Mamma Gina's Pizzeria and Grill

104 E Merrick Rd, Valley Stream
(516) 568-1333

Recent Reviews

Carlos H

there seems to be new ownership in this restaurant, and they are honestly amazing from customer service, to the food tasting amazing. This is the change this business needed. Will definitely keep ordering from this place !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dylan

Been ordering from this place for years. Since they changed owners recently, the quality of the pizza has fallen. Ordered a regular pie a few days ago and the tomato sauce on the pizza tasted off, very bitter. The structure of a regular pie was also small compared to its price. And comparing that to other pizza places nearby, you can definitely get a better deal somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Christopher C. B.

Birria tacos for the win. Best I've had, friendly staff! Go get some as soon as you can

Kyle Conlon

There seems to have been a change at Mamma Gina’s recently, because their pizza has been awful now two times in a row. My family has been ordering from here ever since they’ve opened and have always had a great experience.Unfortunately their pizza has gone downhill in quality over the past few months. The crust on their regular pizza tasted oddly sweet, and most recently their Grandma’s pie has sauce on it that tastes like ketchup was dumped on it. No garlic or any fresh ingredients.I’m not sure if there was a change in ownership, but I don’t think my family will be ordering from Mamma Gina’s anymore sadly.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

victor jimenez

Honestly, one star is too much for the type of garbage food I got. Ordered a chicken marsala and i literally dumped it in the garbage. I've never left a negative comment on anyone's business before but this was unacceptable! The chicken tasted horrible the pasta was overcooked and the sauce almost made me vomit. I don't think the person who cooked this plate has the most basic idea of how to cook pasta or how to make a chicken marsala. Whoever is in charge of this place pay attention to your cooks and taste your food before you put it out there...you're lucky I'm not one of those customers that enjoy drama because you deserved to get a visit from a food service inspector.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

J.A. G.

Very good pizza. Classic taste but on the last order, the dough was very bulky and undercooked but that was my only one negative experience. I would still go back every time though. ?????⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Abramov

Highly recommend this pizzeria, Carlos greeted me with very welcoming customer service and the pizza was really good, especially the Buffalo chicken. Very friendly and old school service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lu Lily

I don't know when they changed owners, but this was the worst pizza I've ever gotten from a "pizzeria". Looked more like an amusement park pizza. The cheese wasn't even melted. Photos speak for themselves. Not worth $19 a pie.

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ry Manil

Worst pizzeria I ever tried. Paid $9.50 for a chicken roll that was cold straight out the oven. If you like cold overpriced food this is the place to go.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Eligio M. Peralta

You gotta check out Mama Gina's Pizzeria! This family-run spot has got some delicious pizza, but the real star of the show is their mouth-watering birria tacos. Don't miss 'em! Their grilled shrimp ones are a solid alternative.Carlos, the owner, is an awesome person with old-school customer service that you just don't see anymore. Plus, with parking available and delivery, it's a no-brainer. Mama Gina's is a place that you need to try.

Ariel Caba

1st time around the neighborhood wanted some good pizza. ?

briandV918QL

This restaurant use to be good but now the quality of the food is terrible. Poor preparation and sad old food. Such a shame.

Chris Xzd

Food was really good and my family and enjoyed.the taco were good and the pizza was good.

S. Keeman

First time at this place and I was curious to try this place out after seeing the recent negative reviews. It's a small place seems to me that's its family owned and operated. The guy place is definitely not the cleanest or the newest. My request was simple 2 plain slices not too hot.My expectations were not highThe 2 slices of pizza and a can of Pepsi was $6.50. Seems fair to me especially with the rising prices of all pizza ingredients and food service.The pizza is very specific. Its plain pizza, no special sauce no special cheese no special bread nothing too special about my slices of pizza at all.But I'm a simple guy who likes simple pizza. And this is textbook pizza that hit the spot. Sauce wasnt overbearing, the cheese was not too gooey and the crust was of reasonable size and was doughy, flaky with a subtle but enjoyable crunch as you ate it. Im big on the crust and it was great. I would come back here again for the plain slice because I'm honestly expecting a decent plain slice and this is great just for that.

Kylie N.

I called an order for pickup. I asked for a total and it took about 5 minutes to get a total. When I got there the food wasn't ready. I reminded the kid working of the drinks I was getting he still forgot to charge me so I had to go back again. I get home to a burnt pie. Not worth it not good.

Load More