Pizza Fenice

304 Fifth Ave, Pelham
(914) 633-3332

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Detroit Roni and Pepperoni Ricotta and Hot Honey Slice
Grilled Chicken with Spinach Sandwich
Grandma’S with Spicy Vodka Sauce
Party Roll Spinach & Mozzarella
Detroit Roni and Regular Slice
Sunday Sausage & Peppers Pizza
Sausage and Peppers Sandwich
Caramel Apple Dessert Pizza
The Every Pizza Place Salad
It Takes Two Pizza

Menu

Sandwiches
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Eggplant Parm Sandwich
Sausage Cutlet Parm Sandwich
butterflied link sausage, breaded & fried
Smash Ball Cutlet Parm Sandwhich
Smashed Meatball breaded and fried
Meatball Parm Sandwich
Eggplant Ball Parm Sandwich
Sausage and Peppers Sandwich
Grilled Chicken with Spinach Sandwich

Breads
Garlic Bread
covered with seasoned roasted garlic brown butter
Garlic Bread with Cheese
covered with seasoned roasted garlic brown butter
Mozzarella Bread
toasted with melted Fresh Mozzarella topped with Sicilian Olive Oil, Sea salt and black pepper
Honey Bacon Bread
Crispy Applewood smoked bacon sautéed with onions and glazed with Mike's Hot Honey and topped with melted Jack Cheddar

Balls
Arancini
(Rice Balls) Cheesy Saffron Rice and rich Meat sauce with peas
Homemade Meatballs
topped with rich tomato sauce and ricotta cheese
Eggplant Balls
Delicious Eggplant "meatballs", made w/roasted eggplant

Sticks
Garlic Sticks
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Sticks
Cap-N-Crunch coated chicken tenders

Detroit Style Pizzas
Detroit Red
Classic Cheese Topped with rich tomato sauce Grated cheese and Basil
Green Machine
Classic Cheese topped with HomeMade Pesto Sauce and grated Romano & Reggiano cheese
Bandiera
A tribute to the Italian flag, stripes of tomato , pesto and creamy provolone cheese sauce with Fresh Mozzarella
The Spin Dip
Our take on spinach & artichoke dip, with mozzarella cheese & grated Romano
The Carbonara
Crispy guanciale with fresh mozzarella and topped with fresh made carbonara sauce and grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese
Pulled Pig & Pickle
12 hr pulled pork with mozzarella and jack cheddar, topped with kosher deli dill pickles and BBQ sauce
Eggplant Caprese
Breaded Eggplant cutlet layered with sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, fresh basil & drizzled with balsamic glaze
It Takes Two
2 types of pepperoni ( Shredded and sliced ), topped with your choice of tomato , pesto or provolone sauce

Traditional Pizza|14"
14" Margherita
14" Marinara
14" NY Cheese
14" NJ Tomato
14" White Pizza
14" Olio e Alice

Traditional Pizza|14"|16"
16" Margherita
16" Marinara
16" NY Cheese
16" NJ Tomato
16" White Pizza
16" Olio e Alice
Grandma's Pan Pizza
Sicilian Pizza

Not So Traditional Pizzas|14"
14" The Angry Drunk Bird
14" The Meathead
14" Sunday Sausage & Peppers
14" Eggplant Capo
14" Fenice Fire
14" Vodka Roni

Not So Traditional Pizzas|14"|16"
16" The Angry Drunk Bird
16" The Meathead
16" Sunday Sausage & Peppers
16" Eggplant Capo
16" Fenice Fire
16" Vodka Roni

Party Rolls
Chicken Parm Party Roll
Eggplant Parm Party Roll
Meatball Parm Party Roll
Pulled BBQ Pork and Cheddar Party Roll
Pastrami & Mozzarella Party Roll
Broccoli & Mozzarella Party Roll
Spinach & Mozzarella Party Roll
Stefano Stromboli Party Roll
Ham, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mozz & American Cheese
Italian Combo Stromboli Party Roll
Genoa Salami, Capicola, Soppressata, Mortadella
Roni Stromboli Party Roll
Shredded Pepperoni with Mozzarella cheese

Salads
The "Every Pizza Place Salad"
Spring Mix with Grape Tomatoes, Green Olives, Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Carrot, Roasted Peppers and Pepperoncini.

Beverages
Partanna Soda
Bottle Snapple
20 oz Soda
Pepsi Nitro

Sweet Things
Pizza Fritte
Dessert Pizza

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+11 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+10 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Small and friendly space. I happened to come on a specialty pizza day. I really enjoyed the Detroit chicken parm pizza. My first Detroit pizza and it didn't disappoint. My husband had another specialty pizza.
The problem, we don't know when they will be making those again.
August 2025
Hands down!!! I have tried many great pizzas in New York, including Lombardi's, Joe's, LTD, and Ceres, but this one beats them all! So happy to pass by this place, and if you love homemade meatballs at their best, get the meathead pizza! It's fantastic! Thank you, can't wait to be back!!
August 2025
Exceptional!! John is a Master Pizzaiolo and his team who create masterful creations for consumption. Each bite is amazing no matter what you have. The wealth of his knowledge and his hospitality is wonderful!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pelville Pastry - 300 Fifth Ave
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Bakery, Coffee Shops, Coffee
Depot Dave Catering - 232 Fifth Ave
Caterers
Renaissance Bagel Cafe and Deli - 309 Fifth Ave

Pizza Fenice

304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803
(914) 633-3332