Keystone Hoagies

549 NY-17, Tuxedo Park
(845) 915-3203

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jose ceron

Amazing place. Amazing staff.???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

byReza byReza

TERRIBLE in every meaning of the word. I ordered the salmon burger and a side of fries. I had to spit the first bite of the salmon out fear of falling ill with food poisoning. The buns tasted as if fried in butter. The french fries soggy and old.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Cook

They have a large selection of items but they took my favorite item and their signature sandwich off the menu. I will not be able to return until they bring back the Pittsburgh Prima!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hand Cut Fries, Sandwich

Ian Isaiah

I just happened to be hungry and in the area so I searched “food” and Keystone Hoagies was the first thing to pop up. I drove over expecting a small sandwich shop but to my surprise, there’s also a bakery here.From the moment I walked in, the service was exceptional and the restaurant has a warm atmosphere.Second surprise came when I ordered the shrimp Po boy expecting a small sandwich, the sandwich was huge and delicious! Also ordered a ginger limeade and a snickerdoodle cookie. 10/10 will be back and would recommend. I’m so happy I was hungry in the area and happy that I decided to give this place a chance.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Gaurav Purandare

Ordered cheesesteak and fish and chips! Best in the area!

Bill Eighmie

Delicious. I am not in the area often, but when I am, I like to stop here. I had the 'Your Honor' chicken sub, and an oatmeal cookie.

Ken W

Very good Food for sandwiches and snacks Great place to stop by

Demi Dunn

So I’ve been here before and had a veggie Duffy who was terrific but no longer on the menu came back had the shrimp po boy. My husband had the cheesesteak, and both were disgusting; that cheesesteak had ZERO flavors. I mean, Zero, he took one bite and left the whole hero there. I took two bites of my shrimp and left it, and I was so upset because I hate to throw away food. I’ve been back since then and kept getting disappointed, so, unfortunately, I will never go back. My husband, on the other, had never gone back?

Galina Niyazov

The most amazing avocado toast I ever had a my life. And I live in NYC!! Bread is delicious, the portion is huge

Amir Khan

Incredible sandwiches. Like... some of the best I've had anywhere. Make sure you go check this place out.

AM Mill (Millyann)

Great food! Everything on the menu that my husband and I have tried has been excellent! Inspired, pleasant owners and workers! Nice place! Btw, I'm speaking about the sister store, Dottie Audrey's also!

Henry

Greatest sandwiches around. I love the cheese steak. Big enough to share. Outdoor seating available and plenty of parking.

Carol Kobetitsch

Great selection of yummy food. First time on the Hoagie side today, everything was delicious. Their baguettes are perfect!!!! Just the right amount of crisp and chew which is very hard to find, ypu can take a bite without squishing the filling out the sides. Foodies will love this place! Nice atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff?

Ann Marie Milligan

Great food! Everything on the menu that my husband and I have tried has been excellent! Inspired, pleasant owners and workers! Nice place! Btw, I'm speaking about the sister store, Dottie Audrey's also!

chatmanka

A place where you will often return after you enjoyed for the first time their tasty food, savored the atmosphere and the coffee. Five stars and one more from me!

Loading...