A perfect, reliable place to get a delicious bagel sandwich. I wish I could give 5 stars but they sometimes mess up my sandwich and very quickly fix it (I don't mind this at all) but the guy at the register (usually has a hat and white apron on, middle aged) absolutely berates and degrades any employee who makes a mistake. I feel bad that he is (apparently) their boss, and his customer service is poor at best.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
Jillian Perlberg
So good!
Paul Mokotoff
Being from Long Island, this was the first time I had a bagel in Central NY and it actually tasted like a bagel from Long Island. The bagel had the right amount of "chew" and was fluffy on the inside. The outside was crisp and seasoned very well. There was a good amount of cream cheese on the bagel (but not too much that it was overkill), leading to a good bagel-spread ratio. If you're in the Syracuse area, I would definitely check out this bagel shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jaclyn Grosso
Happy to see this bagel shop at the University. GREAT bagel. Stopped in for the first time and it didn't disappoint!
Dietary restrictions: Lots of options depending on what your restrictions are
So, not ONLY does Schoolyard Bagels make awesome, mouth-watering authentic down-state bagels and delicious XX LARGE sandwiches, the 3 owners are kind, witty, friendly (sometimes funny) and generous to a fault! When I first met them back in the summer, they told me that were not interested in selling or offering day-old bagels... FRESH ONLY! And they stand by that religiously! So, of course, being a Franciscan and a beggar by profession, I asked them what their plans were with their day-old bagels and rolls? And before they could muster a reply, I told them that we Conventual Franciscan Friars run a Food Pantry and Soup Kitchen on the Northside of Syracuse, called Assumption Food Pantry. And from opening day and every day thereafter, the day-old bagels are in the hands (and mouths) of those who are hungry or suffering with food insecurities on the Northside! And so, on their behalf, please allow me to thank you: Carmine, Nicky, Peter and Frankie, and staff, for your selfless generosity and love for those less fortunate than ourselves! God bless you! May your store be always filled with loving, devoted and hungry customers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sesame Bagel, Taylor Ham, Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Poppy Bagel
FG Waterman
Want a real Brooklyn experience right here in CNY? Visit Schoolyard Bagels on University Ave on the SU Hill. The bagels have the correct "chew" that you expect from an authentic down-state bagel and are quite delicious! There are NY city accents a plenty, from Alice, Carmine, Frankie, Nick, and Peter along with some awesome Italian-attitude sandwiches! There is even one I created and got named after me: "The Father Gerry!" Try it on a sesame bagel OR a sub roll. You'll want to go back for another real soon! And, while you're at it, try "The Billy G." It's named after a good friend of mine here in CNY! "Auguri!!!!" Welcome to the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J T
I guess you have to ask for bagel to be toasted
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lord RJK2
Schoolyard Bagels: Bringing Brooklyn Flavor to SyracuseStepping into Schoolyard Bagels feels like a culinary journey straight to the heart of Brooklyn, New York. From the moment I entered, greeted by the friendly and professional Owen, to my first bite of their perfectly chewy, golden brown bagels, I knew I had stumbled upon something special.My order of a Sesame Bagel toasted with Garden Vegetable Cream Cheese was nothing short of perfection. Each bite resonated with the unmistakable essence of a Brooklyn bagel, boasting a plump, rounded exterior and a fine crumb structure that struck the delicate balance between chewy and tender.It's clear that Schoolyard Bagels has mastered the art of bagel-making, executing a careful dance of preparation that results in a superior product. This dedication to quality was further evident in the enthusiastic response from Frankie when I expressed my delight. His genuine passion for the craft and commitment to excellence underscored the spirit of this young establishment.Despite a rocky start, Schoolyard Bagels has overcome its initial challenges with grace, emerging as a beacon of bagel brilliance in Syracuse. Located on Marshall Street at SU, the former Starbucks location has been transformed into a welcoming haven for bagel aficionados. The clean and inviting interior design sets the stage for an authentic Brooklyn experience right in the heart of the city.In conclusion, Schoolyard Bagels is more than just a bakery—it's a testament to passion, dedication, and the pursuit of perfection. Whether you're a native New Yorker longing for a taste of home or a local looking to indulge in the finest bagels Syracuse has to offer, Schoolyard Bagels delivers an experience that transcends expectations. Prepare to be transported to the streets of Brooklyn with every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Marini
Tastes like Brooklyn. Great bagels with an even better atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Nanno
Ordered a bagel sandwich and salt bagel with cream cheese. Food was really great and they were ok with me bringing in an outside coffee from salt city. Only suggestion is a better way to toast bagels
As a native NYCer, is this the most authentic bagel? No. Does it have potential, absolutely. the quality of the bagel is way better than Water St... Worth a try for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Anthony E
Did a BEC on everything bagel one morning and a few days later grabbed the chicken cutlet parm sandwich (The Frankie Gaga). Both delicious. Owners are friendly, space is nice. Glad to have a new spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
CUSE 67
If you like an incredible chicken salad sandwich this is the best in Onondaga County!!! Reminds me when I’m back home when I go into in Manhattan & Brooklyn NY looking for a great bagel!!!
Vegetarian options: The Vincent is also incredible!!
Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of space for anyone in a wheelchair to come in and eat in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
Rob DiPeri
Stopped in for a bagel, to be honest their bagels are off the hook. Simply delicious. Also had one of their signature sandwiches, " Robby Rings" to bring home with me. It never made it, I devoured it on the ride home. I recommend this place to everyone. ??
A DiSpirito
Came in for a late night BEC and it was perfect.So happy to have a place that’s open late and puts out quality food. Fast service, great bagels and it smelled amazing when I walked in.Definitely reminds me of bagels shops back home in Brooklyn and I can’t wait to come back and give the rest of the menu a try.
A perfect, reliable place to get a delicious bagel sandwich. I wish I could give 5 stars but they sometimes mess up my sandwich and very quickly fix it (I don't mind this at all) but the guy at the register (usually has a hat and white apron on, middle aged) absolutely berates and degrades any employee who makes a mistake. I feel bad that he is (apparently) their boss, and his customer service is poor at best.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
So good!
Being from Long Island, this was the first time I had a bagel in Central NY and it actually tasted like a bagel from Long Island. The bagel had the right amount of "chew" and was fluffy on the inside. The outside was crisp and seasoned very well. There was a good amount of cream cheese on the bagel (but not too much that it was overkill), leading to a good bagel-spread ratio. If you're in the Syracuse area, I would definitely check out this bagel shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Happy to see this bagel shop at the University. GREAT bagel. Stopped in for the first time and it didn't disappoint!
Dietary restrictions: Lots of options depending on what your restrictions are
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bottled Water, Everything Bagel, Poppy Bagel
So, not ONLY does Schoolyard Bagels make awesome, mouth-watering authentic down-state bagels and delicious XX LARGE sandwiches, the 3 owners are kind, witty, friendly (sometimes funny) and generous to a fault! When I first met them back in the summer, they told me that were not interested in selling or offering day-old bagels... FRESH ONLY! And they stand by that religiously! So, of course, being a Franciscan and a beggar by profession, I asked them what their plans were with their day-old bagels and rolls? And before they could muster a reply, I told them that we Conventual Franciscan Friars run a Food Pantry and Soup Kitchen on the Northside of Syracuse, called Assumption Food Pantry. And from opening day and every day thereafter, the day-old bagels are in the hands (and mouths) of those who are hungry or suffering with food insecurities on the Northside! And so, on their behalf, please allow me to thank you: Carmine, Nicky, Peter and Frankie, and staff, for your selfless generosity and love for those less fortunate than ourselves! God bless you! May your store be always filled with loving, devoted and hungry customers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sesame Bagel, Taylor Ham, Bagel, Cinnamon Raisin Bagel, Poppy Bagel
Want a real Brooklyn experience right here in CNY? Visit Schoolyard Bagels on University Ave on the SU Hill. The bagels have the correct "chew" that you expect from an authentic down-state bagel and are quite delicious! There are NY city accents a plenty, from Alice, Carmine, Frankie, Nick, and Peter along with some awesome Italian-attitude sandwiches! There is even one I created and got named after me: "The Father Gerry!" Try it on a sesame bagel OR a sub roll. You'll want to go back for another real soon! And, while you're at it, try "The Billy G." It's named after a good friend of mine here in CNY! "Auguri!!!!" Welcome to the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I guess you have to ask for bagel to be toasted
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Schoolyard Bagels: Bringing Brooklyn Flavor to SyracuseStepping into Schoolyard Bagels feels like a culinary journey straight to the heart of Brooklyn, New York. From the moment I entered, greeted by the friendly and professional Owen, to my first bite of their perfectly chewy, golden brown bagels, I knew I had stumbled upon something special.My order of a Sesame Bagel toasted with Garden Vegetable Cream Cheese was nothing short of perfection. Each bite resonated with the unmistakable essence of a Brooklyn bagel, boasting a plump, rounded exterior and a fine crumb structure that struck the delicate balance between chewy and tender.It's clear that Schoolyard Bagels has mastered the art of bagel-making, executing a careful dance of preparation that results in a superior product. This dedication to quality was further evident in the enthusiastic response from Frankie when I expressed my delight. His genuine passion for the craft and commitment to excellence underscored the spirit of this young establishment.Despite a rocky start, Schoolyard Bagels has overcome its initial challenges with grace, emerging as a beacon of bagel brilliance in Syracuse. Located on Marshall Street at SU, the former Starbucks location has been transformed into a welcoming haven for bagel aficionados. The clean and inviting interior design sets the stage for an authentic Brooklyn experience right in the heart of the city.In conclusion, Schoolyard Bagels is more than just a bakery—it's a testament to passion, dedication, and the pursuit of perfection. Whether you're a native New Yorker longing for a taste of home or a local looking to indulge in the finest bagels Syracuse has to offer, Schoolyard Bagels delivers an experience that transcends expectations. Prepare to be transported to the streets of Brooklyn with every bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tastes like Brooklyn. Great bagels with an even better atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a bagel sandwich and salt bagel with cream cheese. Food was really great and they were ok with me bringing in an outside coffee from salt city. Only suggestion is a better way to toast bagels
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
As a native NYCer, is this the most authentic bagel? No. Does it have potential, absolutely. the quality of the bagel is way better than Water St... Worth a try for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Did a BEC on everything bagel one morning and a few days later grabbed the chicken cutlet parm sandwich (The Frankie Gaga). Both delicious. Owners are friendly, space is nice. Glad to have a new spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
If you like an incredible chicken salad sandwich this is the best in Onondaga County!!! Reminds me when I’m back home when I go into in Manhattan & Brooklyn NY looking for a great bagel!!!
Vegetarian options: The Vincent is also incredible!!
Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of space for anyone in a wheelchair to come in and eat in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
Stopped in for a bagel, to be honest their bagels are off the hook. Simply delicious. Also had one of their signature sandwiches, " Robby Rings" to bring home with me. It never made it, I devoured it on the ride home. I recommend this place to everyone. ??
Came in for a late night BEC and it was perfect.So happy to have a place that’s open late and puts out quality food. Fast service, great bagels and it smelled amazing when I walked in.Definitely reminds me of bagels shops back home in Brooklyn and I can’t wait to come back and give the rest of the menu a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything Bagel
Loading...