Joey's Italian Restaurant and Pronto Joeys

What an amazing relic. I heard it's being torn down and rebuilt, but this was exactly what you want. Older decor, attentive and sharp staff, smells like garlic and parm. The food is outstanding. Here's to the slowing of construction...

Great authentic Italian cuisine

Cool place with great food and big portions. Staff was wonderful.

Let me just say that I love this place! My husband and I ate here last Tuesday and it was amazing across the board. We ate in the downstairs restaurant. I had the cavatelli aletea and my husband had chicken Marsala both fabulous, appetizer was fried calamari and spumoni for dessert, also excellent! They also have a very nice wine list. The atmosphere is something we both loved. We’re from the city and relocated to CNY a few years ago and this place reminded us of some of our Little Italy haunts. We will definitely be regulars here! A keeper! Also, want to mention we’ve been to Pronto Joey’s as well and would highly recommend.

Had lunch.opgen sirloin steak on garlic toast unbelievably delicious chicken masala wonderful beef boulabaise delicious. Sauteed mushrooms tasteless. We will return!

Great NY style Italian food, don't miss out on the calamari steak! Top notch cannoli too.

Wonderful, friendly and yummy. Try local feel that made us felt welcome as soon as we walked in. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Classic menu and meal was delicious.

Don’t normally post stuff just want people to know how awesome this place is starting with our waitress very honest and pleasant person then takes our order with some changes my girlfriend made then chef comes out talks to her tells her he will make her something special and he did food comes out looked like we ordered for 4 we couldn’t even eat half of food we have enough food for dinner tonight then chef comes out to make sure everything was good unbelievable place and service thanks

Marshall was over the top good, this kid knows what he’s doing - Jorge V.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calamari Steak, Chicken Marsala, Meatball

Large portions, not very tasty and quality so so

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Food was awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Utica Greens, Italian Platter, Stuffed Shells

Stop in whenever I'm in the area

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Utica Greens

Little pricey for my taste. Had the chicken riggies. They were o.k. I've had better.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

First time to this restaurant seeking a romantic fine dining experience and definitely achieved that with dark wood, low lighting, and private curtained off table. (Downstairs)

We made an earlier reservation and glad we did since it became busier after 5 on a Saturday. Also seemed to center around an older crowd.

Our server was knowledgeable but not very friendly, and it worsened as things got busier while at the same time putting on the charm with the table beside us with first name familiarity…

Still, the food was exceptional and a level up from our other favorite restaurant. We ordered: shrimp scampi appetizer, surf & turf and filet entrees, with 2 desserts of cannolis and cheesecake. The desserts alone were of the best I’ve ever had at a restaurant.

Overall, this is a quality dining experience that is worth more visits!

Dietary restrictions: Vegetable based and gluten free options were listed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5