Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Only Salvatore’s I go to! Not that the other ones are terrible but the people working at this location are just top tier. Never had a bad experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food, good service multiple tvs for sports

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Extremely terrible service!! Walworth location….

Just ordered and the entire order was incorrect. Then I was told that we never ordered breadsticks but the “new” person taking the order didn’t put that in the first time. The. I said since we are now inconvenienced maybe throw the breadsticks on for free. He said no you need to pay. On top of the $70 we already ordered and was WRONG!! Then he said (manager) he’s not making anything else for us call the Macedon location next time and hung up on me. Very rude, very inconvenient, crap food, crap service!!! Never again!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

It is a five star. But I would prefer you didn't eat here. This is my place. Salvatores baby I have been eating here since the 70s.

Love the food the over and hour wait for a sheet pizza that shows up luke warm im not a fan of. It'd be more understandable if I wasn't able to order the same thing from thier competitor across the rd (marks) and get my food actually hot. Kinda disappointed in the lack of ability to deliver hot food as a pizza joint. Foods always good but it'd be alot better hot not barely warm

Worst pizza I ever got from Salvatores. Not what I expect from a business that has so much competition.

Great pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent food & service! Very good daily specials.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped by for a couple of slices with a coworker, cashier tells me we ordered a large after we cash out separately. Lastly the pizza tasted like some of the ingredients were freezer burned!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

I enjoy all of their pizza, they have their own specific specials that are genuine to themselves that are absolutely delicious . The staff is very friendly and the location is very convenient and easy to get to being right off 31 in Walworth. If you want good pizza I recommend trying it here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have been ordering from salvatores for several years. Up until lately I have not had a bad experience. However the last few times we've ordered from them, the food has been subpar. The quality of the food does not justify the prices. And to top it all off they regularly forget items we have ordered. Today we spent $70 on an order just to realize that they yet again forgotten our drinks. My wife's food was cold, and some of my food was over cooked. I called them not to complain about the quality of the food(perhaps they have a new employee they are training), not to complain about the prices(its a small business and the cost of everything is up), but to simply ask to bring us our drinks. This is something that should have been simple. (Send another driver or the manger) I wasn't asking for a refund at first. But then they told me that I had to wait an hour.

Now I have been in the auto service industry for a number of years. I understand that things are forgotten from time to time. (A set wipers on a particularly long or difficult repair was the most common) you get busy things go awry, the phone rings, 3 people in the back are are asking questions. I get it. But when things get forgotten, you make it right IMMEDIATELY! You don't make the customer wait. Often times it's a lot of little things that drive people away.

My issue should have been addressed immediately. I know it sounds petty. But the fact that they didn't seem to care tells me that the employees no longer prioritize their customers.

Customer service in any industry is key. Customer service determines whether or not you will have repeat business

Poor customer service means you will only have one time customers. And it means long time customer will stop coming.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Yum yum - great old school pizza 🍕😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Love ❤️

I'm only giving a 4 since this was a take out order. I tried to order online on their website but it was more challenging so I ended up calling.
I ordered Thin Thin crust Pineapple and Ham pizza it was good but half of the crust edges were burnt. The large pizza was good too but it had too much sauce for my taster, however, other people who ate it liked it that way. The sausage topping was tasty as well. The order was ready to pick up in 25 minutes.

Parking: Plenty of parking available on the lot when I was there.

Wheelchair accessibility: The establishment was accessible by wheelchair.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

They tried to squeeze every nickel and dime out of ya for a slice of pizza. It's basically one slicy cut in here and charge it almost for what the medium pizza should be. I don't even want to know what their medium pieces are prices. But I would say mediocre pizza

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4