Nicks tomatoes pie is great. The pizza is delicious with fresh ingredients. The customer service is also great. Jodie and Aldo made me feel like family. I would recommend their pizza to all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason L
Terrific food and a bunch of good guys who care about their quality
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma Espinoza
Best pizza in Syracuse, NY! Jody and Nick was nice and courteous, something I didn't expect in NY. They out did themselves is service alone, but the pizza is what took the care or rather the pie! Highly recommend if you want an authentic NY pizza experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yo Girl Zo
We’re from Texas and my family wanted to try a ny pizza and this was our first choice and the best pizza we have ever eaten
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Summer
I have been to this place many times and it has typically been a positive experience. But this last time I have been has to be the worst experience I have ever had in an establishment and absolutely inexcusable. We got kicked out after someone behind us started verbally harassing us. Even though the people behind us in line started an argument the bouncer pointed fingers at us. The people behind us went as far to call us names and repeatedly pretend to SPIT ON US. I feel like I should preface this statement by saying I am a minority myself: but it was obvious that the bouncer treated us different because the people harassing us were the same race/ethnicity as him so he did not look at the situation subjectively. I will never go back or recommend this place to my friends or family. I am SO disappointed in this place and the experience I had after being kicked out for someone else’s bad behavior.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Mike Shaver
I gotta be honest. The here is no tomato on these pies. They are trying their best but it just doesn’t deliver.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Giuseppe Noto
They didn’t let me in the establishment due to my skin color, it is a racist establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Chad Thompson
This is burnt pie.
Pat Mueler
The pizza was very good people were friendly, however this is a big thing to me, I went in there to have a meeting, and constant slamming of the doors people being loud , the people I was meeting with was interrupted bye a guy standing there staring for a couple minutes before interrupting and asking if the other parties wanted pizza, they were going to get a slice after the meeting there not gunna stop our meeting to get pizza ounce were already in the middle of it. sometimes people just want to have meeting with out the distractions. If three people are having a conversation and meeting maybe just a little more respect for them and not need to make that much noise or interrupt them is all . As I was going over schooling information so that time with those guys is very valuable. If that gets cleaned up the next couple of times I go in there I'll change the review to all 5s . There is a time and place to be chatting in the beginning when they order there food. Ounce people and are no longer engaging in a conversation and sit down let them have there space is all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Martin Hawkins
Grabbed a slice to go late night on a weekend, good service and the pizza was delicious
Great pizza, great vibe! Tons of slice options—cheese, meat lovers, Sicilian, buffalo chicken—all super flavorful and perfectly charred. Classic NY fold, crispy crust, and gooey cheese. The place has a cool, late-night college energy with friendly staff and fast service. Interior is no-frills with checkered floors and stacked pizza boxes—gritty in a good way. Open late, right in the heart of downtown. A must-stop after a night out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Michael Connolly
I am a recent widow that was sitting with a man and the person working there picked him up by the neck and through him out of the establishment. This guy was unbelievably inappropriate and yelled at me when I told him he was inappropriate. I with tell everyone I know never to come here , to a place that tastes a new widow like trash!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Billy Sotherden
Very happy to have found this spot! I was taking a walk and saw 'tomato pie' and turned right in.
The 2 guys that were working were both personable, funny, high energy and engaging. Its always a good feeling to see people who are happy to be at their job.
Another bonus, this spot sells single wings!!!! I walked out with a glass bottle of coke, slice and 2 wings for less than ten dollars.
I will certainly return to this spot and eat-in next time. All around great experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lily
Delicious pizza. Watson and Zach are the best! Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
fajjar cheema
Pizza was really flavorful,fresh and delicious! Amazing service too !
Nicks tomatoes pie is great. The pizza is delicious with fresh ingredients. The customer service is also great. Jodie and Aldo made me feel like family. I would recommend their pizza to all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrific food and a bunch of good guys who care about their quality
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in Syracuse, NY! Jody and Nick was nice and courteous, something I didn't expect in NY. They out did themselves is service alone, but the pizza is what took the care or rather the pie! Highly recommend if you want an authentic NY pizza experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’re from Texas and my family wanted to try a ny pizza and this was our first choice and the best pizza we have ever eaten
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been to this place many times and it has typically been a positive experience. But this last time I have been has to be the worst experience I have ever had in an establishment and absolutely inexcusable. We got kicked out after someone behind us started verbally harassing us. Even though the people behind us in line started an argument the bouncer pointed fingers at us. The people behind us went as far to call us names and repeatedly pretend to SPIT ON US. I feel like I should preface this statement by saying I am a minority myself: but it was obvious that the bouncer treated us different because the people harassing us were the same race/ethnicity as him so he did not look at the situation subjectively. I will never go back or recommend this place to my friends or family. I am SO disappointed in this place and the experience I had after being kicked out for someone else’s bad behavior.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
I gotta be honest. The here is no tomato on these pies. They are trying their best but it just doesn’t deliver.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
They didn’t let me in the establishment due to my skin color, it is a racist establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This is burnt pie.
The pizza was very good people were friendly, however this is a big thing to me, I went in there to have a meeting, and constant slamming of the doors people being loud , the people I was meeting with was interrupted bye a guy standing there staring for a couple minutes before interrupting and asking if the other parties wanted pizza, they were going to get a slice after the meeting there not gunna stop our meeting to get pizza ounce were already in the middle of it. sometimes people just want to have meeting with out the distractions. If three people are having a conversation and meeting maybe just a little more respect for them and not need to make that much noise or interrupt them is all . As I was going over schooling information so that time with those guys is very valuable. If that gets cleaned up the next couple of times I go in there I'll change the review to all 5s . There is a time and place to be chatting in the beginning when they order there food. Ounce people and are no longer engaging in a conversation and sit down let them have there space is all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Grabbed a slice to go late night on a weekend, good service and the pizza was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza, great vibe! Tons of slice options—cheese, meat lovers, Sicilian, buffalo chicken—all super flavorful and perfectly charred. Classic NY fold, crispy crust, and gooey cheese. The place has a cool, late-night college energy with friendly staff and fast service. Interior is no-frills with checkered floors and stacked pizza boxes—gritty in a good way. Open late, right in the heart of downtown. A must-stop after a night out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am a recent widow that was sitting with a man and the person working there picked him up by the neck and through him out of the establishment. This guy was unbelievably inappropriate and yelled at me when I told him he was inappropriate. I with tell everyone I know never to come here , to a place that tastes a new widow like trash!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very happy to have found this spot! I was taking a walk and saw 'tomato pie' and turned right in.
The 2 guys that were working were both personable, funny, high energy and engaging. Its always a good feeling to see people who are happy to be at their job.
Another bonus, this spot sells single wings!!!! I walked out with a glass bottle of coke, slice and 2 wings for less than ten dollars.
I will certainly return to this spot and eat-in next time. All around great experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza. Watson and Zach are the best! Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was really flavorful,fresh and delicious! Amazing service too !
Loading...