Sutter's Mill
214 NY-59, Suffern
(845) 357-6556
Customers' Favorites
Sliced Steak on French Bread Sandwich
Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings
California Taco Platter
Sutter's Mill Burger
Cheese Burger Deluxe
Cheeseburger Combo
French Onion Soup
Blue Cheese Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Tacos and Nachos
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Haven't been here in some time, so thought we'd stop in. It was 75 cent wing night, so my husband and I ordered 10 Buffalo wings each. We were offered Bleu cheese, and said yes, without being told there was an upcharge. Our daughter ordered fried pickles and the Italian combo, which she declared delicious. The wings were so overcooked, they were more like chicken jerky. The waffle fries were very good, and it was a large portion. Considering they do wing night every...
During our journey to NYC, we made a pit stop for a late lunch and were pleasantly surprised by the dining experience here. We opted for the chicken quesadillas, which proved to be quite delightful with their melted cheese, flavorful chicken, and delicious whipped cream. The seafood basket was equally impressive, with perfectly fried scallops, fish, and shrimp. While the interior was slightly dry, it remained moist overall, and the crispy exterior paired well with a glass of beer....
You May Also Like
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria Restaurant Deli - 214 NY-59 Unit 2
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Salad
Guacamole Mexican Grill - 214 NY-59
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Bagel Boys Cafe - 9 N Airmont Rd
![]()
Cafe, Bagels, Bakery, Coffee & Tea
Parking: Plenty of parking but entrance is in the side.