Love love love the pickles! My friends had a breakfast sandwich and said they were delicious
Marilyn Holmes
Spectacular pot pies. The crust….oh my gosh, so flaky and buttery and savory. I dream about that crust now. The filling was so thick and rich with lots of big tender chicken chunks. I don’t even normally like pot pies but these have changed my mind. I will only ever get them here though! We ordered pies for all our Thanksgiving guests. It was the perfect all in one feast, requiring no side dishes and no work and no clean up! Best Thanksgiving ever! We also ordered the deviled eggs which were a huge hit, and apple pies which were perfect and homemade. I will always think to J Gallup for Thanksgiving from now on! It made hosting a zero stress event. I’m so grateful to the ladies for their tremendous amount of work making these homemade dishes. Everything was ready to go, exactly right, on Wednesday for pickup. I could not be more thrilled with the entire experience. Many, many thanks!!!!!!
Dana K
Amazing breakfast sandwiches! And while you’re there check out their fresh baked goods and frozen meals to stock your fridge at home!
Dan Bleier
Such a great variety of home made style foods!
Lisa Senatore
Best pickles
Christy Collins
This is a small local bakery that offers not only baked goods but also homemade soups, appetizers, and entrees, which are frozen. They also have fresh breakfast sandwiches. I have had all of these and definitely no complaints. Their food and baked goods are incredibly delicious. Helpful and friendly workers add to their charm. I highly recommend this wonderful little business.
Tim
Be careful! You’ll end up walking out with more than you expected. There’s so many homemade fresh goodies to choose from. I’m eating the pickles right now and they are delicious. Love this place and the very friendly staff.
Edward Gerry
Not cheap ... but nice to visit
Tammy Beaudin
Best pickles ever!
Corinne M.
I can't say enough about this amazing find. My family and I vacation in Wells, NY every year and always make it a point to stop at J Gallup Farms while in the area...sometimes two or three times before we leave. We've tried everything from the pies, to breads, pickles (absolute favorite!!), dips, chicken pot pies....and my second personal favorite, the blueberry buckle! If you find yourself passing through this small town, or staying in or outside of Warrensburg, do yourself a favor...stop in and buy EVERYTHING! You will not be disappointed!
Excellent small family-run shop selling baked goods, frozen meals and soups, produce, etc. We bought an apple pie and small sweet bread loaves (applesauce and zucchini.) Everything was great. Will buy their blueberry pie and try some of their frozen soups very soon. This is the seller who used to sell from the front porch of a house near Oscar's Smokehouse. They moved to a storefront, next door to The Pizza Shop. I highly recommend this shop's home-baked products. The owner/cook/clerk (?) was making apple crumb caramel pies the other day. When I asked about a blueberry pie, she said they'd be coming out of the oven later in the day! The apple pie I bought was great and I'm looking forward to trying the blueberry pie.
Tim G
Be careful! You’ll end up walking out with more than you expected. There’s so many homemade fresh goodies to choose from. I’m eating the pickles right now and they are delicious. Love this place and the very friendly staff.
Rich Schmitt
Excellent small family-run shop selling baked goods, frozen meals and soups, produce, etc. We tried their apple pie, applesauce and zucchini small bread loaves. All three were great. Will buy their blueberry pie and some soup very soon.This is the seller who sold from the front porch of a house near Oscar's Smokehouse. Now they are next door to The Pizza Shop.
Victory Blessings
They soups are unbelievable Great! Mushrooms & clamchowder was amazing. Made a great dinner fir us with fried fresh zucchini I got from her& eggs with toast. Awesome, friendly lady. Will be buying more when am in area, also to travel back with. 5 star restaurant frozen soup. She need open a soup cafe.
Irene Baldwin
I passed by this place so many times going to Oscar's. Finally stopped in and now shop there regularly. Like the pies and especially like the chicken pot pie.
Love love love the pickles! My friends had a breakfast sandwich and said they were delicious
Spectacular pot pies. The crust….oh my gosh, so flaky and buttery and savory. I dream about that crust now. The filling was so thick and rich with lots of big tender chicken chunks. I don’t even normally like pot pies but these have changed my mind. I will only ever get them here though! We ordered pies for all our Thanksgiving guests. It was the perfect all in one feast, requiring no side dishes and no work and no clean up! Best Thanksgiving ever! We also ordered the deviled eggs which were a huge hit, and apple pies which were perfect and homemade. I will always think to J Gallup for Thanksgiving from now on! It made hosting a zero stress event. I’m so grateful to the ladies for their tremendous amount of work making these homemade dishes. Everything was ready to go, exactly right, on Wednesday for pickup. I could not be more thrilled with the entire experience. Many, many thanks!!!!!!
Amazing breakfast sandwiches! And while you’re there check out their fresh baked goods and frozen meals to stock your fridge at home!
Such a great variety of home made style foods!
Best pickles
This is a small local bakery that offers not only baked goods but also homemade soups, appetizers, and entrees, which are frozen. They also have fresh breakfast sandwiches. I have had all of these and definitely no complaints. Their food and baked goods are incredibly delicious. Helpful and friendly workers add to their charm. I highly recommend this wonderful little business.
Be careful! You’ll end up walking out with more than you expected. There’s so many homemade fresh goodies to choose from. I’m eating the pickles right now and they are delicious. Love this place and the very friendly staff.
Not cheap ... but nice to visit
Best pickles ever!
I can't say enough about this amazing find. My family and I vacation in Wells, NY every year and always make it a point to stop at J Gallup Farms while in the area...sometimes two or three times before we leave. We've tried everything from the pies, to breads, pickles (absolute favorite!!), dips, chicken pot pies....and my second personal favorite, the blueberry buckle! If you find yourself passing through this small town, or staying in or outside of Warrensburg, do yourself a favor...stop in and buy EVERYTHING! You will not be disappointed!
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent small family-run shop selling baked goods, frozen meals and soups, produce, etc. We bought an apple pie and small sweet bread loaves (applesauce and zucchini.) Everything was great. Will buy their blueberry pie and try some of their frozen soups very soon. This is the seller who used to sell from the front porch of a house near Oscar's Smokehouse. They moved to a storefront, next door to The Pizza Shop. I highly recommend this shop's home-baked products. The owner/cook/clerk (?) was making apple crumb caramel pies the other day. When I asked about a blueberry pie, she said they'd be coming out of the oven later in the day! The apple pie I bought was great and I'm looking forward to trying the blueberry pie.
Be careful! You’ll end up walking out with more than you expected. There’s so many homemade fresh goodies to choose from. I’m eating the pickles right now and they are delicious. Love this place and the very friendly staff.
Excellent small family-run shop selling baked goods, frozen meals and soups, produce, etc. We tried their apple pie, applesauce and zucchini small bread loaves. All three were great. Will buy their blueberry pie and some soup very soon.This is the seller who sold from the front porch of a house near Oscar's Smokehouse. Now they are next door to The Pizza Shop.
They soups are unbelievable Great! Mushrooms & clamchowder was amazing. Made a great dinner fir us with fried fresh zucchini I got from her& eggs with toast. Awesome, friendly lady. Will be buying more when am in area, also to travel back with. 5 star restaurant frozen soup. She need open a soup cafe.
I passed by this place so many times going to Oscar's. Finally stopped in and now shop there regularly. Like the pies and especially like the chicken pot pie.