Pulcinella on the Green

141 Fairway Dr, Wading River
(631) 886-1896

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dena L Lopez

Food was delicious. Our waiter Dilan was excellent. We will definitely be back again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Pulcinella

B P

Lunch date with my wife that was absolutely terrible. We don't get out much and decided to try this place. I tried to reach out before leaving a Google review but never got a call back. I informed the waiter that I had a shellfish allergy. We ordered an octopus appetizer which isn't a shellfish. I took a bite of octopus which was really fishy and not fresh and noticed there was calamari mixed in. I instantly felt itchy in my throat. When the waiter finally came back to check on us we told him what happened. Instead of apologizing he told us that's what we had ordered. We should have left right away but we were both hungry. I drank a lot of water and was feeling a little better so we stayed. My wife's entrée was overcooked and super spicy. I ordered the stuffed veal chop which was a special. This was the most disgusting meal I have ever been served. There was an inch of grease on the plate. I took one bite and couldn't go any further. I'm a blue collar guy and have never sent food back that's how bad it was. I had to go find the waiter who was watching TV by the bar to tell him. He only took off my meal on the bill. We payed over 100$ dollars for a terrible experience. Certainly wouldn't recommend this place.

Linda Aguanno

We have always had a great experience here. However we came for Christmas Eve and it was below par including two seafood dishes tasting like a soap dish. We said something and they didn’t even care. My opinion of this restaurant has unfortunately changed.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Marina Kaya

An offense to Italian cuisine. They put sugar into their salad so it tastes like ice cream. I’ve asked a pasta for my baby with a small amount of butter and I’ve gotten a butter soup with some pasta swimming in it. My husband god chicken with tomatoes that also contain sugar. My pasta was so creamy I couldn’t eat even a quarter of it. Fries was the only thing that was good and all of these disappointment costed us $190.

If an Italian person have had been here they would spit them in the face.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nazım Kaya

Very pricey for below average quality. The salad was too sweet to eat. Chicken and pasta were too greasy. Very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Brooklyn

Experience is okay, food okay but overpriced! Clam appetizer is great along with bread. They are overpriced but food good no real ambiance.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Peterson

Surprise Birthday party 🥳

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Baby Rack Lamb Chops, Chicken Parmigiana

LuigiM

The ambience and beauty of the restaurant and grounds was unbelievable. Food and service was excellent. The pasta was delicious and portions were generous. The meal was amazing and can't wait to go back again.

Mark

We had reservations in the restaurant but were seated in the bar. Seemed to be a number of catering events going on. Need to give it another shot. Atmosphere in line with country clubhouses.

Suzanne

Love the food and service, but the noise level was very high until we asked to move us to the bar area. A table of 4 should not be positioned between 2 tables of 6 . Most people may not ask to move their table, they may have just left. Good job by staff and manager. Highly recommend!

Jim DeBois

The food was very good, however the service was just ok. Be prepared to open your wallet, as this restaurant is pricey.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Susan

We loved everything about this restaurant. The food and the service were excellent. The only negative is it is very loud and hard to hear people speaking at your table. Will definitely come back.

Kevin Block

Food was honestly pretty bad. I think most resturants have ok food but all 4 of us actually stopped eating half way through. Maybe because it was the tail end of the night? Do not get the zucchini flowers. A comically small portion for what you pay for and it was nothing special. The chicken pulcinella was okay but was soggy from the balsamic. The eggplant pasta was just not good. We all tasted it and said yea no way. The best thing on the menu was their fries / chips. For $10 you get a great portion of spicy potato chips. We loved them. Just wish there was less juice on the plate.

Service was pretty good. Sometimes they'd forget to fill someone's water at the table but nothing horrible. Waiter was awesome. Environment looked amazing. Just the food was flat out bad. Probably won't go back. Other people looked to be having a blast so may have just been our choices.

Parking: Tons of parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Linda

This is a favorite for family celebrations. The servers are friendly and we always feel welcome. We often order the specials. This time we had a few hiccups—the risotto was underdone, and one pasta dish was nearly raw. I know it's hard to plate and serve bone entrees, so we understood—but for the price, we expect a little more. We will return and see!

Jennifer

Ordered 2 of the specials, waiter never said anything about size of meals. 1 plate was huge and for 3 people, so ordered way too much food. 75 dollars per plate, food was just ok. Appetizer did not taste right, hope ricotta did not go bad. Waiters and staff were rude, wont be back.

Loading...