Oysters were incredible and I enjoyed the fried trio with fries. Very good people here and a wondeful spot if you are looking to buy fresh seafood or have a quick bite.
Ellen Kaspar
Stopped in with my son to get the special of a cold lobster roll with fries or chips for the discounted price of $20. Apparently the discount is for online orders, but they honored the price for our in-person visit. The lobster rolls were freshly prepared (not premade) and served with lettuce on a particularly tasty, decent-sized bun. But the lobster salad did not fill up the roll; it was maybe half full. There were only two good-sized red chunks in each roll recognizable as lobster meat. The majority was white, finely minced pieces. Very heavy on chopped celery and onion, in a mayonnaise base. My son is not fond of celery. He expected SOME, but this had an excessive amount. He removed a good amount of the celery/onion mixture and was left with a VERY small amount of filling in the bun. We both enjoyed the flavor, and the lobster itself seemed fresh and well prepared. There just was not enough of it. We agreed it was a decent meal for $20, but would've been disappointed if it were the full price of $30. My son thought the fries were particularly good. I asked for them to be well done, and they did honor that request, as well as honoring the discount, all with professionalism and a smile. All in all, pretty good, but NOT generous AT ALL with the lobster meat.
Donna Capone
Everything is fresh and delicious! We live in Huntington and come to eat here. We love the town and neighborhood.. the whole experience is great
marc lubin
Great source for fresh seafood
ecw 4 life
My parents and I always go here whenever we pass by. The food is absolutely delicious 10/10
ann garamella
Fresh seafood and delicious fried seafood
Andreiю Sirenkoз
We visited this place nearly ten times this summer for lunches on our ways from or to the beaches. Oysters are always excellent, lobsters are fresh and juicy, soft shell crabs are tasty. There is always enough outside seating. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Next summer we will be there again!
Michele E
Cute little fish market with reasonable prices. They also prepare fresh food too. We shared the fried fluke po boy and it was very tasty. The French fries were very soft and and not crunchy, which we prefer but still good.
Would buy fresh fish and prepared foods here again.
Ma Piedal
Was googling for seafood restaurant in the area and found this gem with almost 5 star rating. We went and we’re glad we did. Food is so fresh and yummy! We had the lobster roll and shrimp salad on roll. Fries are so good! No need to come to Maine! So many options in the menu to choose from, which we plan to try each every time we come back!
Monica O'K
Delicious. - everything. And great fishermen to help you choose!!!!!!
Every time I go there, everything is fresh clean super nice. The food is excellent. Service is great. Keep up the good work.
Sven Ebinger
After trying lobster rolls all summer across Long Island, Blue Water Fish Market took the crown! Instead of the usual roll, they serve it on a perfectly toasted baguette, and honestly, it was a great choice. The baguette added a delightful crunch and held up beautifully against the generous chunks of fresh lobster. The lobster itself was tender and flavorful, not drowned in mayo, just the right balance of creamy and fresh. If you’re looking for the best lobster roll on Long Island, this place is a must-try!
Kosta Rica
A small fish shop with limited choices but very fresh and high quality. They offer a catch of the day options (it was Black Sea bass this time). One can try a delicious soft shell crab and sea scallops cooked right off the oven. Plenty of free parking across the street. Nice!
Don Hughes
Terrific fish market and restaurant food was tremendous and the softshellcrab and chef blacks sea bass special was perfect
Jacqueline T Hughes
Our first trip to Long Island and we happen on to Blue Water Fish Market and ordered the chef special of black Seabass. I ordered it baked with rice and vegetables. My first bite was like biting into a cloud from another dimension. It was heavenly. Thank you, Chef! Enough said. It was spectacular.
Oysters were incredible and I enjoyed the fried trio with fries. Very good people here and a wondeful spot if you are looking to buy fresh seafood or have a quick bite.
Stopped in with my son to get the special of a cold lobster roll with fries or chips for the discounted price of $20. Apparently the discount is for online orders, but they honored the price for our in-person visit. The lobster rolls were freshly prepared (not premade) and served with lettuce on a particularly tasty, decent-sized bun. But the lobster salad did not fill up the roll; it was maybe half full. There were only two good-sized red chunks in each roll recognizable as lobster meat. The majority was white, finely minced pieces. Very heavy on chopped celery and onion, in a mayonnaise base. My son is not fond of celery. He expected SOME, but this had an excessive amount. He removed a good amount of the celery/onion mixture and was left with a VERY small amount of filling in the bun. We both enjoyed the flavor, and the lobster itself seemed fresh and well prepared. There just was not enough of it. We agreed it was a decent meal for $20, but would've been disappointed if it were the full price of $30. My son thought the fries were particularly good. I asked for them to be well done, and they did honor that request, as well as honoring the discount, all with professionalism and a smile. All in all, pretty good, but NOT generous AT ALL with the lobster meat.
Everything is fresh and delicious! We live in Huntington and come to eat here. We love the town and neighborhood.. the whole experience is great
Great source for fresh seafood
My parents and I always go here whenever we pass by. The food is absolutely delicious 10/10
Fresh seafood and delicious fried seafood
We visited this place nearly ten times this summer for lunches on our ways from or to the beaches. Oysters are always excellent, lobsters are fresh and juicy, soft shell crabs are tasty. There is always enough outside seating. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Next summer we will be there again!
Cute little fish market with reasonable prices. They also prepare fresh food too. We shared the fried fluke po boy and it was very tasty. The French fries were very soft and and not crunchy, which we prefer but still good.
Would buy fresh fish and prepared foods here again.
Was googling for seafood restaurant in the area and found this gem with almost 5 star rating. We went and we’re glad we did. Food is so fresh and yummy! We had the lobster roll and shrimp salad on roll. Fries are so good! No need to come to Maine! So many options in the menu to choose from, which we plan to try each every time we come back!
Delicious. - everything. And great fishermen to help you choose!!!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Every time I go there, everything is fresh clean super nice. The food is excellent. Service is great. Keep up the good work.
After trying lobster rolls all summer across Long Island, Blue Water Fish Market took the crown! Instead of the usual roll, they serve it on a perfectly toasted baguette, and honestly, it was a great choice. The baguette added a delightful crunch and held up beautifully against the generous chunks of fresh lobster. The lobster itself was tender and flavorful, not drowned in mayo, just the right balance of creamy and fresh. If you’re looking for the best lobster roll on Long Island, this place is a must-try!
A small fish shop with limited choices but very fresh and high quality. They offer a catch of the day options (it was Black Sea bass this time). One can try a delicious soft shell crab and sea scallops cooked right off the oven. Plenty of free parking across the street. Nice!
Terrific fish market and restaurant food was tremendous and the softshellcrab and chef blacks sea bass special was perfect
Our first trip to Long Island and we happen on to Blue Water Fish Market and ordered the chef special of black Seabass. I ordered it baked with rice and vegetables. My first bite was like biting into a cloud from another dimension. It was heavenly. Thank you, Chef!
Enough said. It was spectacular.
Loading...