Sutter's Mill
214 NY-59, Suffern
(845) 357-6556
Customers' Favorites
Sliced Steak on French Bread Sandwich
Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings
California Taco Platter
Sutter's Mill Burger
Cheese Burger Deluxe
Cheeseburger Combo
French Onion Soup
Blue Cheese Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Tacos and Nachos
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Always heard great things first time being there. Food and service were great it was empty and server noticed my brother and I watching the TV she came and asked if we wanted the volume on which doesn't happen often. Very kind of hee. Highly recommend.
Great environment, food was delicious, service was fantastic! Had the Sutters double smash burger and that’s the definition of a burger. Sloppy, juicy, seasoned well and the sauce was the icing on it. Sweet potato fries and onion rings were great also. Karen provided excellent service, attentive, quick, very friendly and inviting!! Definitely will return 👍🏼
Excellent food. Love their wings and burgers,fries. Karen our waitress is awesome and Samara is incredible in the kitchen. Staff is great. In short it's a hidden gem. Go visit.
You May Also Like
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria Restaurant Deli - 214 NY-59 Unit 2
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Salad
Guacamole Mexican Grill - 214 NY-59
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Bagel Boys Cafe - 9 N Airmont Rd
![]()
Cafe, Bagels, Bakery, Coffee & Tea