Pies Guys Pizzeria

3106 James St, Syracuse
(315) 802-2470

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tyler Blair

55 bucks for one large pizza and 20 wings gtfo so over priced never will order here

Shawn Shadman

Unfortunately lesson learned. Don't order fish from a pizza place. It was like rubber. Fries were hard as rocks. Coleslaw was terrible. Asked for extra tartar. Nope. At least the salad is edible. I received $5 off for first time order. Hopefully, their pizza is better. Likely will not order again, though. And the bag leaked on my seat of my car. Made it smell horrible. Suggestion. Maybe use plastic bags in the future.

Noel Contois

Pizza is always hot and fresh and good, I always get the sides I ask for, delivery is always amazing, and the delivery drivers are amazing as well! MY FAVORITE PIZZA SPOT.

J P

It’s Easter and we have no dinner plans and my son asks for pizza. Considering he’s my boss, I obey his demands. Our usual spot was closed, so we tried Pies Guys for the first time. Naturally, I figured they’d be slammed and I was pretty unbothered by the wait time but they called me twice and texted me updates with apologies about the wait. They even threw in a free 2 liter and some garlic knots. Even though I didn’t care it’s clear they do and that’s insanely rare and worth a shout out. Will definitely order from them again.

Joyce J Schneider

Horrible customer service... manager acts like he is the greatest person ever. He has no customer service skills nothing but a bully

Brianna Ashley

I ordered for delivery last week, they were the only pizza place that had delivery at that time. My daughter who is 6 is very picky with her pizza and absolutely loved it. Delivery was fast and the food was great.

billy smyth

Had one Philly Chicken Sub and one Buffalo Chicken Sub . Both were whole subs and amazing, price was as great as the subs . Way to go Pies

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Braden Gilchrist

Delicious pizza. Would recommend

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Marisa

Delicious easy dinner. I called ahead and ordered over the phone for 5pm and the food was ready right on time. We love their sheet pizza! We got a sheet cheese pizza and 2 orders of char grilled wings for $60. Wings were delicious and had a nice grilled flavor. I really liked that the man was very transparent about the prices over the phone and told me the wings are expensive. They were about $15 for 10 which is probably standard right now. Worth it! His customer service was good and he even totaled my order which is something not every establishment will do and rush to hang up on you. Thanks for an easy dinner and leftovers.

Parking: There are usually spots off James street, to the right of the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza

Brian Belcher

I don't know what to say. I've never given a 1 star to a pizza place before. It feels kind of dirty inside the place. I over heard the workers complaining about the prices of other things on the menu, while I waited for my pick up order for 2 18" pizzas, which came to $65 with the seemingly mandatory tip. It's not a terrible price if the ingredients were premium but they definitely were not considering I had to vomit everything I ate 2 hours after I ate. I've never had a worse pizza experience and this place needs to shape up or get out.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Promise Hera

The customer service here is truly exceptional however, the personal hygiene is a great put off and disappointment.

Service: 5

Alexis Battreall

Ordered delivery like many times before and it had always come fast. Was told an hour wait on the phone but it usually comes faster. Waited an hour and a half and pizza had still not arrived. Called to check on status of pizza and was told by the woman on the phone that she lost the order ticket. She did not apologies but offered to remake the food and give $10 off but we still had to wait another hour. Her tone was very rude on the phone. Ended up cancelling the order and making food at home.

Service: 1

Kari Lanning

Ordered delivery on a Wednesday for their Pizza Deal - along with some wings... Everything was hot and fresh and arrived early! Plus they followed my instructions about how I like my wings. Thanks for the perfect food!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza

The Lucky Pupp

Always great food & service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

tat man

Love this place,it's an Eastwood staple. Ordered a plain cheese pizza a couple weeks ago,and the order never printed. Went in to grab it and when the employee noticed the issue, he was very apologetic,and I had my pizza in 10 minutes. He even threw extra cheese on it for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...