Pizza was alright tasting. Put good amount of toppings on. Garlic bread with cheese had an off flavor, not good. Both my fiance and I had upset stomachs shortly after we ate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza
Andrew Wilson
Great NY style pizza. Highly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza
Dan Ioven
This was a great stop on our way back to Philadelphia. We highly recommend it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Shelli O.
One of our favorite places to go to when we visit! The pizza has the absolute best crust. The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The ambiance is meh.... But who cares the pizza is grubbing!! We'll be back next time we visit.
Ricky Davis Sr.
Without question low value...Nothing on the order is ever right.typical Warsaw Ny Garbage..Dont waste your money..Eating 7-11 food is a better
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Oblitus Angelus
So tried this place for the first time. Pretty good pizza. Definitely a nice NY style pizza. Picked up a large cheese. Nice dough. Not too chewy. Good amount of cheese. Sauce was a bit bland but nothing some garlic powde didn't fix. Only complaint is the guy working there could cheer up a bit,didn't seem too happy. Maybe a bad night idk. Anyhow I'd definitely come back and try them again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
P B.
In town for a wedding an ordered baked ziti with eggplant parmigiana. The eggplant was very tender and tasty. Ziti was cooked al dente and had a lot of cheese. All in all a delicious meal.
Marsha Bouslimi
This is 2nd time we visited1st time, we loved the foodThis time, pizza crust burnt, spinach was wet and floppy on the pizza, the chicken wing pizza had the gristle end pieces on the pizza,On all pizzas, sauce was nearly non-existent, and the cheese just fell off even though we let it cool for about 20 minutesWe won't be returning for a third try.
Being from downstate NY, I’m always on the hunt for authentic NY style pizza in the WNY region. Stefano’s came through! Solid crust, super cheesy, and a perfectly tart, subtle sauce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mircea
Very delicious pizza. One of the best pizza around. Delicious, right size, good food service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Smith
Their fried foods are good, fried pickles are hit or miss if you get the coins or the fries, NY style-ish pizza is hit or miss if you actually get a big fluffy crust when you're craving that NY thin crust pizza. Also as writing this ordered deep dish and pan pizza. They have two separate options for deep dish and pan pizza, so i was kinda afraid being in NYS and ordering a deep dish that this would be the case. Gave them the benefit of the doubt, was hopeful when they said it would be an hour to make, However it was simply a pan pizza. Also Delivery always seems to be an hour and a half even at 2PM on a Tuesday they quoted an hour and a half. 4PM on a Friday, hour and a half. Bottom line, they are reliable for fried foods thats about it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Matt D.
Unreliable for quality, ordering a regular pizza can be a good quality NY style crust it could be big fluffy crust as seems to be the norm around here. They have pan pizza and deep dish options but don't get your hopes up if you are from the midwest, the deep dish is just a pan pizza, it is in no way a chicago style deep dish. Chicken wings are iffy as well as sometimes nice and saucy, and sometimes drier than the Sahara. Mozz. sticks are reliable and other fried foods, fried pickles can be coins or fries, thats iffy. For their prices you'd think they could at least have consistent foods. They are fairly pricey as well.
Michael S.
Pizza's not bad probably the best in town now.wings need to be cooked more and when i got wing I wasn't given blue cheese . darn good think i paid for extra. if your looking for pizza in warsaw. this is probably the place to go.
Raw chicken finger sub ?
Food: 1
Best pizza in Warsaw, hands down.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was alright tasting. Put good amount of toppings on. Garlic bread with cheese had an off flavor, not good. Both my fiance and I had upset stomachs shortly after we ate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza
Great NY style pizza. Highly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: NY Style Pizza
This was a great stop on our way back to Philadelphia. We highly recommend it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
One of our favorite places to go to when we visit! The pizza has the absolute best crust. The people that work there are always friendly and helpful. The ambiance is meh.... But who cares the pizza is grubbing!! We'll be back next time we visit.
Without question low value...Nothing on the order is ever right.typical Warsaw Ny Garbage..Dont waste your money..Eating 7-11 food is a better
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
So tried this place for the first time. Pretty good pizza. Definitely a nice NY style pizza. Picked up a large cheese. Nice dough. Not too chewy. Good amount of cheese. Sauce was a bit bland but nothing some garlic powde didn't fix. Only complaint is the guy working there could cheer up a bit,didn't seem too happy. Maybe a bad night idk. Anyhow I'd definitely come back and try them again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
In town for a wedding an ordered baked ziti with eggplant parmigiana. The eggplant was very tender and tasty. Ziti was cooked al dente and had a lot of cheese. All in all a delicious meal.
This is 2nd time we visited1st time, we loved the foodThis time, pizza crust burnt, spinach was wet and floppy on the pizza, the chicken wing pizza had the gristle end pieces on the pizza,On all pizzas, sauce was nearly non-existent, and the cheese just fell off even though we let it cool for about 20 minutesWe won't be returning for a third try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Being from downstate NY, I’m always on the hunt for authentic NY style pizza in the WNY region. Stefano’s came through! Solid crust, super cheesy, and a perfectly tart, subtle sauce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very delicious pizza. One of the best pizza around. Delicious, right size, good food service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their fried foods are good, fried pickles are hit or miss if you get the coins or the fries, NY style-ish pizza is hit or miss if you actually get a big fluffy crust when you're craving that NY thin crust pizza. Also as writing this ordered deep dish and pan pizza. They have two separate options for deep dish and pan pizza, so i was kinda afraid being in NYS and ordering a deep dish that this would be the case. Gave them the benefit of the doubt, was hopeful when they said it would be an hour to make, However it was simply a pan pizza. Also Delivery always seems to be an hour and a half even at 2PM on a Tuesday they quoted an hour and a half. 4PM on a Friday, hour and a half. Bottom line, they are reliable for fried foods thats about it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Unreliable for quality, ordering a regular pizza can be a good quality NY style crust it could be big fluffy crust as seems to be the norm around here. They have pan pizza and deep dish options but don't get your hopes up if you are from the midwest, the deep dish is just a pan pizza, it is in no way a chicago style deep dish. Chicken wings are iffy as well as sometimes nice and saucy, and sometimes drier than the Sahara. Mozz. sticks are reliable and other fried foods, fried pickles can be coins or fries, thats iffy. For their prices you'd think they could at least have consistent foods. They are fairly pricey as well.
Pizza's not bad probably the best in town now.wings need to be cooked more and when i got wing I wasn't given blue cheese . darn good think i paid for extra. if your looking for pizza in warsaw. this is probably the place to go.