Food is great but they mess up every time the cheese isn't even on the entire pizza and forget about messaging corporate as they don't contact u back
Food: 4
Service: 3
Zoolu “Zoolu” Zoolu
We have had zero problems with Caraglio’s in Victor. Food is always good and on time. We welcome them to the area!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S S
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, thought we’d try it for the first time. The dough was extremely thick and too soft on the bottom. Pepperoni was really greasy. The worst part was biting into a slice and there was a hair in it! Gross!! Will never, ever order from there again!!!! Do better!
jeff guinan
I had great wings and chicken fingers with fries and plus the people were very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
peter garlock
Slice was half crust and they had a 2 slice & 1 drink combo for 9$ got charged 14$ asked her about it she said you have to get it on a box.
Jarrad K
Excellent pizza. Best in the area. Wont go anywhere else
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Gonzalez
I wish I had a picture of the sheet pizza I ordered for the Bill's game.. I love cariglios pizza. I've been going to them for a few years now and they never dissapoint!! I've been telling everyone in my family to give them a shot and you'll see. Why I enjoy them so much!! Now they have a location in Victor! Which is sweet! My brother orders from them and my sister orderfeom them from East Rochester. They all agree that they are worth the money and what they offer for deals!! I'm happy to see them expanding. I used to go out to 104 to grab pizza. Now they are a lot closer to me I'm Canandaigua.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moira Strouse
I wanted to like it, wanted to give it a shot. Tasteless sauce, banana peppers that were as mild as green peppers, and the main fault, cheap cheese. Folks this is not real mozzarella, it’s blended with oils in production and tasteless. There is a conscious decision to use inferior products, and they made it. I want to support local, but never again here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
NEVR XHALE
Truly wish Pontillos was still occupying this location. I've made the mistake of ordering from Caraglio's twice, with both orders ending in disappointment. The 1st order they forgot some toppings on my pizza, but sure didn't forget to charge for them. After a phone call they offered me a complimentary specialty pizza with my next order. Well, with my next order the specialty pizza comp got downgraded to a pepperoni pizza so I got charged $6.00 for the complimentary pizza and they screwed that pizza up too. Also ordered a dozen wings and 3 if them had shattered bones in them...nothing more enjoyable than eating wings contaminated with bone fragments and marrow. Never again
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Patti Schaff
Took a chance on ordering delivery from this place as I had a delicious slice prior. I ordered a large thin crust pizza with two sides of sauce which are almost $1 a piece . Order was delivered without the sauces , and pizza was extremely greasy …I called to inquire about the sauces and was only offered to come get them or receive a credit for my next order . I explained I may not order again in the future and was made to speak to 5 different employees none of whom cared . I was told a refund was not available to my card and they would reach out to district manager . Very disappointed!
I called because I had a coupon for a free cheese pizza with my next purchase when I went to click on redeem it instantly went to expired. I called they said I didn’t have anything rewards. Foods great 100% will order from them again it just made me activated the wouldn’t honor it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Kevin Markman
Good doughy pizza and lots of kids working to get the pizza out on time. Good wings.
Craig Ross
The pizza is really great, would drive from Canandaigua just to get this pizza. I just learned it's in Geneva too, so that's a bonus!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Isaac
First time trying them today. Got a sheet pizza, and was very pleased. Sauce is fantastic. Great pie!
Food is great but they mess up every time the cheese isn't even on the entire pizza and forget about messaging corporate as they don't contact u back
Food: 4
Service: 3
We have had zero problems with Caraglio’s in Victor. Food is always good and on time. We welcome them to the area!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, thought we’d try it for the first time. The dough was extremely thick and too soft on the bottom. Pepperoni was really greasy. The worst part was biting into a slice and there was a hair in it! Gross!! Will never, ever order from there again!!!! Do better!
I had great wings and chicken fingers with fries and plus the people were very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Slice was half crust and they had a 2 slice & 1 drink combo for 9$ got charged 14$ asked her about it she said you have to get it on a box.
Excellent pizza. Best in the area. Wont go anywhere else
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wish I had a picture of the sheet pizza I ordered for the Bill's game.. I love cariglios pizza. I've been going to them for a few years now and they never dissapoint!! I've been telling everyone in my family to give them a shot and you'll see. Why I enjoy them so much!! Now they have a location in Victor! Which is sweet! My brother orders from them and my sister orderfeom them from East Rochester. They all agree that they are worth the money and what they offer for deals!! I'm happy to see them expanding. I used to go out to 104 to grab pizza. Now they are a lot closer to me I'm Canandaigua.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to like it, wanted to give it a shot. Tasteless sauce, banana peppers that were as mild as green peppers, and the main fault, cheap cheese. Folks this is not real mozzarella, it’s blended with oils in production and tasteless. There is a conscious decision to use inferior products, and they made it. I want to support local, but never again here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Truly wish Pontillos was still occupying this location. I've made the mistake of ordering from Caraglio's twice, with both orders ending in disappointment. The 1st order they forgot some toppings on my pizza, but sure didn't forget to charge for them. After a phone call they offered me a complimentary specialty pizza with my next order. Well, with my next order the specialty pizza comp got downgraded to a pepperoni pizza so I got charged $6.00 for the complimentary pizza and they screwed that pizza up too. Also ordered a dozen wings and 3 if them had shattered bones in them...nothing more enjoyable than eating wings contaminated with bone fragments and marrow. Never again
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Took a chance on ordering delivery from this place as I had a delicious slice prior. I ordered a large thin crust pizza with two sides of sauce which are almost $1 a piece . Order was delivered without the sauces , and pizza was extremely greasy …I called to inquire about the sauces and was only offered to come get them or receive a credit for my next order . I explained I may not order again in the future and was made to speak to 5 different employees none of whom cared . I was told a refund was not available to my card and they would reach out to district manager . Very disappointed!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
I called because I had a coupon for a free cheese pizza with my next purchase when I went to click on redeem it instantly went to expired. I called they said I didn’t have anything rewards. Foods great 100% will order from them again it just made me activated the wouldn’t honor it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Good doughy pizza and lots of kids working to get the pizza out on time. Good wings.
The pizza is really great, would drive from Canandaigua just to get this pizza. I just learned it's in Geneva too, so that's a bonus!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying them today. Got a sheet pizza, and was very pleased. Sauce is fantastic. Great pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza
Loading...