Excellent food. Love their wings and burgers,fries. Karen our waitress is awesome and Samara is incredible in the kitchen. Staff is great. In short it's a hidden gem. Go visit.
Ashley Graham
2025 Update: I have heard that this place has been through a few owners and renovations since my original review. It is no longer the same, it has not improved.
It makes me quite sad because, despite my original review, I fell in love with wings and especially their small ones. I know people rave about big meaty wings but something about their small wings really set them apart.
The wings I had today were run of the mill wings you could get anywhere. Not bad, but not great.
Original review (I didn't like wings): I can't speak for the wings, though everyone raves about them, don't eat anything but a hamburger. Especially the fish and chips, if you've had them the proper way (in England) you'll be extremely let down.
Nora Kramer
My BLT would have been so much better if the tomato was ripe and flavorful. The bacon should have been made to order.
Jason C.
Great wings. Best in the area. Small crispy wing with a delicious sauce. My kids loved their meals. The French Onion soup was delicious.
Nice spacious place.
Jeff Cifichiello
Had an awesome dinner with my family @ an old-time favorite place for Suffern. Shout out to Samara and the rest of the staff. Happy to see that Sutter's Mill is back and better than ever!
Aurora C
Relaxing not crowded great atmosphere Their salmon is delicious as are those sweet potato fries!
Lauren Tomaino
Great chicken fingers ❤️
Julieanne Nardi
Service was good. She was really nice. Daniel loved the meatball and spaghetti. Wings were great.chlli thai.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Steve Howard
A great place to catch a lunch or dinner. Prices are good and portions are large. Plenty of tv’s to watch sports. Menu is large and diverse.
Parking: Plenty of parking but entrance is in the side.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
R. Binder
Burgers not cooked right, oinion soup was so salty it was unedible, understaffed, and when we complained to the waitress about the Flys all she said was yes I know. Definitely not the way I remember it.
Haven't been here in some time, so thought we'd stop in. It was 75 cent wing night, so my husband and I ordered 10 Buffalo wings each. We were offered Bleu cheese, and said yes, without being told there was an upcharge. Our daughter ordered fried pickles and the Italian combo, which she declared delicious. The wings were so overcooked, they were more like chicken jerky. The waffle fries were very good, and it was a large portion. Considering they do wing night every Tuesday, to serve wings like that at a place like this, is nothing short of disgraceful. Also, it was in the midst of a heatwave, and the a/c was barely working. Overall, very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
david Hannon
Great service, great prices, great flavor
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tacos and Nachos, Brussels Sprouts, California Taco Platter
Morgue Rata
Exceptional on Hospitality & flavor?. Get a little to eat or a bite to eat.
Excellent food. Love their wings and burgers,fries. Karen our waitress is awesome and Samara is incredible in the kitchen. Staff is great. In short it's a hidden gem. Go visit.
2025 Update: I have heard that this place has been through a few owners and renovations since my original review. It is no longer the same, it has not improved.
It makes me quite sad because, despite my original review, I fell in love with wings and especially their small ones. I know people rave about big meaty wings but something about their small wings really set them apart.
The wings I had today were run of the mill wings you could get anywhere. Not bad, but not great.
Original review (I didn't like wings): I can't speak for the wings, though everyone raves about them, don't eat anything but a hamburger. Especially the fish and chips, if you've had them the proper way (in England) you'll be extremely let down.
My BLT would have been so much better if the tomato was ripe and flavorful. The bacon should have been made to order.
Great wings. Best in the area. Small crispy wing with a delicious sauce. My kids loved their meals. The French Onion soup was delicious.
Nice spacious place.
Had an awesome dinner with my family @ an old-time favorite place for Suffern. Shout out to Samara and the rest of the staff. Happy to see that Sutter's Mill is back and better than ever!
Relaxing not crowded great atmosphere Their salmon is delicious as are those sweet potato fries!
Great chicken fingers ❤️
Service was good. She was really nice. Daniel loved the meatball and spaghetti. Wings were great.chlli thai.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
A great place to catch a lunch or dinner. Prices are good and portions are large. Plenty of tv’s to watch sports. Menu is large and diverse.
Parking: Plenty of parking but entrance is in the side.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Burgers not cooked right, oinion soup was so salty it was unedible, understaffed, and when we complained to the waitress about the Flys all she said was yes I know. Definitely not the way I remember it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Best burgers and fries!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haven't been here in some time, so thought we'd stop in. It was 75 cent wing night, so my husband and I ordered 10 Buffalo wings each. We were offered Bleu cheese, and said yes, without being told there was an upcharge. Our daughter ordered fried pickles and the Italian combo, which she declared delicious. The wings were so overcooked, they were more like chicken jerky. The waffle fries were very good, and it was a large portion. Considering they do wing night every Tuesday, to serve wings like that at a place like this, is nothing short of disgraceful. Also, it was in the midst of a heatwave, and the a/c was barely working. Overall, very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Great service, great prices, great flavor
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tacos and Nachos, Brussels Sprouts, California Taco Platter
Exceptional on Hospitality & flavor?. Get a little to eat or a bite to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Sutter's Mill Burger
Went there after playing round of golf at spook rock. One of the best smash burgers that I've ever had.
Loading...