As soon as I walked in, there was a cop, so that was already a sign that the vibes were off. The selection was minimal, but still wanted to try and support. I got one vanilla and one cookies and cream cupcake and one brownie. Everything was underwhelming. The cake was super plain, little flavor. The frosting was a weird, whipped texture. Again, flavorless. The brownie... I honestly could've had something better from the box. Sorry, but this first impression was a bad one. Won't be returning here.
Renee C.
Food: I had several items from them this week. 2 cupcakes 1 boozy red velvet and 1 strawberry crunch. Both were delicious but small. The next item was a coconut pineapple donut. The flavor reminded me of my grandmother's family famous coconut pineapple cake. It was delicious! The final item was a walnut brownie, my coworker ate this and said that it was delicious.
G Bach
Some delicious variety of desserts. Staff were very friendly and courteous.
Heston R.
Love the soft cookies and lil sis enjoyed the caramel drizzle brownies, top favorites with me and the fam is the chocolate chip cookie, cookie & cream cookie, buttercrunch, caramel apple oatmeal, red velvet cookie. Totally worth the visit ?
brie
I used them recently for a birthday party and everything was amazing. I had never had any of their desserts prior to ordering. They were super accommodating with my dessert pick up time as well as with my budget. The cake turned out beautiful! & we received a lot of compliments on the taste and the moisture of the cake. We also ordered a tray of cookies which were equally delicious. I will definitely be returning for our next special occasion as well as more cookies just for us, the next time we are in the area. Thank you!
Alva Mendez
I was craving Magnolia’s banana pudding but didn’t want to take a trip to the city. I found The Best Goodie Bag online and to my surprise it’s right behind my home. All I gotta say is WOW! Best banana pudding ever. Magnolia’s where?! This place is my new go to for banana pudding!!!
Kam J
Had the pleasure of visiting The Best Goodie Bag on Father's Day. The staff was very welcoming, and helpful, but the products they were offering that day looked so tempting that I ended up purchasing two dozen cupcakes as we were having a Father's Day BBQ. I was highly satisfied because they were as delicious s they were beautiful, and our guests loved them too because they tore them up. I especially loved the fact that they were not overly sweet, just the right amount of sweetness, and very flavorful. The Strawberries and Cream was like have Strawberry Shortcake in cupcake form as was the German Chocolate cupcake which was sinfully delicious. They also had Parfait desserts that looked very tempting as well. I plan on try them on my next visit, as well as tasting more of the cupcakes they offerings I didn't get a chance to taste s they had more than a dozen different flavors, so if you have the need to satisfy your sweet tooth, do your tastebuds a favor and run over to 77 Roosevelt Ave, Valley Stream. I think you will be very satisfied.
Kam Steele
A hidden gem. I had the pleasure of visiting this shop yesterday afternoon. The cupcakes looked so delicious I ended up walking out with almost two dozen as we were having guests for Father’s Day. Everyone loved them, and they were all gone by the end of the day. I loved them because they weren’t overly sweet, the sweetness was perfect, and the texture of them was moist and flavorful. I definitely have to come back as I only got to taste the German Chocolate cupcake and the Strawberry and Cream cupcake. The German Chocolate was fantastic, and the Strawberry was like having Strawberry Shortcake in cupcake form, and everyone else loved the ones they had. Do yourself a favor and run over and get you some. The staff there were really nice people and made me feel welcomed.
DaniKay Inc.
These reviews have to be fake, the cupcakes are mediocre tastes like box cake. They were nice people but don’t waste your time. Looks good tastes mediocre
Dawn Bascombe
Delivered items and didn’t include my cheesecake after CHARGING me as if they included it. I thought Uber driver stole it but the bag was stapled. Do better for the next customer because this was not a cool thing to do.
Everything we have ever had from here is delicious. Only complaint is I wish they were open more days lol. But maybe that’s for the better, their items are dangerously delicious ?? You will NOT be disappointed
Bella Karakis
Attended a party last night and had the most amazing peach cobbler pudding I’ve ever tasted! Made by The Best Goodie Bag. Highly recommend!
Ibrahim
Easy to find location. Extremely helpful staff. The strawberry cupcakes and peach cobbler are mouth watering. I plan on returning to the The best goodie bag for more amazing desserts. :??
Fila A.
I'm in love with this cute, family owned bakery! I first ordered a cake for my daughters 10th birthday and I've subsequently placed more orders since then.The service is great, the cakes are gorgeous and they taste amazing!
Lisa Laborde
Nails our cupcake orders EVERY time!Moist, delish and artfully created with personalized customer service. Premium service and treats ?
As soon as I walked in, there was a cop, so that was already a sign that the vibes were off. The selection was minimal, but still wanted to try and support. I got one vanilla and one cookies and cream cupcake and one brownie. Everything was underwhelming. The cake was super plain, little flavor. The frosting was a weird, whipped texture. Again, flavorless. The brownie... I honestly could've had something better from the box. Sorry, but this first impression was a bad one. Won't be returning here.
Food: I had several items from them this week. 2 cupcakes 1 boozy red velvet and 1 strawberry crunch. Both were delicious but small. The next item was a coconut pineapple donut. The flavor reminded me of my grandmother's family famous coconut pineapple cake. It was delicious! The final item was a walnut brownie, my coworker ate this and said that it was delicious.
Some delicious variety of desserts. Staff were very friendly and courteous.
Love the soft cookies and lil sis enjoyed the caramel drizzle brownies, top favorites with me and the fam is the chocolate chip cookie, cookie & cream cookie, buttercrunch, caramel apple oatmeal, red velvet cookie. Totally worth the visit ?
I used them recently for a birthday party and everything was amazing. I had never had any of their desserts prior to ordering. They were super accommodating with my dessert pick up time as well as with my budget. The cake turned out beautiful! & we received a lot of compliments on the taste and the moisture of the cake. We also ordered a tray of cookies which were equally delicious. I will definitely be returning for our next special occasion as well as more cookies just for us, the next time we are in the area. Thank you!
I was craving Magnolia’s banana pudding but didn’t want to take a trip to the city. I found The Best Goodie Bag online and to my surprise it’s right behind my home. All I gotta say is WOW! Best banana pudding ever. Magnolia’s where?! This place is my new go to for banana pudding!!!
Had the pleasure of visiting The Best Goodie Bag on Father's Day. The staff was very welcoming, and helpful, but the products they were offering that day looked so tempting that I ended up purchasing two dozen cupcakes as we were having a Father's Day BBQ. I was highly satisfied because they were as delicious s they were beautiful, and our guests loved them too because they tore them up. I especially loved the fact that they were not overly sweet, just the right amount of sweetness, and very flavorful. The Strawberries and Cream was like have Strawberry Shortcake in cupcake form as was the German Chocolate cupcake which was sinfully delicious. They also had Parfait desserts that looked very tempting as well. I plan on try them on my next visit, as well as tasting more of the cupcakes they offerings I didn't get a chance to taste s they had more than a dozen different flavors, so if you have the need to satisfy your sweet tooth, do your tastebuds a favor and run over to 77 Roosevelt Ave, Valley Stream. I think you will be very satisfied.
A hidden gem. I had the pleasure of visiting this shop yesterday afternoon. The cupcakes looked so delicious I ended up walking out with almost two dozen as we were having guests for Father’s Day. Everyone loved them, and they were all gone by the end of the day. I loved them because they weren’t overly sweet, the sweetness was perfect, and the texture of them was moist and flavorful. I definitely have to come back as I only got to taste the German Chocolate cupcake and the Strawberry and Cream cupcake. The German Chocolate was fantastic, and the Strawberry was like having Strawberry Shortcake in cupcake form, and everyone else loved the ones they had. Do yourself a favor and run over and get you some. The staff there were really nice people and made me feel welcomed.
These reviews have to be fake, the cupcakes are mediocre tastes like box cake. They were nice people but don’t waste your time. Looks good tastes mediocre
Delivered items and didn’t include my cheesecake after CHARGING me as if they included it. I thought Uber driver stole it but the bag was stapled. Do better for the next customer because this was not a cool thing to do.
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything we have ever had from here is delicious. Only complaint is I wish they were open more days lol. But maybe that’s for the better, their items are dangerously delicious ?? You will NOT be disappointed
Attended a party last night and had the most amazing peach cobbler pudding I’ve ever tasted! Made by The Best Goodie Bag. Highly recommend!
Easy to find location. Extremely helpful staff. The strawberry cupcakes and peach cobbler are mouth watering. I plan on returning to the The best goodie bag for more amazing desserts. :??
I'm in love with this cute, family owned bakery! I first ordered a cake for my daughters 10th birthday and I've subsequently placed more orders since then.The service is great, the cakes are gorgeous and they taste amazing!
Nails our cupcake orders EVERY time!Moist, delish and artfully created with personalized customer service. Premium service and treats ?