John Anthony’s Pizzeria

1056 Franklin Ave, Valley Stream
(516) 256-3300

Recent Reviews

Lenny S.

I just waited 2 hrs for a 2 item order. Grub hub called the restaurant and told me their response was the driver was out, was about 1 hr late, AND THEY HAD NO IDEA WHAT WAS GOING ON!! ?? Who in their right mind owns a business and gives that kind of answer to a retail/restaurant customer?? That is so absurd,, that I am beyond mad,, bordering on laughable!! STAY FAR FAR AWAY !!!

New Y.

Who knew there would be A great pizza shop hidden in franklin ave. They have really good pizzas. Great service. Call ahed for fresh orders.

Harriet S.

I ordered cauliflower pizza cause that's my favorite and a linguine pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage and it was delicious..my family always ordered food in this pizzeria because not only delicious but on time or earlier on the specified time . I recommend this place and try it!!!

Stanley C.

I have been driving by this place for years and just realized they had a parking lot in the back which made it very convenient to stop. I ordered a pizza and found it to be scrumptiously delicious. Two weeks later, I ordered catering. All the food was made to perfection - the meatballs were tender, the lasagna was cheesy, and the antipasto and party hero had lots of cold cuts...and the pizza of course was delicious, as well as other dishes. Also, they give comp trays according to the size of your order. They definitely give you the best "bang for your buck". This is my new pizza spot!

Larry Lombardo

they refuse to accept the coupon. I had a $5 off coupon this Cooper had no expiration date and Jonathan's refused to accept the coupon. Dick coupons from the old menu has no expiration date I presented I told them and they refuse to accept it show now I refuse to accept them and go to them I will find other Pizzeria but I'm just letting you people on Facebook know that John Anthony's is not trustworthy and they don't accept that coupons like I said there is no expiration dates

Harpreet K.

The old management had way better food! This new managements food sucks! Come back Anthony

Deborah Z.

I Purchased the family special. It comes with a lot of food it was great tasting the only thing I didn't like was the bread. Would definitely purchase again.

Leif W.

Worst pizza I've ever had , got a regular pie and every slice was squished and the entire cheese came right off the slice when lifting it

Luis Gordon

We met with friends at this spot for a meeting. This place was recommended to us by a friend. Well, we were not disappointed. The crew were extremely nice and we felt good. The food was just great. We loved this spot very much and we shall absolutely come back again. Warmly recommended.

James Pacheco

Love a pizzeria that can accommodate. All veggie no cheese pie was delicious.

Deirdre C.

Zero stars. I ordered through grubhub, 1.5 hours later and nothing delivered. I called the restaurant and they said "it's not my problem, call grubhub." No attempt to make it right, no attempt to problem solve. So many better options, I recommend going elsewhere.

Janine F. Snow

I usually just go in and grab a few slices to go. The pizza is great. Tonight we ordered chicken francese and veal marsala and it was amazing!! Highly recommend

Tatiana V

My daughter was invited here for a birthday get together the other day so I decided to order yesterday as she liked it. I ordered pizza, garlic bread, and Calamri and it was all amazing! This is the best spot yet that i have gotten pizza from. We will be ordering all the time from here. As well its not as pricey as all the other pizza shops around.

David D.

Worst veal Parmesan hero of my entire life. Bill was flat and tough and had a funny taste. Will never order this again

BABY A

Really great tasting pizza! Friendly Staff!!

Load More