New York Pizzeria
2 W Main St, Trumansburg
(607) 387-3700
Customers' Favorites
White Pizza with Tomato
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Lots of Pizza
Large Pizza
Meat Pizza
Menu
Photos
+55 photos
+54 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We use to go there all the time when my granddaughter was little. She loved it so much. We have since moved away to Florida. We are coming back to new york for the Lafayette Apple Festival and my granddaughter requests we go to the pizza place..
Been sitting here in the restaurant for 35 minutes waiting for a small pepperoni pizza. It’s good pizza but absolutely not worth this kind of wait, actually pretty bizarre a small pie takes over 15 mins, especially ordering in person.
I miss this place, one of the best pizzas on Earth. I miss it. I'm originally from NJ across the river from Staten Island, NY. This is in my pizza. Top Five I currently reside in Ohio.... pizza sucks here, although most upstate pie sucks too!! The best way to get a pie here is well done or have them reheat the slice cause I've had this pizza many times as just slice and 3 times as a whole pie and everytime the whole pie didn't have a good bottom crisp!! So ask for...
You May Also Like
Creekside Cafe - 4 W Main St
![]()
Cafe, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian
Gimme! Coffee - 7 E Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Cafe