Fortunes Ice Cream
55 Broadway, Tivoli
(845) 757-2899
Customers' Favorites
Toasted Rice Fluff
Strawberry
Mint Chip
Gelato
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
When I am having a good day, I celebrate with fortunes. When I am having a bad day, I celebrate with fortunes. Whatever day you are having, you should treat yourself with fortunes and you will not regret it. It is truly the best ice cream in the world and also my favorite place 🍦❤️😍💖
The best dang ice cream in all the land; for realz.
Yes, a pint is pricier than what most are used to; however, once you taste, you will come to understand.
I had to stock up for winter, as they close 12/22/24 for the season 🙃
Yes, a pint is pricier than what most are used to; however, once you taste, you will come to understand.
I had to stock up for winter, as they close 12/22/24 for the season 🙃
EXCELLENT ice cream!!! And such amazing flavours!!!
My friend and I had the labne sour, rosemerry caramel, halva honeycomb, and chocolate orange – ALL WERE HEAVENLY. I also packed a pint to take back with me to New York City and they packaged it in a cool bag with ice. Super relieved that it survived the journey home!
My friend and I had the labne sour, rosemerry caramel, halva honeycomb, and chocolate orange – ALL WERE HEAVENLY. I also packed a pint to take back with me to New York City and they packaged it in a cool bag with ice. Super relieved that it survived the journey home!
You May Also Like
ALL THAT JAVA Tivoli - 53 Broadway
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Venues & Event Spaces
Tivoli General - 54 Broadway
![]()
Grocery, Sandwich Shop, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Shops, Coffee
Santa Fe Tivoli - 52 Broadway
![]()
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian