place. Ordered 2 tasty lobster rolls that came with seasoned fries. It is a little pricey, but it’s a small business and worth it. I wish I took a picture of my meal, but ate it too fast!

Andrew Greenlaw

The freshest fish I've ever had

S K Y

Just like I’m down the shore. The best quality anywhere really love this place. I would easily drive over an hour just to come here.My go to.Also The owners are such good people.

Nash Williams

I went in and asked if they could order a 10lb (or close) lobster for me. The guy was very nice and seemed interested. Said he would call Wednesday (3 days later) with info. I gave him my business card and was off. It's now been two weeks with no call back. I'll never return. There is no excuse for lack of communication!!! The building is still standing so there wasn't a fire....that's about the only excuse I'd believe....

RaQu Alight

There's nothing I can complain about. Customer service was great food was well seasoned and fresh. Im glad I gave this place a shot, worth the money.

sharon quayle

I bought soft shell crabs and sardines today. They were spectacular. Thank you JR Lobster.

Matt Wagner

Outstanding discovery! Great selection of fresh seafood. It is a store but they have a picnic table. Don’t let it fool you - they prepare great dishes, will clean and serve lobster. They also offer great recipes and even made a great sauce on the spot for us. They also offer grass fed steaks and cater. Super nice staff. No wonder why they have been in this location since 1979.

Sky

Just like I’m down the shore. The best quality anywhere really love this place. I would easily drive over an hour just to come here.My go to.Also The owners are such good people.

Loading...